RDQD and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

RDQD and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2020] AATA 4655 (20 November 2020)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/6860

Re:RDQD

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndXVHS

OTHER PARTY

Decision

Tribunal:The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Date:20 November 2020

Place:Sydney

The reviewable decision of the Social Services & Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 5 November 2018 is set aside and in substitution it is decided that the mother provided 86% care for the children and the father 14% to take effect from 1 May 2018.

.......................[SGD].................................................

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care determinations – whether each parent had pattern of care for the children – relevant care period – whether the existing percentage of care determination must or should be revoked and a new determination be made – decision set aside and substituted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 37

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 5, 49, 50, 51, 54A, 54B, 54F, 54G, 54H, 55C

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (‘Collection Act’) ss 4, 96A(b) Family Amendment and Child Support Legislation Amendment (Protecting Children) Act 2018 (Cth)

A New Tax System (Family Assistance) Act 1999 (Cth)

Cases

Polec v Staker and Another [2011] FMCAfam 959; 253 FLR 339

P v Child Support Registrar [2012] FCA 1398

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286

Secondary Materials

Child Support Guide, version 4.46, 10 February 2020

REASONS FOR DECISION

The Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President

20 November 2020

Background

  1. The applicant in this matter (‘the father’) and the other party in these proceedings (‘the mother’) are parents to two children, born in May 2010 and February 2013.

  2. On 15 September 2017, a child support case was registered in respect of the children with the care percentages reflecting that the mother had 100% care of the children and the father 0%.

  3. On 12 October 2017, the father notified the respondent (‘the Registrar’) that there had been a change in the actual care of the children from 6 October 2017. He reported that from 6 October 2017 he had care of the children on one Friday and Saturday night per fortnight, which was confirmed by the mother. Accordingly, the Registrar determined new care percentages from 6 October 2017 to reflect that the mother provided 85% care for the children and the father 15%.

  4. On 25 October 2017, the mother objected to the Registrar’s determination on the basis that the father only cared for the children…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RDQD and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 4655
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support percentage of care determination. The parties were the father and the mother, with the Deputy President of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal presiding. The core dispute revolved around whether the existing percentage of care determination, made by a previous iteration of the Tribunal, should be revoked and a new determination made, reflecting the actual care provided by each parent.

The Tribunal was required to determine two primary issues: first, whether the existing care percentages must or should be revoked, and second, if revocation was warranted, what the respective care percentages of the father and mother should be during the relevant care period. The Tribunal considered a substantial volume of conflicting evidence, including text messages, diary entries, and after-school care records, noting the significant hostility between the parties which complicated the assessment. Allegations of domestic violence were made by the mother, but no evidence was presented to support these claims at the current hearing.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal applied sections 54F, 54G, and 54H of the Assessment Act concerning the revocation of previous care percentage decisions. It found that section 54G did not apply as the father had a regular pattern of care of 14%. However, the Tribunal determined that section 54F was engaged because the actual care provided by the father (52 nights, equating to 14% of care) differed from the previous determination, resulting in a change in his cost percentage from 'nil' to 24%. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that the previous decision must be revoked. Applying section 50 of the Assessment Act, which governs determinations where a responsible person has had a pattern of care, the Tribunal substituted a new determination of 86% care for the mother and 14% for the father, effective from 1 May 2018.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal must determine:(a)whether the existing care percentages, as determined by AAT1 in its decision dated 5 November 2018, must or should be revoked; and(b)if so, what are the respective care percentages of the father and the mother during the care period.The evidence The Tribunal accepted into evidence all of the information previously provided by the parties in relation to the hearings conducted by AAT1 and AAT2. There were many volumes of material, including documentation of text messages, diary entries, after school care records and tables setting out each parties’ versions of events, much of it conflicting and often without corroborating material. Some of the material lodged with the Tribunal was not relevant to the current proceedings as it related to a period outside the ambit of the relevant care period in question. There was a significant level of hostility between the parties which, whilst not unusual in such cases, can make it more difficult to determine issues, particularly when matters normally considered uncontentious cannot be agreed upon. I have read and considered all of the material submitted by both parties, but as much of the material was unsubstantiated, contested and/or conflicting, I have chosen not to go through that evidence in detail but rather to focus on the evidence and findings of fact relevant to the decision I have made. I note that at the end of the hearing the mother made allegations against the father of domestic violence and said that she feared for her safety. No evidence was provided to support this allegation at the current hearing, although I note that the allegation has been previously made and there was some evidence including the father’s oral evidence of an Apprehended Violence Order (‘AVO’) having been in place which may have affected the father’s capacity to see the children. There was no objective evidence before the Tribunal that it had affected the father’s access during the relevant care period. The mother was urged to deal with any ongoing issues of domestic violence through the appropriate authorities. The mother also claimed at the end of the hearing that the proceedings should have been confidential, although no such request was made prior to commencement of the hearing. The mother claimed that she had heard the father speaking to another person whom she said was in the room with him whilst he was participating in the hearing by phone. I am not aware that anyone else involved in the proceedings heard any third party voice. I did not hear such a voice. In any event, the mother was reminded that hearings of the Tribunal are generally public, and third parties may generally attend hearings of the Tribunal unless another decision is made on appropriate grounds. It is reasonable to assume, in light of previous litigation, that both parties were aware of the usual restrictions which apply to hearings of this kind. No reference was made by either party to any relevant directions. Subsequent to the hearing, the mother emailed the Tribunal on 6 October 2020 and stated as follows:I wish to raise my concern about my hearing dated today at 10am.I raised in the last part of the hearing a concern about another party being present with [the father].It is my understanding under These Directions are given under section 18B of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.23. Adult persons who may be present at the hearing (1) At least 14 days before the hearing, you must tell us of any person (other than an interpreter or representative) whom you want to be present at the hearing.This was not the case.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider it likely that there were times additional to 23 and 24 February 2018 when the father provided care overnight at times randomly agreed to make up for these school holiday times when the children were not available. I note the Guide states that if a care event is missed but substitute care occurs at another time, it is not considered as a missed event.[1] There was evidence of a number of occasions where the children had spent at least 19 hours with the father but I have not added additional nights to the AAT1 charts except for 23 and 24 February 2018, as the evidence either lacked specificity or was conflicted so that I could not be sufficiently satisified. In any event, I am satisified that the father had actual care of the children for 52 nights and therefore had 14% care of the children.[1] Department of Social Services, Child Support Guide, ‘2.2.2 Care determinations & changes in care’, <>On the basis of the evidence, including the amount of weekend time the father had care of the children outside of school holidays together with ad hoc make up time, I find that the father had at least 52 nights of care with the children and therefore I am satisified that the appropriate percentage of care percentage is 86% to the mother and 14% to the father. Must or should the care percentage decision be revoked?As I have outlined above, I am satisified that the appropriate percentage of care differed from the reviewable decision of AAT1 and should have reflected 86% percent of care to the mother and 14% to the father. In determining whether the reviewable decision must or should be revoked, I have considered whether section 54F, 54G and 54H of the Assessment Act are applicable revoking the percentages of care attributed to the mother and father from AAT1’s decision.Revocation under section 54GThe Tribunal must firstly consider the applicability of section 54G in relation to the revocation of AAT1’s decision, as section 54H can only apply if sections 54F and 54G do not apply (section 54H(1)(e)) and section 54F can only apply if section 54G does not apply (section 54F(1)(e)).In relation to section 54G and the question of whether a person who was to have at least regular care has had less than regular care or none at all, it should be noted that “regular care” is provided by a person if that person’s “percentage of care for the child during a care period is at least 14% but less than 35%” (section 5(2) of the Assessment Act).As I have outlined above in my consideration of the percentages of care for both parents, I am satisified on the basis of the evidence that the appropriate percentage of care is 86% to the mother and 14% to the father. Accordingly, section 54G does not apply, because I am satisified that the father does have a regular pattern of care of 14%.Revocation under section 54FAs section 54G of the Assessment Act does not apply, I have considered whether section 54F applies to revoke the previous care percentages as determined by AAT1. In doing so, I have considered whether the care of the children actually taking place did or did not correspond with the person’s existing care percentage, and if it did not, whether the person’s cost percentage would change if a new determination were made.A person’s cost percentage for the purposes of section 54F is to be ascertained in accordance with the table in section 55C of the Assessment Act as follows:As previously discussed, I have determined that the father’s care percentage should be 14% based on the evidence, as opposed to 13% percentage of care decided in the AAT1 decision under review. Accordingly, the father’s cost percentage has changed from ‘nil’ to ‘24%’ in accordance with the above table in section 55C of the Assessment Act. Given the father’s change in cost percentages as a result of the actual care provided as I have discussed above, this engages the provisions of section 54F regarding mandatory revocation of the previous decision where there is a change to the responsible person’s cost percentage.Revocation under section 54HHaving decided that section 54F applies to revoke the previous determination, it follows that section 54H does not apply (section 54H(e) of the Assessment Act).Determining percentages of careAs I have decided to revoke the existing determination, I must now consider whether section 49, 50 or 51 of the Assessment Act is applicable to make a new care percentage determination.The pre-amendment version of section 49 relevantly provided:49 Determination of percentage of care—responsible person has had etc. no pattern of care for a child(1) This section applies if:(a) …(b) the Registrar:(i) revokes, under Subdivision C of this Division, a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under this section or section 50; and(ii) is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, no pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.(2) The Registrar must determine the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child during the care period.(3) The percentage of care determined under subsection (2) must be 0%, unless section 51 applies in relation to the responsible person.I am satisified that section 49 does not apply in the current circumstances in determining the father and mother’s percentage of care, as I have already determined that the parties did have a pattern of care for the children during the relevant period. Section 49 is specifically about determinations where the responsible person(s) has had no pattern of care for a child.The pre-amendment version of section 51 of the Assessment Act provides:51 Percentage of care if action taken to ensure that a care arrangement in relation to a child is complied with(1) This section applies if:(a) the Registrar is required by section 49 or 50 to determine a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child during a care period; and(b) a care arrangement applies in relation to the child; and(c) the Registrar is satisfied that the actual care of the child that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, during the care period does not comply with the extent of care of the child that the person should have had, or is to have, under the care arrangement during that period (which may be nil); and(d) a person who has reduced care of the child has taken reasonable action to ensure that the care arrangement is complied with.Note: This section does not apply in certain circumstances: see section 53.The Guide provides some guidance when considering what constitutes a written agreement at [2.2.4], specifically:A written agreement exists between separated parents (or a parent and another person who cares for the child) if:• there is a document in writing;• the document is signed and dated by both parties; and• both parties agree on the care arrangements for the child, which are specified in the document.The provisions of section 51, in my opinion, do not apply to the current circumstances, as I am not satisified that the mother and father had a care arrangement in place in relation to the children. I note that the agreement between the parties as to the care of the children has not been signed and secondly that the purported care arrangement was not always complied with and was rather used as a reference tool for consultation or, in some instances, a lack of consultation where the mother made a decision not to make the children available to the father. The relevant provision is therefore section 50 of the Assessment Act in making a new determination on percentage of care where the parent(s) have had a pattern of care for the child. The pre-amendment version of section 50 relevantly provided:50 Determination of percentage of care—responsible person has had etc. a pattern of care for a child(1) This section applies if:(a) …(b) the Registrar:(i) revokes, under Subdivision C of this Division, a determination of a responsible person’s percentage of care for a child that was made under section 49 or this section; and(ii) is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, a pattern of care for the child during such period (the care period) as the Registrar considers to be appropriate having regard to all the circumstances.(2) The Registrar must determine the responsible person’s percentage of care for the child during the care period.(3) The percentage determined under subsection (2) must be a percentage that corresponds with the actual care of the child that the Registrar is satisfied that the responsible person has had, or is likely to have, during the care period.(4) Subsection (3) does not apply if section 51 or 52 applies in relation to the responsible person.Accordingly, pursuant to section 50, I am satisified that the percentage of care should reflect 86% of care to the mother and 14% to the father, having regard to the actual care provided to the children and with the date of effect being 1 May 2018.DECISIONOn the basis of the evidence, I am satisified that the father did have 52 nights of actual care of the children so as to have 14% care of the children. In substitution for times missed during the holiday period or where the children were not made available, the father was able to have substitute overnight time with the children when they were available, plus other time that was not overnight time. Accordingly, I am satisified that the reviewable decision of the Social Services & Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 5 November 2018 should be set aside and in substitution it is decided that the mother provided 86% care for the children and the father 14% to take effect from 1 May 2018. I certify that the preceding 103 (one hundred and three) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of the Hon. John Pascoe AC CVO, Deputy President. .............................[SGD]...........................................AssociateDated: 20 November 2020 Date of hearing: 6 October 2020 Applicant:Other party: In person (by telephone) In person (by telephone) Solicitors for the Respondent: Mr K Eskerie, Sparke Helmore Lawyers

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.