Re Braceros and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 145

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2000/165

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      Emma Jane Braceros     
  Applicant
           And    Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs      
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal        The Hon. RNJ Purvis, QC, Deputy President  

Date 27 February  2001

Place Sydney

Decision       The decision under review is affirmed.

[sgn]J Purvis , QC
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
Immigration – Class BC Subclass 100 Spouse Migrant Visa – falsified passport and visa – worked illegally – overstayed visa – false identity – failure to disclose information relevant to application for protection visa – provision of false baptismal certificate; provision of false answers in application – whether recent good conduct or rehabilitation – character test – protection of the Australian Community – expectations of the Australian Community – other considerations
Migration Act 1958

REASONS FOR DECISION

the application       

  1. This is an application made by Emma Jane BRACEROS ("the Sponsor") seeking review of a decision of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs ("the Respondent") under date 15 December 1999, refusing a Class BC Subclass 100 Spouse (Migrant) Visa in respect of her husband Salvador BERNABE ("the Visa Applicant").

  2. In the reasons for the refusal decision the Delegate of the Respondent stated

    "The Applicant travelled to Australia on a Visitor Visa on 24/10/1990, using a falsified passport and visa after having been refused a visitor visa previously. Whilst in Australia he worked illegally and overstayed his visa. He departed on 19/8/1994 under the supervision of Compliance Officers. Upon his return to the Philippines in August 1996, he lodged the current application for spouse Migration on the basis of his marriage to an Australian citizen. For the current spouse application the baptismal certificate he submitted has been assessed as a false document…I find that the level and duration of the fraudulent behaviour is not outweighed by the short duration since the last of his actions nor the compassionate grounds associated with his marriage to Ms Braceros"
    The Applicant has for a lengthy period consistently dealt untruthfully with the Department in a system that requires and in fact depends on a person to be open and honest so that a proper assessment may be made.
    In view of his past and present conduct and taking account of all of his circumstances, I do not elect to exercise my discretion to grant a visa to the Applicant in this case."  (T1, P7)

  1. In her application the Sponsor stated as the reason for seeking review of the decision of 15 December 1999:

    "The DIMA made an error in not considering all the relevant facts in refusing my husbands application for a Spouse Visa."       (T1)

The hearing            

  1. At the hearing of this application the Sponsor was represented by Mr Edgar Aquino of F & M International Consulting Group and the Respondent by Miss Quayle, a departmental representative.

  2. There was tendered in evidence the documents lodged by the Respondent pursuant to Section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 marked T1 to T39,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Braceros and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural A... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 145
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Braceros and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, the parties involved were the Visa Applicant, a jeweller by occupation, and the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs. The dispute centered around the Visa Applicant's fraudulent application for a Spouse Migrant Visa, which included using a falsified passport and visa, working illegally, and providing false documentation to support his application. The case was heard by the Tribunal, which was required to determine whether the Visa Applicant met the character test and if there were any other considerations that warranted the exercise of discretion in his favor.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether the Visa Applicant was a victim of circumstances or if he could avoid responsibility for his false application for refugee status. The Tribunal also needed to assess whether the Visa Applicant had demonstrated recent good conduct or rehabilitation and if there were any mitigating factors that would warrant a different outcome. The Tribunal found that the Visa Applicant had not been truthful or prepared to be frank and truthful in his evidence, and his actions demonstrated a clear disregard for Australia's Immigration Laws.

The Tribunal concluded that the Visa Applicant did not pass the character test and that his conduct represented a serious breach of the law. The Tribunal found that the Visa Applicant's actions, including entering Australia on a false passport and visa, working illegally, and providing false documentation, warranted the exercise of discretion in favor of refusing his Spouse Visa Application. The Tribunal accepted the submissions made on behalf of the Respondent and found that there were no relevant mitigating factors. The Tribunal was satisfied that the conduct of the Visa Applicant was serious and warranted the refusal of his application.

The final orders of the Tribunal were to affirm the decision under review, which was the refusal of the Visa Applicant's Spouse Visa Application. The Tribunal found that the Visa Applicant had not demonstrated recent good conduct or rehabilitation and that his actions warranted the exercise of discretion in favor of refusing his application. The Tribunal also found that the Visa Applicant's conduct represented a serious breach of the law and that there were no relevant mitigating factors. The Tribunal concluded that the Visa Applicant did not pass the character test and that his actions warranted the refusal of his application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Visa Applicant is a jeweller by occupation and no doubt if his application should be granted would be able to obtain employment as such in Australia. submissions and decision It was submitted on behalf of the Visa Applicant that he had been "a victim of circumstances". It was recognised and accepted that his refugee application had not been true but blame was sought to be placed on "the conduct of the agent". The Tribunal is not satisfied that the Visa Applicant was such a victim or that he can avoid responsibility for his false application for refugee status. Nor is the Tribunal satisfied that there was any confusion in the mind of the Visa Applicant, as was submitted on his behalf, during the course of his cross-examination. He, on a number of occasions claimed an inability to remember relevant details, leading the Tribunal to conclude that he was not prepared to be frank and truthful in the evidence that he gave. On his behalf it was said, that he would "keep trying to come to Australia, not use illegal acts, just use the law as it is". He is entitled to "use the law" but not to act contrary to it or endeavour to use it in an improper way. The Tribunal is not satisfied that the Visa Applicant accepts that what he did was wrong and was contrary to the law. This reflects adversely upon his character. The Tribunal is not satisfied that there has been a change in attitude of the Visa Applicant or in this sense that he has reformed. It is true to say that he has not come under the notice of the police since returning to the Philippines but it is apparent that in the context of the present application and interviews with authorities in Manila he has sought to avoid the consequences of his conduct. It is true to say that the effect of an adverse finding upon the Applicant would be distressing for her. However, she entered the marriage with full knowledge of the circumstances. On behalf of the Respondent it is submitted that the Visa Applicant is an untruthful person. The Tribunal is inclined to the view that the Visa Applicant was not being truthful in his evidence in the aspects earlier mentioned. His alleged inability to remember is not accepted as being truthful. The Visa Applicant knew when he arrived in Australia that he was travelling on false documents. He knew that his refugee application was false. His sole purpose in coming to Australia was to obtain employment and to illegally remain here. As has already been stated, the Tribunal finds the Visa Applicant to not be of good character and does not consider that the primary and other considerations relevant to the exercise of its discretion are such as to warrant it being exercised in his favour in. Accordingly the decision under review is affirmed

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is noted that in assessing the compassionate claims of an Australian partner, decision makers are to consider the circumstances under which the relationship was established and whether the Australian partner knew that the non-citizen was of character concern at the time of entering into or establishing the relationship.acts relied on as being in breach of migration legislation It is apparent from the evidence placed before the Tribunal that the Visa Applicant has in general terms committed the following acts contrary to migration legislation: The aspects in which the Visa Applicant has disregarded or acted in breach of Australia's Immigration Law have been detailed earlier in these reasons. Amongst the more significant are the following. The Visa Applicant : Taking into account all of the circumstances relevant in this matter, including the hesitancy displayed by the Visa Applicant in answering questions put to him during the course of his cross examination as to the identity of the provider of the passport, the place where contact took place as well as the many occasions during his evidence when he claimed an inability to recall various events, the Tribunal is satisfied that he has not demonstrated recent good conduct or rehabilitation. The conduct of the Visa Applicant demonstrates a clear disregard for Australia's Immigration Laws and a willingness to deceive and make false statements in aid of obtaining a desired end. He does not pass the character test.Protection of australian community Seriousness and nature of conduct It was submitted on behalf of the Respondent that by entering Australia on a false passport and visa, in deliberately making false statements in relation to his marital status, working illegally for cash in hand and tendering a false birth certificate in support of his Spouse Visa Application, the Visa Applicant committed offences for which he might be prosecuted pursuant to section 234 of the Act. It was further submitted that his conduct regarding immigration fraud represented a serious offence under the Act and a disregard of Australia's Immigration Laws which warrants the exercise of the discretion in favour of refusing his Spouse Visa Application. There are said to be no relevant mitigating factors. The Tribunal is satisfied that the conduct of the Visa Applicant was as submitted on behalf of the Respondent. To enter Australia under the guise of a false passport, visa and employment documentation well knowing that the material was obtained as a result of payment of a relatively large sum of money, this for the purpose of remaining in Australia illegally, together with the obtaining of employment and being paid in cash, all represent acts constituting serious breaches of the law. The deceit and lack of truthfullness associated with his refugee application further evidences the seriousness of the conduct of the Visa Applicant. The Tribunal accepts the relevance and weight warranted to be given to the submissions made on behalf of the Respondent. likelihood conduct may be repeated