Re Camilleri, Colin Michael James Ex Parte Maguire, Michael

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF VICTORIA           No VN 238 of 1996

Re:       COLIN MICHAEL JAMES CAMILLERI

Judgment Debtor

Ex Parte:        MICHAEL MAGUIRE
  Judgment Creditor

Coram:    Olney J

Place:    Melbourne

Date:     8 May 1996

MINUTE OF ORDERS

The Court is not satisfied that the judgment debtor has such a set-off, counter-claim or cross demand as is referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 and orders that:

  1. The judgment debtor pay the judgment creditor's costs of this proceeding.

  2. In the event that a sequestration order is made against the estate of the judgment debtor based on an act of bankruptcy committed by him as a result of his failure to comply with the demand contained in the bankruptcy notice herein, the costs referred to in paragraph 1 of this order be deemed to be costs in the administration of the bankruptcy.

NOTE:     Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in rule 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
GENERAL DIVISION
BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF VICTORIA           No VN 238 of 1996

Re:       COLIN MICHAEL JAMES CAMILLERI

Judgment Debtor

Ex Parte:        MICHAEL MAGUIRE
  Judgment Creditor

Coram:    Olney J

Place:    Melbourne

Date:     8 May 1996

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
THE PROCEEDING
On 22 November 1991 the judgment debtor and another issued proceedings in the Magistrates' Court at Melbourne in which they claimed damages against 5 defendants including the judgment creditor.   On 21 December 1992, after a 2 day hearing, the Magistrate upheld a submission made on behalf of the judgment creditor that there was no case for him to answer and dismissed the claim against him.   At the same time the judgment debtor was ordered to pay the judgment creditor $2,306 for costs.

On 12 February 1996 the judgment creditor caused to be issued a bankruptcy notice which required the judgment debtor within 14 days of service to make one of the responses required pursuant to the prescribed form of notice. The demand in the bankruptcy notice relates to the order for costs made on 21 December 1992. The notice was served on 25 February 1996. On 12 March 1996 the judgment debtor filed an affidavit pursuant to s 41 (7) of the Bankruptcy Act in which he asserted that he had a set-off against the judgment creditor in the sum of $200,000 which he could not set up in the proceeding in which the judgment debt was obtained. (By reason of the intervention of a weekend followed by a public holiday the affidavit was filed within the period required by s 41(7)).

Although the judgment debtor has specifically referred to a set-off in his affidavit, I understand his claim to be a reference to a "set-off, counter-claim or cross demand" as those terms are used in s 40(1)(g) and s 41(7) of the Bankruptcy Act.   The term "set-off" in its conventional meaning is obviously inappropriate in the present context.

The question of whether the Court is satisfied that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Camilleri, Colin Michael James Ex Parte Maguire, Michael and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] FCA 328
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia, in the General Division, Bankruptcy District of Victoria, heard the case of Re Camilleri, Colin Michael James Ex Parte Maguire, Michael. The judgment debtor, Colin Michael James Camilleri, was ordered to pay the judgment creditor, Michael Maguire, costs of $2,306 from a previous proceeding. Mr. Maguire issued a bankruptcy notice demanding payment, which Mr. Camilleri sought to contest by claiming a set-off, counter-claim, or cross-demand against Mr. Maguire in the amount of $200,000. The Court needed to determine whether Mr. Camilleri's claim could be considered a set-off, counter-claim, or cross-demand as referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966, and whether it could be set up in response to the bankruptcy notice.

The Court examined the nature of the claim Mr. Camilleri made against Mr. Maguire, which was a part of a larger proceeding in the County Court of Victoria, where Mr. Camilleri and his wife claimed damages against three defendants, including Mr. Maguire. The claim was based on alleged misrepresentations made by Mr. Maguire during negotiations for a share purchase agreement. The Court found that Mr. Camilleri's claim was a joint claim against multiple defendants, and could not be set up as a set-off, counter-claim, or cross-demand against Mr. Maguire alone. The Court also noted that the claim could not have been set up in the original proceeding where the judgment debt was obtained, as Mr. Maguire had not made a claim against Mr. Camilleri in that proceeding.

Based on its findings, the Court concluded that Mr. Camilleri did not have a set-off, counter-claim, or cross-demand of the nature referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act. Consequently, the Court ordered Mr. Camilleri to pay Mr. Maguire's costs of the proceeding. In the event of a sequestration order being made against Mr. Camilleri's estate based on his failure to comply with the demand in the bankruptcy notice, the costs would be deemed to be costs in the administration of the bankruptcy.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 21 December 1992, the Magistrates' Court at Melbourne dismissed a claim made by Colin Michael James Camilleri and another against five defendants, including Michael Maguire. The judgment debtor was ordered to pay Michael Maguire $2,306 for costs. On 12 February 1996, Michael Maguire issued a bankruptcy notice to Colin Michael James Camilleri demanding payment of the aforementioned costs. Colin Michael James Camilleri responded by filing an affidavit on 12 March 1996, asserting that he had a set-off, counter-claim, or cross demand against Michael Maguire in the sum of $200,000, which he could not set up in the proceeding in which the judgment debt was obtained. Colin Michael James Camilleri and his wife are plaintiffs in a proceeding in the County Court of Victoria in which they claim $200,000 for damages against three defendants, including Michael Maguire. The County Court proceeding is based on an allegation that Informed Sources Ltd engaged in conduct in contravention of the Fair Trading Act 1985 (Vic), resulting in loss or damage to the plaintiffs.

On 17 April 1996, the matter came before the Federal Court of Australia, General Division, Bankruptcy District of Victoria, where judgment was reserved. The court was required to determine whether Colin Michael James Camilleri had a set-off, counter-claim, or cross demand of the nature referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. The case was heard on 17 April 1996, and judgment was delivered on 8 May 1996.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the Court satisfied that the judgment debtor has such a set-off, counter-claim, or cross demand as is referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966?
2. Could the cross-claim be set up in the proceeding in which the judgment was obtained?
3. Is the claim against Michael Maguire a joint claim with other defendants, and if so, what are the implications for the cross-demand?

Held
1. The Court is not satisfied that the judgment debtor has such a set-off, counter-claim, or cross demand as is referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. The Court ordered the judgment debtor to pay the judgment creditor's costs of this proceeding.
2. The cross-claim could not have been set up in the proceeding in which the judgment debt was obtained.
3. The claim against Michael Maguire is a joint claim with other defendants, and this has implications for the cross-demand, which is insufficient to satisfy s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined whether the judgment debtor had a set-off, counter-claim, or cross demand as referenced in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966. The judgment debtor claimed a $200,000 set-off against the judgment creditor, alleging misrepresentations made during negotiations for a share purchase agreement. However, the court determined that the judgment debtor's claim was not a personal claim against the judgment creditor but rather a joint claim against multiple defendants, including the judgment creditor.

The court noted that the cross demand could not have been set up in the proceeding where the judgment was obtained, as the judgment creditor made no claim in that proceeding against which the judgment debtor could set up the cross demand. The relevant proceeding for the purposes of s 40(1)(g) was the judgment creditor's application for a costs order against the judgment debtor following the dismissal of the claim. This aligns with the decision in Chesson v Smith and related cases.

Additionally, the court considered the implications of the judgment debtor's claim being a joint claim with other defendants, as established in re Brown and re Wedd; Ex parte Parker. These cases established that a judgment creditor should not be compelled to hold their hand while their debtor prosecutes a claim against them and someone else. The court found that the principle in re Brown applied and was fatal to the judgment debtor's case.

The court concluded that the judgment debtor did not have a set-off, counter-claim, or cross demand of the nature referred to in s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act, and therefore ordered the judgment debtor to pay the judgment creditor's costs of the proceeding. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a cross-claim against a judgment creditor cannot be set up if the claim is a joint claim with other defendants, and the debtor cannot satisfy s 40(1)(g) of the Bankruptcy Act under such circumstances.