Re Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders Labourers Federation

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA-- INDUSTRIAL DIVISION

-

- .

.

re Australian Building Construction

mployees and'

Builders Labourers Federation

N.S.W.

Nos. 16 & 28 of 19-

CATCHWORDS

Conciliation & Arbitration Act, 1904, s.159 et seq.

- election inquiries - vagueness and uncertainty of

resolution - test to be

applied - endorsement of

resolution - effect of adoption of minutes and

reports -

Nomination posted

before closing tlme but received

later - invalid

coram J.B. Sweeney J.

23 January, 1978

.

.p

..

c

. -

f

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

,'.NSW

NOS. 16 & 28 of 19;

INDUSTRIAL DIVISION

1

IN THE MATTER of inquiries into an

election for offices in the Australian

~~

Building construction mployees and

Builders Labourers Federation, an

organisation of employees registered

under the Conciliatlon and Arbitration

Act. 1904

23 JANUARY, 1978

Sh'EENEY

J.B.

J.

._

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

m e s e are two inquiries into elections held in the Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders Labourers Federation ("the Federation"). The

elections are those for the offices of General Secretary

and for Trustee and Federal Vice-President. In each

case application was made to the Registrar pursuant to

s.159 of the Act who, being satisfied as required under

9.160. referred the matters to the Court. Mr. Enderby Q.C.

and m. Manser appeared for the three applicants and Mr.

Ryan for the Federation and for each of

the successful

candidates.

.

The first application is by Mr. B.V. RiX.

It

appears that Mr. Rix lodged on 7 July, 1977 a nomination for the position of General Secretary which admittedly

was in time.

The Returning Officer did not reject this

nomination and clearly the appropriate steps under

regulation 146AE(ii) were not taken.

. p

- 2 -

.

.-

. -

. L

It is now

sulmitted that *he nomination was

not valid because, at the time of

nomination, Mr. Rix

and his two nominators were

not financial members.

Their financial standing

depends on questions

arising

as to a levy purported to be

imposed in November, 1974.

.

A second nomination was lodged by Rix for the

same office on 8 m l y , 1977.

This nomination was rejected

.by the Returning

Officer on the ground that it was not

iodged within time. It

is now further submitted that

the nomination was

invalid because Rix and the two

nom-

inators were not financial members of

the Federation.

Regulation 146AE(ii) was

obeyed in dealing with this

nomination in respect of the first ground but not the

second.

The second inquiry is one sought jointly by

Mr. Reginald Mason and Mr.

Noel Olive who nominated for

the positions of

Trustee and Federal vice-president

respectively. Their nominations were forwarded on

8 July, 1977 and it is submitted that they were not received in time. It is further submitted that the nominations were invalid because each nominator and

>

each of the persons

nominated was unfinancial within

the Federation by reason of the date of payment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1978] FCA 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia, Industrial Division, was called upon to address two inquiries regarding the validity of elections held within the Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders Labourers Federation, concerning the offices of General Secretary and for Trustee and Federal Vice-President. The applicants, including Mr. B.V. Rix, Mr. Reginald Mason, and Mr. Noel Olive, challenged the legitimacy of their nominations and the subsequent election process, arguing that irregularities, including the timing of nominations and the financial status of the applicants, rendered the elections invalid. The court was tasked with determining the validity of the levies imposed on the members, the endorsement process of the Federal Council's decisions by the branches, and whether the nominations were received in time.

The court first examined the financial status of the applicants, focusing on the validity of a levy imposed in November 1974. It concluded that while the Federal Council had the authority to impose the levy, the resolution was not effectively endorsed by the majority of branches as required. The levy, therefore, was not valid, and the applicants were financial members at the time of nomination. The court then turned to the timeliness of the nominations. Despite the nominations being posted before the closing time, they were not received in time due to postal system inefficiencies. Consequently, the nominations of Mr. Olive, Mr. Mason, and Mr. Rix's second nomination were deemed out of time.

Based on these findings, the court determined that the elections were void due to the irregularities in the nomination process and the invalid levy. It proposed declaring the election of Mr. Gallagher void and directing the Industrial Registrar to arrange for a new election or take steps to hold an election from the receipt of the nominations. The court also considered the possibility of taking action regarding the levy but decided to adjourn the hearing to allow for further submissions on the appropriate orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established