Re Agricultural Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  No. 8 of 1995

[Re Agricultural Services Pty Ltd]

IN THE MATTER of THE CORPORATIONS LAW

- and -

IN THE MATTER of AGRICULTURAL SERVICES PTY LTD A.C.N. 052 412 281

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 22/05/1996

CATCHWORDS      APPLICATION to wind up - application for leave to apply to set aside out of time - Cavetina Pty Ltd v. Synthetic Dyeworks Industries Pty Ltd appld. -wh genuine dispute - solvency of company - wh Stamps Act requires stamping of agreement relied on in statutory demand - costs.

Counsel:Mr T North for applicant/creditor.

Mr H Fraser QC for respondent/company

With him Mr G Newton.

Solicitors:Gadens Ridgeway for applicant/creditor.

Russell and Company for respondent/company.

Hearing date:    9 February 1995

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND

Brisbane  No. 8 of 1995

IN THE MATTER of THE CORPORATIONS LAW

- and -

IN THE MATTER of AGRICULTURAL SERVICES PTY LTD A.C.N. 052 412 281

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - WHITE J

Judgment delivered 22/05/1996

The applicant, Rural Finance Pty Ltd ("Rural") seeks an order that Agricultural Services Pty Ltd ("Agricultural Services") be wound up and a liquidator appointed.  Messrs Phillip Arthur Hennessey and Michael Joseph Dwyer, the receivers and managers of Rural appointed by Equus Financial Services Limited, ("Equus") served a statutory demand for the payment of $1.4 million on Agricultural Services on 11 November 1994 pursuant to a loan agreement allegedly made between Rural and Agricultural Services on 28 June 1991.
           Agricultural Services has filed five separate applications in respect of this hearing two of which are amended applications and it is those latter which  encapsulate the relief sought.  Agricultural Services seeks:

•An order extending the time within which to make this application;

•An order setting aside the statutory demand;

•Alternatively an injunction restraining the receivers and managers from further prosecuting the application to wind-up;

•Alternatively leave to oppose the application for an order for the winding-up of the company;

•That the receivers and managers pay the applicant company's costs of these applications less the costs thrown away by reason of the failure to apply within time to set aside the statutory demand.

A separate application filed on 2 February 1995 sets out the grounds upon which Agricultural Services intends to oppose the application to wind-up.  Those grounds are

•That it is not indebted to the applicant in the sum the subject of the demand or in any sum;

•Alternatively that the debt is the subject of a genuine dispute;

•Alternatively if the company was indebted pursuant to the loan agreement referred to in the demand that indebtedness has been discharged by set-off;

•Alternatively there is an offsetting claim in respect of the whole of the debt the subject of the demand;

•Alternatively the debt the subject of the demand arose in the course of an illegal scheme to defraud the Commissioner of Taxation in which the applicant/creditor knowingly participated;

•Alternatively the loan agreement not having been duly stamped is unenforceable pursuant to s.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Agricultural Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] QSC 86
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Agricultural Services Pty Ltd and Rural Finance Pty Ltd was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The dispute arose from a statutory demand issued by Rural Finance Pty Ltd against Agricultural Services Pty Ltd, which Agricultural Services Pty Ltd failed to set aside within the prescribed period. The central issue before the court was the allocation of costs between the parties, considering the statutory demand was not contested within the time limit set by section 459G of the Corporations Law.

The court was required to determine whether the failure to set aside the statutory demand within the statutory time limit should result in the party that failed to act within the prescribed period bearing the costs of the other party. The court examined the relevant statutory provisions and case law to establish the appropriate legal principles to apply in the circumstances. It considered the objectives of the statutory scheme, which include encouraging prompt action and deterring inaction that could prejudice the rights of other parties.

The court held that Agricultural Services Pty Ltd was liable to pay Rural Finance Pty Ltd's costs thrown away as a consequence of not seeking to set aside the statutory demand within the statutory time limit. The court reasoned that the statutory scheme was designed to encourage prompt action in response to statutory demands, and a party that failed to act within the prescribed period should bear the costs of the other party's inaction. However, the court also held that the Receivers and Managers of Rural Finance Pty Ltd were to pay the costs of Agricultural Services Pty Ltd after 1 February 1995 in respect of the several applications before the court, save for the costs of the two documents being the amended applications filed by leave on 9 February 1995. The court found that the Receivers and Managers of Rural Finance Pty Ltd had acted reasonably in pursuing the statutory demand and that the costs incurred by Agricultural Services Pty Ltd after 1 February 1995 were a consequence of the Receivers and Managers' actions.

The court made orders that Agricultural Services Pty Ltd was to pay Rural Finance Pty Ltd's costs thrown away as a consequence of not seeking to set aside the statutory demand within the statutory time limit to be taxed. The Receivers and Managers of Rural Finance Pty Ltd were to pay the costs of Agricultural Services Pty Ltd after 1 February 1995 in respect of the several applications before the court to be taxed, save for the costs of the two documents being the amended applications filed by leave on 9 February 1995. Liberty was given to apply with respect to the orders as to costs on giving 2 days' notice in writing.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves Agricultural Services Pty Ltd and Rural Finance Pty Ltd. Agricultural Services Pty Ltd failed to seek to set aside a statutory demand made by Rural Finance Pty Ltd within the time limit prescribed by s. 459G of the Corporations Law. The statutory demand was issued due to an outstanding debt, leading to the enforcement proceedings. The failure to respond to the statutory demand within the specified timeframe resulted in the throwing away of costs incurred by Rural Finance Pty Ltd. After the statutory demand was not set aside, further legal proceedings were initiated, including several applications before the court. These applications pertained to the costs associated with the enforcement and the subsequent legal actions taken by both parties.

The matter came before the court following the failure of Agricultural Services Pty Ltd to respond to a statutory demand issued by Rural Finance Pty Ltd within the statutory period. The primary issue was the costs incurred due to the late response to the statutory demand. Subsequent to this, multiple applications were filed in relation to the costs of the enforcement proceedings and the subsequent legal actions taken by both parties. The applications included those filed on 9 February 1995, which were amended with leave. The court was required to determine the taxation of costs incurred by both parties in relation to the applications and the enforcement proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether Agricultural Services Pty Ltd should be ordered to pay the costs thrown away by Rural Finance Pty Ltd due to the failure to set aside the statutory demand within the specified time.
2. Whether the Receivers and Managers of Rural Finance Pty Ltd should be ordered to pay the costs incurred by Agricultural Services Pty Ltd after 1 February 1995 in relation to the several applications before the court.
3. The taxation of the costs of the two amended applications filed by leave on 9 February 1995.

Held
1. The court held that Agricultural Services Pty Ltd should be ordered to pay the costs thrown away by Rural Finance Pty Ltd due to the failure to set aside the statutory demand within the specified time.
2. The court held that the Receivers and Managers of Rural Finance Pty Ltd should be ordered to pay the costs incurred by Agricultural Services Pty Ltd after 1 February 1995 in relation to the several applications before the court.
3. The court held that the costs of the two amended applications filed by leave on 9 February 1995 are to be taxed separately.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Agricultural Services Pty Ltd to pay Rural Finance Pty Ltd's costs thrown away as a consequence of not seeking to set aside the statutory demand referred to in 1. above within the time limited by s. 459G of the Corporations Law to be taxed. The Receivers and Managers of Rural Finance Pty Ltd to pay the costs of Agricultural Services Pty Ltd after 1 February 1995 in respect of the several applications before the court to be taxed save the costs of the two documents being the amended applications filed by leave on 9 February 1995. Liberty to apply with respect to the orders as to costs on giving 2 days' notice in writing.