Raynik Pty Ltd v Gill No. DCCIV-96-1199 Judgment No. D3

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

RAYNIK PTY LTD v GAVIN GILL
[1999] SADC 3

Judge Lunn
Civil

  1. Don Nikou (“Nikou”) went to school with the defendant, Gavin Gill (“Gill”), but thereafter they lost contact.  The plaintiff is a company controlled by Nikou.  In 1985 he ran a menswear business through the company which made substantial losses.  Nikou was apparently personally liable for some of the unpaid debts of the plaintiff.  Although he did not have any formal trade qualifications, he thereafter carried on business with his brother, Con, as a painter and decorator.  In about 1990 he became a land agent and was employed by the real estate firm of Weeks & Macklin at its office at Grange.  The debts of the plaintiff and Nikou were increasing because of accrued interest as he did not have sufficient income to service them fully.  He had no significant assets.  He became enthusiastic about being involved in residential property subdivision and re-development projects, which he saw as a way of making a substantial amount of money and thus alleviating his continuing financial difficulties.  However, he had no capital to invest in such projects and no capacity to borrow money for them.  His activities as a real estate agent made him conversant with opportunities for such property developments and gave him some expertise in pricings and costings which were necessary for carrying them out successfully.  However, he did not have experience in actually carrying out any property re-developments.  He spent a good deal of his time in his employment with Weeks & Macklin in searching out properties which would be suitable for subdivision and re-development of various kinds.

  2. Gill became a plumber.  He worked for his father who was a builder.  After he married he and his wife bought a home which they renovated and sold.  With the proceeds they bought another house at Meredith Avenue, Fulham (“Meredith Avenue”).  By 1992 they owned it freehold.  They had done some renovations to it.  They had one child who had been born in 1990.  They, and Mrs Gill in particular, planned to sell Meredith Avenue and to buy a better and more expensive family home.  They also had about $70,000 in the bank which was available to be put into any future property which they purchased.

  3. In about March 1992 Nikou and Gill became re-acquainted.  Social contact between them increased in the next few months and by later in 1992 they were very friendly and seeing each other almost daily.  Nikou was a frequent visitor at Meredith Avenue and they often went out together.

  1. In about mid 1992 Mrs Gill was interested in possibly purchasing a house in West Lakes as a new family home.  Nikou, as a friend, assisted her and advised her about some of these houses, but nothing came of it.  Shortly after mid 1992 Gill and his wife put Meredith Avenue on the market through an agent, George Kelleher, but it did not sell.

  2. In the course of their friendship in the latter part of 1992…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Raynik Pty Ltd v Gill No. DCCIV-96-1199 Judgment No. D3 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SADC 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Raynik Pty Ltd, a company controlled by Don Nikou, initiated legal proceedings against Gavin Gill, a former schoolmate, alleging breach of an oral agreement for a joint venture in residential property development and seeking an account of profits and damages. The South Australian District Court was required to determine whether there was a concluded agreement between the parties for a joint venture in property development and, if not, whether the plaintiff was entitled to recover for the work done by Nikou on a quantum meruit. The court held that there was no concluded agreement for a joint venture between the parties. Nikou's claims of an agreement to share profits equally lacked substantiation, were inconsistent with Gill's conduct and Mrs Gill's position, and were at odds with the lack of formal records or calculations reflecting such an agreement. The court also rejected the plaintiff's claims on quantum meruit for work done in searching for development properties and in renovating the old police station, finding that a reasonable person in Gill's position would not have expected payment beyond commission for the former and that cash payments made to Nikou for the latter made it unlikely that it was unjust for Gill to accept the benefit of Nikou's services without further remuneration.