Re Aggett & Ors; Ex parte Australian Airlines Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

~

~ ·.;-~·~

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry

Melbourne No M76 of 1992
In the matter of -

An application for a writ of

prohibition and a writ of

certiorari against THE

HONOURABLE MICHAEL FRANCIS

MOORE, THE VICE PRESIDENT OF

THE AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL

RELATIONS COMMISSION,

THE HONOURABLE SIMON JOHN

WILLIAMS, A DEPUTY PRESIDENT

OF THE AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL

RELATIONS COMMISSION,

COMMISSIONER RUPERT GEORGE
SWEENEY and COMMISSIONER
KENNETH JOHN McDONALD,
COMMISSIONERS OF THE

AUSTRALIAN INDUSTRIAL

RELATIONS COMMISSION

First Respondents

AUSTRALIAN FEDERATION OF AIR

PILOTS

Second Respondents

RONALD WALTER AGGETT AND ORS

Third Respondents

Ex parte -

AUSTRALIAN AIRLINES LIMITED

Prosecutor

TOOHEY J

(In Chambers)

Airlines 1 10/12/92

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT CANBERRA ON THURSDAY, 10 DECEMBER 1992, AT 10.59 AM

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MR C.N. JESSUP, QC:  May it please Your Honour, I appear

with my learned friend, MR G.J. HATCHER, on behalf

of Australian Airlines Limited to seek an order

nisi for certiorari and prohibition. (instructed

by Blake Dawson Waldron)

MR J. BREWSTER: If Your Honour pleases, I seek leave to

appear for the second respondent. (instructed by

Mahony Galvin Rylah)

HIS HONOUR:  Do you want to be heard on that aspect,

Dr Jessup?

MR JESSUP: It is a matter for Your Honour. If Your Honour

thinks you would be assisted by my learned

friend - - -

HIS HONOUR: 

I think I will be, clearly, in the light of the material that has just been filed.

MR JESSUP:  Yes, Your Honour.

HIS HONOUR: Perhaps that is the first thing we should

consider, Dr Jessup, is whether or not, in view of

the material contained in the affidavit of Robert Bruce Carpenter, which I take it you have seen, the affidavit of 9 December, it is appropriate that the
matter should proceed at this stage.

MR JESSUP: 

Your Honour would want to hear from my learned friend on that.

We do not accept what is in the

affidavit, of course, but Your Honour may wish to

hear from my learned friend in that regard.

HIS HONOUR:  Yes, I think I ought to deal with that aspect

of it first.

MR JESSUP:  I profess not to be able to understand why that

affidavit might ground the kind of application

which is foreshadowed but no doubt my learned

friend will be able to assist Your Honour in that

regard.

Airlines 2 10/12/92
HIS HONOUR:  Yes, thank you. Mr Brewster. I shall hear

from you at the moment on what I would take to be

an application that the present proceedings be

adjourned.

MR BREWSTER:  Yes. I rely, Your Honour, on the affidavit of
Mr Carpenter. Does Your Honour wish me to formally
read that?
HIS HONOUR:  No, I do not.
MR JESSUP:  Your Honour. Might we just make this point,

Your Honour, that if it were contentious, we would hope Your Honour would not accept what is contained

in paragraph 2 of that affidavit as not being given

from the knowledge of the deponent.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Aggett & Ors; Ex parte Australian Airlines Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1992] HCATrans 359
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Airlines Limited sought orders for certiorari and prohibition against the Honourable Michael Francis Moore (Vice President of the Australian Industrial Relations Commission), the Honourable Simon John Williams (Deputy President), and Commissioners Rupert George Sweeney and Kenneth John McDonald. The application concerned proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission should be allowed to continue at that stage, in light of an affidavit filed by the respondents. This affidavit, it was suggested, contained assertions about statements made by Australian Airlines Limited in the Commission that were disputed by the airline.

The Court considered whether to accept the contents of the affidavit, particularly paragraph 2, as evidence. Australian Airlines Limited argued that certain assertions within that paragraph, concerning the progressive integration of pilots into Qantas including subsidiaries, were not supported by the deponent's knowledge and were contrary to their instructions. They contended that better evidence, such as a transcript, would be required to prove such sweeping statements, especially the contentious final lines of the paragraph. The Court indicated it would hear from the respondents on this aspect.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application for a writ of prohibition and a writ of certiorari by Australian Airlines Limited against the Australian Industrial Relations Commission and others. Australian Airlines Limited contests a finding of an industrial dispute by the Commission, asserting that the dispute is beyond the Commission's jurisdiction. The case revolves around pilots employed by Eastern Airlines, a subsidiary of Australian Airlines, who sought career progression into Australian Airlines. The pilots were not directly employed by Australian Airlines but by Eastern Airlines, leading to jurisdictional questions about the Commission's authority to handle the dispute. The matter is further complicated by Qantas Airways' acquisition of Australian Airlines, which raises questions about integration policies affecting the pilots. Australian Airlines argues that the dispute does not pertain to the relationship between employers and employees as required by law, and that the Commission lacks jurisdiction. The application is made ex parte, but the proceedings are affected by recent developments and an affidavit filed by Robert Bruce Carpenter, which Australian Airlines disputes. The Court considers whether to grant an order nisi and, if so, whether to stay the proceedings in the Commission. The arguments focus on the arguability of the case, the potential for unnecessary delay, and the implications of Qantas' acquisition on the jurisdictional issues. The Court decides to grant an order nisi but not to stay the proceedings, allowing the Commission to continue its work while the jurisdictional questions are addressed.

This matter came before the High Court of Australia on an ex parte application for a writ of prohibition and a writ of certiorari against the Australian Industrial Relations Commission and other respondents. The application was brought by Australian Airlines Limited, seeking to challenge the jurisdiction of the Commission to hear a matter involving an industrial dispute. The case originated from a finding by the Australian Industrial Relations Commission that an industrial dispute existed between the pilots of Eastern Airlines, a subsidiary of Australian Airlines, and the two companies, Australian Airlines and its parent company. The application was heard by Toohey J in chambers. The key procedural steps involved included the filing of an affidavit by Robert Bruce Carpenter, which raised questions about the factual basis of the application and the potential impact of Qantas' acquisition of Australian Airlines. The arguments focused on whether the application should proceed, be adjourned, or be granted a stay pending further developments. Ultimately, Toohey J decided to grant an order nisi, refusing a stay, and outlining the conditions under which the parties could apply for further relief. The matter was not adjourned, and the order included provisions for service and liberty to apply for a stay of further proceedings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the acquisition of Australian Airlines Limited by Qantas Airways Ltd affects the jurisdictional basis of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission.
2. Whether the subject matter of the dispute pertains to the relationship between employers and employees, as required by the definition of "industrial dispute" in section 4 of the Industrial Relations Act.
3. Whether the Australian Federation of Air Pilots is properly a party to the proceedings before the High Court.
4. Whether the Court should grant a stay of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission.
5. Whether the Court should adjourn the present application due to the uncertain factual situation and potential future developments.

Held
1. **Jurisdictional Basis of Proceedings:**
The court concluded that the acquisition of Australian Airlines Limited by Qantas Airways Ltd does not affect the jurisdictional basis of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission. The court granted an order nisi.

2. **Subject Matter of Dispute:**
The court found that the subject matter of the dispute pertains to the relationship between employers and employees, satisfying the definition of "industrial dispute" in section 4 of the Industrial Relations Act. The court granted an order nisi.

3. **Proper Party to Proceedings:**
The court determined that the Australian Federation of Air Pilots is not properly a party to the proceedings before the High Court. The court amended the order to remove the Federation as a respondent.

4. **Stay of Proceedings:**
The court decided not to grant a stay of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, allowing the Commission to proceed with its hearings. The court granted an order nisi with liberty to apply for a stay.

5. **Adjournment of Application:**
The court declined to adjourn the present application, deciding to proceed with the order nisi. The court granted an order nisi and set a future date for further hearings.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered several key issues in this case. Firstly, it assessed whether the acquisition of Australian Airlines Limited by Qantas Airways Ltd affected the jurisdictional basis of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission. The court concluded that while Qantas' acquisition of Australian Airlines Ltd was a significant development, it did not alter the jurisdictional foundation of the proceedings, as the dispute remained centered on the relationship between the pilots and their potential employers.

Secondly, the court examined whether the subject matter of the dispute pertained to the relationship between employers and employees, as required by the definition of "industrial dispute" in section 4 of the Industrial Relations Act. The court found that the dispute involved a claim by employees of one employer (Eastern Airlines) to be employed by another employer (Australian Airlines), which did pertain to the relationship between employers and employees.

Thirdly, the court considered whether the Australian Federation of Air Pilots was properly a party to the proceedings before the High Court. The court decided that the Federation should not be named as a party but would be served with the order and have the liberty to apply to a Justice of the Court.

Fourthly, the court deliberated whether it should grant a stay of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission. The court decided against granting a stay, as it did not want to preclude the Commission from being seized of the matter in respect of the joinder of Qantas or any further developments that may take place.

Lastly, the court addressed whether it should adjourn the present application due to the uncertain factual situation and potential future developments. The court determined that an order nisi should be made in terms of the draft, subject to some modifications, as the matters sought to be raised by the order nisi were sufficiently arguable to warrant the granting of an order.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the acquisition of Australian Airlines Ltd by Qantas Airways Ltd did not affect the jurisdictional basis of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, and the dispute pertained to the relationship between employers and employees as required by the definition of "industrial dispute" in section 4 of the Industrial Relations Act. The court also decided that the Australian Federation of Air Pilots should not be named as a party but would be served with the order and have the liberty to apply to a Justice of the Court. The court declined to grant a stay of the proceedings before the Australian Industrial Relations Commission and decided to proceed with the order nisi in terms of the draft, subject to some modifications.