Re Buggy, M.F. & Anor v Ex parte Morton

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

Re: MICHAEL FRANCIS BUGGY and LEONIE FRANCES BUGGY
Ex parte: ROBERT WILLIAM MORTON
And: CANOONA PTY LIMITED; RONALD DAVID SILVERSTEIN and RONALD EDWARD EGGERT
Nos. A B67 and 68 of 1990
FED No. 293
Contempt of Court

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
GENERAL DIVISION
Neaves J.(1)
CATCHWORDS

Contempt of Court - Interference with course of justice - Bankruptcy proceedings pending at suit of the trustee in bankruptcy - Telephone call to trustee by bankrupt - Whether words used amounted to a contempt.

HEARING

CANBERRA

#DATE 31:5:1991

Counsel for the trustee : Mr J.K. Chippindall

Solicitors for the trustee : Higgins

Counsel for Michael Francis Buggy : Mr W.L. Donald

Solicitors for Michael Francis Buggy : Macphillamy Donald and Co.

ORDER

The Court declares that Michael Francis Buggy is guilty of contempt of court in that on 3 May 1991 in the course of a telephone conversation with Robert William Morton, the trustee of his bankrupt estate, he made statements which were calculated or had a tendency to interfere with the course of justice in connection with certain proceedings then pending in this Court numbered AB 67/90 and AB 68/90 in which the said Robert William Morton as such trustee and as trustee of the bankrupt estate of Leonie Frances Buggy was the applicant and the said Michael Francis Buggy was a respondent.

Orders that in respect of the said contempt Michael Francis Buggy pay a fine of $750.

Orders that the amount of the said fine be paid to the District Registrar of this Court at Canberra in the Australian Capital Territory within 21 days from the date of this order.

Orders that Michael Francis Buggy pay the costs of Robert William Morton of and incidental to the application filed herein on 6 May 1991.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in rule 124 of the Bankruptcy Rules.

JUDGE1

This is an application by Robert William Morton to have Michael Francis Buggy committed for contempt of court in relation to proceedings pending before this Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

  1. By force of s.55(4A) of the Bankruptcy Act and by virtue of the presentation of a debtor's petition against himself, Michael Francis Buggy became a bankrupt on 29 May 1990. Robert William Morton became, and remains, the trustee of Mr Buggy's bankrupt estate. On 30 May 1990, Mr Buggy's wife, Leonie Frances Buggy, became a bankrupt by virtue of the presentation of a debtor's petition against herself. Mr Morton became, and remains, the trustee of her bankrupt estate. On 12 September 1990, an order was made by the Court under s.53(1) of the Bankruptcy Act consolidating the proceedings in relation to the two bankrupt estates.

  2. At the time of the alleged contempt, a proceeding was pending before this Court at the suit of Mr Morton, as trustee of the consolidated estates, in which he was seeking certain declarations and orders in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Buggy, M.F. & Anor v Ex parte Morton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1991] FCA 293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re Buggy, M.F. & Anor v Ex parte Morton involved the question of whether Michael Francis Buggy had committed contempt of court by making statements that interfered with the course of justice during a telephone conversation with Robert William Morton, the trustee of Buggy's bankrupt estate. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with the proceedings numbered AB 67/90 and AB 68/90, involving bankruptcy applications. The court was tasked with determining whether Buggy's words during a conversation on 3 May 1991 constituted contempt, specifically whether they were calculated or had a tendency to interfere with the pending bankruptcy proceedings.

The central legal issue before the court was whether Buggy's statements during the phone call to Morton amounted to contempt of court. The court considered the nature of the statements made by Buggy and their potential impact on the ongoing bankruptcy proceedings. The court had to ascertain whether the words used by Buggy were indeed intended to, or had the effect of, interfering with the judicial process. This involved examining the context of the conversation and the specific words used, as well as the principles of contempt of court and the interference with the course of justice.

The court found that Buggy was guilty of contempt of court. It concluded that Buggy's statements made during the telephone conversation on 3 May 1991 were calculated or had a tendency to interfere with the course of justice in the bankruptcy proceedings. The court noted that Buggy's words were directed at Morton, the trustee, and had the potential to influence the proceedings. Consequently, the court imposed a fine of $750 on Buggy and ordered him to pay the costs of the application filed by Morton on 6 May 1991. The fine was to be paid to the District Registrar of the Court at Canberra within 21 days of the order. The orders were made in accordance with rule 124 of the Bankruptcy Rules.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Court declares that Michael Francis Buggy is guilty of contempt of court in that on 3 May 1991 in the course of a telephone conversation with Robert William Morton, the trustee of his bankrupt estate, he made statements which were calculated or had a tendency to interfere with the course of justice in connection with certain proceedings then pending in this Court numbered AB 67/90 and AB 68/90 in which the said Robert William Morton as such trustee and as trustee of the bankrupt estate of Leonie Frances Buggy was the applicant and the said Michael Francis Buggy was a respondent.

Orders that in respect of the said contempt Michael Francis Buggy pay a fine of $750.

Orders that the amount of the said fine be paid to the District Registrar of this Court at Canberra in the Australian Capital Territory within 21 days from the date of this order.

Orders that Michael Francis Buggy pay the costs of Robert William Morton of and incidental to the application filed herein on 6 May 1991.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in rule 124 of the Bankruptcy Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Michael Francis Buggy was a bankrupt and the subject of bankruptcy proceedings numbered AB 67/90 and AB 68/90. The trustee in bankruptcy, Robert William Morton, was conducting the proceedings. On 3 May 1991, Buggy made a telephone call to Morton in his capacity as trustee. During the conversation, Buggy made statements which were alleged to be calculated or to have a tendency to interfere with the course of justice in the bankruptcy proceedings. The conduct in question arose out of these proceedings and the allegations against Buggy centred on the content of the telephone conversation with Morton.

This case came before the Court in the form of an application by the trustee in bankruptcy, Robert William Morton, seeking a declaration of contempt against Michael Francis Buggy. The application was filed on 6 May 1991, following the telephone conversation in question on 3 May 1991. The Court heard the matter and made its decision, finding Buggy guilty of contempt of court. The Court issued orders declaring Buggy's guilt, imposing a fine of $750 to be paid within 21 days, and requiring Buggy to pay the costs of the application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the words used by Michael Francis Buggy during a telephone conversation with Robert William Morton on 3 May 1991 amounted to a contempt of court.
2. If so, what orders the Court should make in respect of the contempt.

Held
1. The Court held that the words used by Michael Francis Buggy during a telephone conversation with Robert William Morton on 3 May 1991 amounted to a contempt of court.
2. The Court ordered that Michael Francis Buggy pay a fine of $750 in respect of the contempt, to be paid within 21 days. Additionally, Buggy was ordered to pay the costs of Robert William Morton associated with the application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered whether the statements made by Michael Francis Buggy during a telephone conversation with Robert William Morton, the trustee of Buggy's bankrupt estate, amounted to a contempt of court. The Court found that Buggy's statements, made during bankruptcy proceedings numbered AB 67/90 and AB 68/90, were calculated or had a tendency to interfere with the course of justice. This interference was deemed significant enough to constitute contempt of court. The Court relied on the principle that any action that threatens the integrity of court proceedings can be considered contempt, particularly when it pertains to bankruptcy proceedings where the trustee's role is critical to the fair administration of justice. The Court referenced relevant legal authorities that support the notion of contempt in similar contexts, ensuring that the ruling aligns with established legal precedents. The binding principle established by this decision is that statements made with the intention to interfere with the course of justice, especially in the context of bankruptcy proceedings, are contempt of court. The Court's ruling did not depart from but rather reinforced prior authority on the matter of contempt in relation to court proceedings.