Re Bachmann, C. v Ex parte Doran, E

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

.

-

.

.

CATCHWORDS

Bankruptcy - creditors petition - debtor able but unwilling to pay

debts - whether sequestration ought to be made

- costs.

.

Bankruptcy Act 1966 ss.40(l)(d)(i), 52(2)

Re: CLENENS BACHMANN EX parte: ETHEL DORAN

No. P. 360 of 1987

Sweeney J.

Sydney

3 JUIY, 1987

I

i

..

, I

t

l -

! '

I

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GENERAL DIVISION

No. P. 368 of 1987

BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

AND THE

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

!

RE :

CLEMENS

BACHMANN

EX PARTE: ETHEL

DORAN

I

THE COURT: Sweeney J.

PLACE : Sydney

DATE

: 3 July, 1987

MINUTES OF ORDER

THE COURT ORDERS

THAT:

1.

The petition be dismissed.

I.'

2.

Debtor to pay petitioning creditor's costs of and incidental to petition up to 17 June 1987 when the debtor's affidavit

was served on the

petitioning

creditor

and

that

he

petitioning creditor pay the

debtor's costs of and incidental

to the petition thereafter.

Note:

Settlement and entry of orders

is dealt with

in Order

36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL

COURT OF AUSTRALIA

)

)

DIVISION

GENERAL

1

1

BANKRUPTCY DISTRICT OF THE STATE

)

1

OF NEW SOUTH WALES AND

THE

1

1

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

)

.

RE

:

CLEMENS B A C H W N

EX PARTE: ETHEL

DORAN

THE COURT: Sweeney J.

PLACE : Sydney

: 3 July, 1987

-

DATE

EX TEliIPORE JUDGMENT

This is a creditor's petition by Ethel

Doran, the creditor,

against

Clemens

Bachmann,

the

debtor,

in

which

the

creditor

alleged that the debtor

was just and truly indebted to her in the

sum of $16,839.65, being the amount due under the final judgments

recovered in the District Court at Sydney on the 31st day of May

1982, together with interest thereon at 10 per cent per annum on

reducing balances from time to time and costs taxed pursuant to

such

judgment,

the

consideration

for

such

debt

being

wages,

overtime and holiday pay due to the creditor for work done for the

debtor.

The act of bankruptcy alleged in the petition

was that the

debtor within six months before the presentation of the petition

committed the following

act of bankruptcy, namely that

on 5

-

2

Itembe

r

1986

execution having been issu

ed against him under

process of

the District Court of New South

wales certain of his

5

property, namely yellow Falcon station sedan number MDM-407,

was

held by the sheriff for

21 days.

The act of bankruptcy alleged is said to be within the berms

of section 40(1) (d)

(i) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 which I shall

call the Act, which reads as follows:

"A debtor commits an act of bankruptcy

in each of

the following cases

-

...

...

(d) if -

(i) execution has been issued aginst him under process of a court and any of

his property has,

in consequence,

either been sold by the sheriff

or

held by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Bachmann, C. v Ex parte Doran, E and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] FCA 496
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Bachmann, C. v Ex parte Doran, E, the creditor, Ethel Doran, filed a petition against Clemens Bachmann, the debtor, alleging that the debtor owed her the sum of $16,839.65 plus interest and costs. The basis of the petition was an act of bankruptcy, where the debtor's property was held by the sheriff for 21 days following the issuance of an execution against him. The debtor opposed the petition, claiming that he was solvent and able to pay his debts, relying on the precedent set in Re Sarina ex parte Wollondilly Shire Council.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the debtor could be declared bankrupt despite his ability to pay his debts, given his refusal to do so. The court had to determine whether the discretionary power under section 52(2) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 should be exercised to dismiss the petition in light of the debtor's solvency.

Justice Sweeney found that the debtor had discharged the onus of proving his solvency and ability to pay his debts. The court concluded that the discretionary power should be exercised in favour of the debtor and dismissed the petition. The court also ordered that the debtor pay the petitioning creditor's costs up to 17 June 1987, when the debtor's affidavit was served, and that the petitioning creditor pay the debtor's costs thereafter. This ruling was consistent with the precedent set in Sarina, where a similar order for costs was made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established