RCBZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

RCBZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 4435 (26 November 2021)

Division:                  GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2020/1302

Re:RCBZ

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

Andm GJBG

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:L M Gallagher, Member

Date:26 November 2021

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision, being the AAT1 decision dated 23 May 2019, is:

a)affirmed, insofar as it determined that the relevant commencement date is 26 January 2018;

b)affirmed, insofar as it determined that the date of effect is 8 March 2019; and

c)set aside, insofar as it determined that the Applicant and the Other Party each had 50/50 care of the child for the duration of the care period, and substituted with the decision that the Applicant had 100% care of the child and the Other Party had 0% care of the child during the care period.

............[Sgd]............................................................

L M Gallagher, Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care –
actual care – date of effect – evidence – decision under review affirmed in part

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 29(7), 43(6)

Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) – ss 49(1)(a), 49(1)(b), 50(1)(a), 50(1)(b), 50(3), 54A(1), 54B, 54F, 54G, 54H, 55C

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – ss 87AA(1), 87AA(2), 95N(1), 95N(2)

CASES

Afghani and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2017] AATA 410

Angelakos and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations  [2007] FCA 25

Beadle and Director-General of Social Security (1984) 6 ALD 1

Boscolo v Secretary, Department of Social Security (1999) 90 FCR 531

Davy and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations [2007] AATA 1114

Drainchnikov v Centrelink (2003) 75 ALD 134

Groth v Secretary, Department of Social Security (1995) 40 ALD 541

P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312

P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98

Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562

Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Rodgers and Child Support Registrar (Child Support second Review) [2016] AATA 1064

Shanhun and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 675

Singleton and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 766

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

L M Gallagher, Member

26 November 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of two children. The present application relates to one of those children (the child), who is now 13 years of age.

  2. On 9 December 2014, a child support case was registered in relation to the child.[1]

    [1]R1, T35, p 265.

  3. Departmental…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RCBZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 4435
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding a child support percentage of care determination. The parties involved were RCBZ (the Applicant) and the Child Support Registrar, with the dispute centering on the actual percentage of care each party had of the child and the date from which any change in care should have effect.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the existing determination of a 50/50 percentage of care, made by a previous AAT decision effective from 8 March 2019, should be revoked and replaced. This required the Tribunal to determine the actual percentage of care each party had of the child during the relevant period and, crucially, the date on which any change in care occurred. If a change in care was found, the Tribunal also needed to determine the new percentage of care and the date from which it should have effect for child support purposes, considering whether special circumstances warranted an earlier commencement date than the objection lodgement date.

The Tribunal considered the evidence provided solely by the Applicant, finding her to be a credible witness who gave a detailed account of the care arrangements. The Applicant's evidence indicated that the care arrangement was never 50/50 and detailed a period from late December 2017 where the child stayed with the Applicant's parents, followed by the Other Party having care for specific periods in early 2018. The Applicant also provided evidence of a significant change in care on 31 March 2018, when she and the child moved to her mother's residence and subsequently to Western Australia. The Tribunal noted that the Other Party made no submissions.

The Tribunal affirmed in part the previous decision, finding that a change in care did occur. However, it determined that the Applicant and the Other Party did not have 50/50 care from 26 January 2018. The Tribunal found that the Applicant's evidence established a change in care on 31 March 2018, and based on the Applicant's credible testimony and calendar, it determined the actual percentages of care from that date. The Tribunal ultimately revoked the previous decision and substituted a new percentage of care determination, with the date of effect being 31 March 2018.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal notes that the Respondent’s file notes of conversations with both parties are contained at R1, T34. The Applicant’s evidence The Applicant gave the following evidence as to the care arrangements of the child between herself and the Other Party at the relevant time:[40][40]The Tribunal notes the Applicant’s evidence that follows accords with her written statement in A1.(a)The care arrangement was never 50/50 (in actuality).[41](b)The Other Party had spent the Christmas day of 2017 together with the child, the Applicant and the Applicant’s parents.[42](c)After Christmas day of 2017, and for the remainder of the school holidays, the child stayed with the Applicant’s parents.[43] The Applicant and the Other Party went their separate ways.[44](d)The Other Party did not see the child from 27 December 2017, nor did he have any contact with the child until he returned to the Applicant’s house on 14 February 2018 to collect some items.[45] At that time, the Applicant’s parents were at her home for a few days as they were helping her move.[46] (e)The Other Party saw the child for a few hours on 14 February 2018.[47] Then, the Other Party had care of the child for the three nights from 15 February 2018.[48](f)The Other Party had care of the child for a total of 23 nights from 16 February 2018 to 31 March 2018.[49](g)The Other Party has not seen the child since 31 March 2018[50] and has barely called him.[51] Any telephone contact the Other Party has with the child is initiated by the Applicant.[52](h)On 31 March 2018, the Applicant and the child went to visit the Applicant’s mother on her birthday.[53] While they were visiting, the child indicated he wished to stay on there, so the Applicant enrolled him school there and they stayed.[54](i)The Applicant and the child stayed with the Applicant’s parents until July 2019.[55](j)After that, the Applicant, the Applicant’s mother and the child moved to Western Australia[56] and have resided there ever since.[41]Transcript, p 7 [5], [10]; p 14 [15]–[25].[42]Transcript, p 9 [15].[43]Transcript, p 9 [25]–[30].[44]Transcript, p 9 [25].[45][46]Transcript, p 9 [30].[47]Transcript, p 9 [30]–[35].[48]Transcript, p 9 [40].[49][50]Transcript, p 10 [25].[51]Transcript, p7 [5]–[10], [30]; p 10 [30]–[35]. See R1, T27.[52]Transcript, p 10 [35]–[45].[53]Transcript, p 10 [5].[54]Transcript, p 10 [5]–[10].[55]Transcript, p 10 [10]–[15].[56]Transcript, p 10 [10]–[15].The Applicant’s submissions The Applicant’s submission in this matter is straightforward. Essentially, the Applicant submits that the Reviewable Decision is wrong because she and the Other Party simply never shared care of the child on a 50/50 basis, either from 26 January 2018 or at any point in time after this date.The Other Party’s submissions The Other Party did not make any submissions in the present application. For completeness, there is insufficient material before the Tribunal for it to deem or infer any such submissions.CONSIDERATIONWhether the existing determination of percentage of care made on 23 May 2019 should be revoked and replaced

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 23 May 2019, the AAT1 set aside the decision under review and, in substitution, decided that from 26 January 2018 the Applicant and Other Party each had 50/50 care of the child, with effect for child support purposes from the date the AAT1 application was lodged (8 March 2019) (the Reviewable Decision).[11] [11]R1, T4. The Tribunal notes that the Reviewable Decision made clear that the AAT1 was not persuaded that there were ‘special circumstances’[12] which prevented the Other Party from lodging his application to the AAT1 within the prescribed timeframe, hence the date of effect being 8 March 2019.[13][12]See further discussion at [14] below.[13]As opposed to 14 February 2018, being the date that the change in care was notified, which would have been the date of effect had special circumstances been found to exist. See R1, T4 [19]–[20]. What is unclear to the Tribunal from the AAT1 decision, however, is whether the basis of the AAT1’s finding as to date of effect is that it:(1) declined to make a determination under s95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act) at all; or (2) did determine, under s95N(2) of the Collection Act, that it could not be satisfied that special circumstances under s95N(2) were made out of the evidence. The extent of the evidence and findings of the AAT1 on this point are (R1, T4 p 15 [20]): [GJBG] applied for the review nearly eight months after the original decision. He said he has been suffering from mental health issues and this has impacted on [sic] his ability to deal with the care issue. The tribunal did not consider there was enough evidence to find that [GJBG’s] health issues prevented him from applying for a review. The tribunal therefore decided that the date of effect of this decision is 8 March 2019. Then, under the heading ‘Decision,’ the AAT1 states (R1, T4, p15): …as a result of the Tribunal’s determination under s95N of the (Collection Act)’ indicating that the AAT1 did in fact make a determination to the effect that special circumstances did not exist. This is addressed further at n 57. On 6 March 2020, the Applicant applied to the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for review of the AAT1 decision.[14] [14]R1, T1. The Applicant’s application was dated 12 December 2019 but not received by the Tribunal until 6 March 2020. As the Applicant’s application to the Tribunal was lodged more than 28 days after the Applicant received notice of the AAT1 decision, an extension of time was required in accordance with section 29(7) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth). This was granted by the Tribunal on 21 May 2020.[15] [15]R1, T2.ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION The issue for determination by this Tribunal is the Applicant’s and the Other Party’s respective percentages of care of the child from the relevant commencement date.[16] Specifically:[16]The relevant commencement date, being the date on which the change of care occurred (if indeed the Tribunal finds a change in care did occur), are findings of fact addressed by the Tribunal at [41]-[47] below. As the care period is now in the past, these percentages must correspond to the actual care that took place during that period. (a)Whether the existing determination of percentage of care made by the AAT1 on 23 May 2019 should be revoked and replaced. This requires the Tribunal to determine what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party each had of the child from the relevant commencement date.(b)If so, that is, if the Tribunal finds that there was a change in the percentage of care from the relevant commencement date, such that a new determination of percentage of care should be made: (i)What is the new percentage of care determination?(ii)What is the date from which the new percentage of care determination should have effect for the purposes of child support? Generally speaking,[17] this date would be either:· From the date the objection was lodged,[18] which was on 8 March 2019; or· From the date that the change in care was notified, being 14 February 2018. · As noted above,[19] this will be the case only if there were ‘special circumstances’ that prevented the objection from being lodged at the time it was required to be lodged, namely within 28 days of the original decision.[20] · The period of time falling for consideration in the context of special circumstances is the period between 10 April 2018, when the original decision was made, and 8 March 2019, when the objection was lodged with the AAT1. [17]However, see further discussion at paras [27]–[29] and [48] below.[18]Section 87AA(1) of the Collection Act provides that where an objection is not lodged within 28 days of a percentage of care determination, and the objection is allowed in a way that has the effect of varying the percentage of care determination or substituting a new care percentage determination, the objection decision will have effect from the date the objection was lodged.[19]See [8]-[10] above.[20]Section 87AA(2) of the Collection Act provides that the Registrar may determine that the 28-day objection period be extended to such longer period as the Registrar determines appropriate if the Registrar is satisfied that special circumstances prevented the objection being lodged within the stipulated timeframe. In that situation, the objection decision has effect as if the objection were lodged within the 28-day timeframe and therefore will have effect from the date that the original decision had effect (being 14 February 2018 in the present matter). See further [10] and n 57.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Other Party did not make any submissions in the present application. For completeness, there is insufficient material before the Tribunal for it to deem or infer any such submissions.CONSIDERATIONWhether the existing determination of percentage of care made on 23 May 2019 should be revoked and replaced The first matter for the Tribunal’s consideration is whether, the existing determination of percentage of care made on 23 May 2019, being that from 26 January 2018, the Applicant and the Other Party each had 50/50 care of the child, with effect from 8 March 2019, should be revoked and replaced. If not, then the existing percentage of care determination remains in place and that ends the Tribunal’s consideration of the matter. This requires the Tribunal to determine what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party each had of the child during the care period[57], and, if there was a change in care, from what date that change in care occurred.[57]As the relevant care period has passed, the Tribunal must determine the percentage of care by, in turn, determining the pattern of care that occurred during the relevant period, being the 12-month period from the day on which the actual care of a child changed. Refer to n 21. Was there a change in care? If so, on what date did the change in care occur? The Applicant and the Other Party agree that a change in care occurred, but disagree as to when it occurred. The point in time in which the change in care occurred, (if indeed the tribunal ultimately finds that a change in care did occur) is an essential finding of fact as the date of the change is the appropriate commencement date of the care period. As the relevant care period has passed, the Tribunal must determine the pattern of care that occurred during the 12-month period from the day on which the actual care of a child changed.[58] [58]Refer to n 20. The Applicant and the Other Party agree on the following matters in relation to percentage of care of the child:[59](a)In late 2017 they agreed to move into their own homes when their rental lease expired on 25 January 2018.(b)On 30 November 2017, the Applicant left the family home and returned just before Christmas.(c)During this period, the Applicant’s mother moved into the family home.(d)The Applicant, the Other Party and the child spent the Christmas of 2017 with the Applicant’s parents. (e)The Applicant returned to her home from 29 December 2017 to 11 January 2018 and the child stayed with the Applicant’s parents.(f)On 25 January 2018, the Applicant and the Other Party both moved out of their family home and it was initially agreed they would have 50/50 care of the child.[59]R1, T4, p 13. The Tribunal understands that the Applicant and the Other Party disagree as to the actual amount of care they each had of the child from December 2017 onward. The evidence before the Tribunal in the present matter as to the pattern of care has been provided solely by the Applicant. The Tribunal relies upon, in particular the Applicant’s calendar[60] and the Applicant’s evidence at hearing. The Tribunal considered the Applicant to be a credible witness, who gave a detailed and clear historical account of her own recollection of the division of care between herself and the Other Party from late 2017. [60]R1, T27.