Reported Decision: [2000] 115 A Crim R 1
New South Wales
Supreme Court
CITATION: AH-SEE v. HEILPERN & ANOR [2000] NSWSC 627 CURRENT JURISDICTION: COMMON LAW FILE NUMBER(S): SC 10054/00 HEARING DATE(S): 14/06/00 JUDGMENT DATE: 6 July 2000 PARTIES :
Albert Ah-See - Plaintiff
David Heilpern - First Defendant
Richard Morley - Second DefendantJUDGMENT OF: Bryson J at 1
COUNSEL : S. Odgers - Plaintiff
P. Berman - Second DefendantSOLICITORS: M. Dennis (s) Western Aboriginal Legal Service
S.E. O'Connor (s) for Public Prosecutions
First defendant submitting.CATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE - Criminal Proceedings - admission in official questioning - accused was asked, in an interview which was not electronically recorded, "Do you wish to participate in a line-up." and answered "No" - Magistrate admitted picture identification evidence after having regard to this q & a when considering objection - Evidence Act subs 115(5) made picture identification evidence inadmissible unless the accused refused to take part in an identification parade - it was contended that the q & a should not have been regarded when ruling on the objection because the q & a were an admission and the conditions for admissibility of evidence of an admission in Crimes Act s 424A (relates to electronic recording) (see now Criminal Procedure Act s 108) had not been complied with - meaning of "admission" in s 424A and significance of definitions of "admission" and "representation" in Evidence Act 1995 - cognate legislation - held - the q & a evidence of refusal were not evidence of an admission within s 424A - Magistrate was correct in having regard to q & a when ruling on objection to picture identification evidence. LEGISLATION CITED: Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 (NSW)
Crimes Act 1900 s 424A
Crimes Legislation Amendment (Sentencing) Act 1999
Criminal Procedure Act 1986 s 108
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) s59, s72, s81, s82, s85, s115, s138, Dictionary
Evidence (Consequential and Other Provisions) Act 1995
Justices Act 1902 s109
Supreme Court Act 1970 s101CASES CITED: Viro v. The Queen (1978) 141 CLR 88
Repatriation Commission v. Vietnam Veterans’ Association [2000] NSWCA 65
Horton (1998) 104A Crim R 306
Hinton (1999) 103A Crim R 142
Esposito (1998) 105A Crim R 27DECISION: Appeal dismissed
1 HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal under Pt 5 of the Justices Act 1902. On 24 August 1999 the plaintiff was arrested by police at Wellington and on 25 August he was brought before the Dubbo Children’s Court and charged with an offence under s 97 of the Crimes Act 1900 (which relates to robbery being armed with an offensive weapon). The particulars alleged that on 24 August he robbed a named Commonwealth Bank officer of $1,698 the property of the Bank while armed with a bladed instrument. The plaintiff was born on 30 August 1981. At the time of the…
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISIONBRYSON J.
THURSDAY 6 JULY 2000
10054/00 ALBERT AH-SEE v. DAVID HEILPERN and RICHARD MORLEY
JUDGMENT
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Re A (a Child) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 627
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of Re A (a Child), the dispute involved the admissibility of certain evidence obtained during an official questioning of the accused in criminal proceedings. The case was heard in the Children's Court of Victoria. The primary issue before the court was whether the evidence obtained during the questioning, which was not electronically recorded, could be admitted as evidence of an admission by the accused in relation to a line-up refusal. The court had to determine whether the conditions for admissibility of evidence of an admission, as outlined in the Crimes Act, had been complied with.
The legal issue centred on the interpretation of the term "admission" in the context of the Evidence Act and the Crimes Act. The accused argued that the evidence of the questioning, where they were asked if they wished to participate in a line-up and responded with "No," should not be considered because it was not electronically recorded and did not meet the statutory requirements for admissibility of an admission. The court needed to assess whether this evidence was an admission under section 424A of the Crimes Act (now section 108 of the Criminal Procedure Act) and whether the absence of an electronic recording rendered it inadmissible.
The court found that the evidence of the refusal to participate in a line-up was not an admission within the meaning of section 424A. The court reasoned that the term "admission" should be interpreted in the context of the definitions provided in the Evidence Act and cognate legislation. The court held that the questioning and the accused's response were evidence of a refusal, not an admission, and therefore, the Magistrate was correct in admitting the picture identification evidence when ruling on the objection. The court concluded that the Magistrate's decision to consider the questioning and response when ruling on the objection was appropriate, and the evidence was admissible under the circumstances.
No further orders were made by the court beyond the determination of the admissibility of the evidence in question.
The legal issue centred on the interpretation of the term "admission" in the context of the Evidence Act and the Crimes Act. The accused argued that the evidence of the questioning, where they were asked if they wished to participate in a line-up and responded with "No," should not be considered because it was not electronically recorded and did not meet the statutory requirements for admissibility of an admission. The court needed to assess whether this evidence was an admission under section 424A of the Crimes Act (now section 108 of the Criminal Procedure Act) and whether the absence of an electronic recording rendered it inadmissible.
The court found that the evidence of the refusal to participate in a line-up was not an admission within the meaning of section 424A. The court reasoned that the term "admission" should be interpreted in the context of the definitions provided in the Evidence Act and cognate legislation. The court held that the questioning and the accused's response were evidence of a refusal, not an admission, and therefore, the Magistrate was correct in admitting the picture identification evidence when ruling on the objection. The court concluded that the Magistrate's decision to consider the questioning and response when ruling on the objection was appropriate, and the evidence was admissible under the circumstances.
No further orders were made by the court beyond the determination of the admissibility of the evidence in question.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi