Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2007] AATA 2099
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No W200600092
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF EMPLOYMENT AND WORKPLACE RELATIONS Applicant
And
STEPHEN BRENTNALL
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Ms L R Tovey, Member Date 21 December 2007
PlacePerth
Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal made on 22 February 2006 and substitutes a decision that the decision of the Applicant, to raise and recover overpayments of disability support pension of $2,111.08 for the period 6 February 2003 to 25 June 2003, is affirmed. ….....(Sgd. L R Tovey)...............
Member
11. On 30 March 2006 the Applicant sought a review of the SSAT's decision by this Tribunal.
ISSUES AND LEGISLATION
12. It is not in dispute that the Respondent was entitled to receive disability support pension during the relevant period.
13. Disability support pension is provided for by Part 2.3 of the Social Security Act 1991 (Cth) ("the Act"). Section 117 of the Act provides that a person's disability support pension rate is to be worked out using Benefit Rate Calculator A at the end of s 1064 of the Act. The rates provided for in that section vary according to whether or not the person is a "member of a couple" or "partnered", with a higher rate being paid to a person who is not a member of a couple. The income of both members of a couple is taken into account in determining that rate.
14. Subsections 4(2) and 4(3) of the Act define when a person is a member of a couple in the following terms:
"4(2) Subject to subsection (3), a person is a member of a couple for the purposes of this Act if:
(a) the person is legally married to another person and is not, in the Secretary’s opinion (formed as mentioned in subsection (3)), living separately and apart from the other person on a permanent or indefinite basis; or
(b) all of the following conditions are met:
(i) the person has a relationship with a person of the opposite sex (in this paragraph called the partner);
(ii) the person is not legally married to the partner;
(iii) the relationship between the person and the partner is, in the Secretary’s opinion (formed as mentioned in subsections (3) and (3A)), a marriage-like relationship;
(iv)both the person and the partner are over the age of consent applicable in the State or Territory in which they live;
(v)the person and the partner are not within a prohibited relationship for the purposes of section 23B of the Marriage Act 1961.
Member of a couple—criteria for forming opinion about relationship
4(3) In forming an opinion about the relationship between 2 people for the purposes of paragraph (2)(a) or subparagraph (2)(b)(iii), the Secretary is to have regard to all the circumstances of the relationship including, in particular, the following matters:
(a) the financial aspects of the relationship, including:
(i) any joint ownership of real estate…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Brentnall; and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] AATA 2099
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to determine whether the Respondent was living in a de facto relationship with the Applicant, as this would have impacted her eligibility for the disability support pension. The court considered the nature of the relationship between the parties, the duration of the relationship, and whether the parties were living together in a shared domestic environment. The court also examined the evidence provided by both parties and the findings made by the Social Security Appeals Tribunal.
After carefully considering the evidence and the arguments presented by both parties, the court found that the Respondent was indeed living in a de facto relationship with the Applicant during the relevant period. The court determined that the relationship between the parties met the criteria for a de facto relationship under the Social Security Act. As a result, the court set aside the decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal and substituted a decision that affirmed the Applicant's decision to recover overpayments of disability support pension. The court concluded that the Respondent was not eligible for the disability support pension during the relevant period due to her de facto relationship with the Applicant.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Social Security Appeals Tribunal made on 22 February 2006 and substitutes a decision that the decision of the Applicant, to raise and recover overpayments of disability support pension of $2,111.08 for the period 6 February 2003 to 25 June 2003, is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
This overpayment was contested by the Respondent, who appealed the decision to the Social Security Appeals Tribunal (SSAT). The SSAT upheld the Applicant's decision to recover the overpayment. Dissatisfied with the SSAT's decision, the Respondent further appealed to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which was tasked with reviewing the SSAT's decision.
The matter was first heard at the SSAT, where the original decision to recover the overpayment was upheld. Following this, the Respondent appealed the SSAT's decision to the AAT. The AAT was presented with the task of reviewing the SSAT's decision to ensure it was legally sound and based on proper consideration of the evidence and applicable law. The AAT's role was to determine whether the SSAT had erred in law or made a decision that was unreasonable.
In the appeal to the AAT, the Respondent argued against the SSAT's decision, potentially raising issues about the evidence used to determine the existence of the marriage-like relationship and its impact on DSP eligibility. The AAT reviewed the case, taking into account the evidence and arguments presented by both parties, before making its determination.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the SSAT erred in law or made a decision that was unreasonable in affirming the Applicant's decision to recover overpayments of disability support pension.
2. Whether the evidence sufficiently established that the Respondent was living in a marriage-like relationship during the relevant period, thereby affecting DSP eligibility.
3. Whether the AAT had the jurisdiction to review the SSAT's decision and, if so, whether it was appropriate for the AAT to substitute its decision for that of the SSAT.
Held
1. The court held that the SSAT did not err in law or make a decision that was unreasonable in affirming the Applicant's decision to recover overpayments of disability support pension. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the SSAT's decision and affirmed the Applicant's decision to recover the overpayments.
2. The court found that the evidence was insufficient to establish that the Respondent was living in a marriage-like relationship during the relevant period, thereby not affecting DSP eligibility.
3. The court determined that the AAT had jurisdiction to review the SSAT's decision and found it appropriate for the AAT to substitute its decision for that of the SSAT.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the decision of the SSAT affirming the Applicant's recovery of overpayments of disability support pension. The court considered whether the SSAT's decision was legally sound and reasonable. It found no error in the SSAT's affirmation of the Applicant's decision, leading to the Tribunal's decision to set aside the SSAT's decision and affirm the Applicant's decision to recover the overpayments.
Regarding the second issue, the court assessed the evidence presented to determine if the Respondent was living in a marriage-like relationship during the relevant period. The evidence provided was deemed insufficient to establish such a relationship, thereby not impacting the DSP eligibility.
The court further deliberated on the AAT's jurisdiction to review the SSAT's decision. It found that the AAT had the necessary jurisdiction and considered it appropriate to substitute its decision for that of the SSAT. This led to the Tribunal setting aside the SSAT's decision and substituting its own, affirming the Applicant's decision to recover the overpayments. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by this decision pertains to the appropriate circumstances under which the AAT may exercise its jurisdiction to review and substitute the decision of the SSAT in cases concerning the recovery of overpayments of disability support pension.