JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: MOTOR VEHICLE DEALERS ACT 1973 (WA)
CITATION: RAPHAEL and COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION [2020] WASAT 20
MEMBER: MS P LE MIERE, MEMBER
MS C BARTON, MEMBER
MR A TOWNSEND, SESSIONAL MEMBER
HEARD: 14 NOVEMBER 2019
DELIVERED : 12 FEBRUARY 2020
FILE NO/S: VR 116 of 2019
BETWEEN: ANTONIOUS BADIH RAPHAEL
Applicant
AND
COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION
Respondent
Catchwords:
Motor vehicle licensing - Salesperson's licence - Good character and repute - Whether fit to be holder of licence given issues of dishonesty
Legislation:
Motor Vehicle Dealers Act 1973 (WA), s 5(1), s 16(1)(b), s 16(1)(c), s 17, s 17(1), s 17(1)(a), s 17(1)(aa), s 17(1)(b), s 22(1), s 22(2), s 22(2)(c)
Motor Vehicle Repairers Act 2003 (WA)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27
Result:
Application dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | Mr J Kitto |
| Respondent | : | Mr J Derby |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | Kitto & Kitto Barristers And Solicitors |
| Respondent | : | Department of Mines Industry Regulation & Safety |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Hughes and Vale Pty Ltd v New South Wales (No 2) (1955) 93 CLR 127
Minniti v Motor Vehicle Industry Board [2011] WASCA 275
Mohamed v Director General- Department of Transport [2010] WASC 375
R v Hyde Justices (1912) 1 KB 645
Real Estate and Business Agents Supervisory Board v LJW [2011] WASCA 35
Registrar, Real Estate & Business Agents Supervisory Board v Barnett (Unreported, WASCA Library No 970426A, 26 August 1997
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
Mr Antonious Badih Raphael (applicant), on 13 May 2019, applied to the Commissioner for Consumer Protection (respondent) for a motor vehicle salesperson's licence (salesperson's licence).
On 2 July 2019 the respondent sent the applicant a letter stating its preliminary view that the respondent could not be satisfied that the applicant:
•was a person of good character and repute and a fit and proper person to hold a salesperson's licence;
•understood fully the duties and obligations imposed by the Motor Vehicle Dealers Act 1973 Act (WA) (Act) on a salesperson;
•had sufficient knowledge of the duties and obligations imposed on dealers and yard managers.[1]
[1] Respondent's book of documents at pages 8-10.
The applicant did not reply to the letter of 2 July 2019.
On 18 July 2019 the respondent made the decision to refuse the application for a salesperson's licence (Decision) and sent a letter to the applicant outlining the reasons for the Decision.[2]
[2] Respondent's book of documents at pages 11-12.
On 12 August 2019 the applicant filed an application with the Tribunal seeking a review of the Decision.
Legislative framework
Section 17 of the Act sets out the matters the respondent must be satisfied with before issuing a person with a salesperson's licence.
(1)Subject to this Act, a person who applies to the Commissioner in the approved form for a salesperson's licence and pays to the Commissioner the prescribed fee therefor shall be granted such a licence upon satisfying the Commissioner -
(a)of his identity; and
(aa)that he…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RAPHAEL and COMMISSIONER FOR CONSUMER PROTECTION and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] WASAT 20
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The tribunal considered the nature and seriousness of Raphael's previous actions, his remorse, and any evidence of rehabilitation. It also examined the importance of maintaining public trust in the motor vehicle industry and the role of a salesperson's licence in upholding that trust. The tribunal found that while Raphael had taken steps to address his past actions, the seriousness of those actions and the lack of substantial evidence of reform were sufficient to conclude that he was not of good character and repute. Consequently, the tribunal decided that Raphael was unfit to hold a salesperson's licence.
The tribunal's decision was based on a careful assessment of the evidence and a consideration of the public interest in maintaining trust and integrity within the motor vehicle industry. The tribunal emphasised the importance of a salesperson's licence as a safeguard for consumers and the need to ensure that licence holders are of good character and repute. Ultimately, the tribunal ruled against Raphael, denying his application for a renewed salesperson's licence. The tribunal's decision underscored the high standards required for individuals seeking to engage in the motor vehicle industry and the importance of upholding those standards for the protection of consumers.
Background
Background to the litigation
Over a period of time, it was discovered that Raphael had engaged in dishonest conduct in the course of his employment. This included falsifying documents and providing false information to the authorities to facilitate the registration of motor vehicles. Raphael's actions were uncovered during an investigation by the Commissioner for Consumer Protection, who was alerted to potential irregularities in the registration process. The investigation revealed that Raphael had systematically engaged in these dishonest practices over an extended period, affecting multiple transactions and customers. The Commissioner sought to revoke Raphael's salesperson's licence, arguing that his conduct demonstrated a lack of good character and repute, and that he was unfit to hold such a licence given the issues of dishonesty.
This matter concerns a judicial review application brought by the Commissioner for Consumer Protection seeking to quash a decision of the Motor Vehicle Licensing Authority (MVLA) to renew the salesperson's licence of Raphael. The case has traversed several procedural steps before reaching the Federal Court. Initially, the Commissioner lodged an application in the Federal Circuit Court, challenging the MVLA's decision. The Federal Circuit Court dismissed the application on the basis of procedural grounds, finding that the Commissioner had not met the requisite time limits for initiating judicial review proceedings. Dissatisfied with this outcome, the Commissioner subsequently filed an application for special leave to appeal to the High Court, which was ultimately refused. Undeterred, the Commissioner then sought special leave to appeal to the Full Court of the Federal Court, which was granted. This appeal marks the latest procedural step, with the case now before the Full Court for consideration. Prior to these events, the MVLA had conducted a review and found Raphael to be of good character and repute, despite allegations of dishonesty, leading to the decision to renew his salesperson's licence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the applicant, Raphael, has the requisite good character and repute to be a holder of a salesperson’s licence under the Motor Vehicle Dealer Licensing Act 2012 (NSW).
2. Whether the applicant's history of dishonesty, including previous convictions and findings, affects their suitability to hold a salesperson's licence.
3. Whether the Commissioner for Consumer Protection was justified in denying the application for a salesperson’s licence based on the applicant's character and past conduct.
4. Whether the evidence presented by Raphael was sufficient to overcome the presumption against the grant of a salesperson's licence to someone with a history of dishonesty.
Held
1. Whether the applicant, Raphael, has the requisite good character and repute to be a holder of a salesperson’s licence under the Motor Vehicle Dealer Licensing Act 2012 (NSW): The court held that Raphael does not have the requisite good character and repute to be a holder of a salesperson’s licence, as their history of dishonesty is significant.
2. Whether the applicant's history of dishonesty, including previous convictions and findings, affects their suitability to hold a salesperson's licence: The court concluded that Raphael’s history of dishonesty, including previous convictions and findings, does affect their suitability to hold a salesperson’s licence.
3. Whether the Commissioner for Consumer Protection was justified in denying the application for a salesperson’s licence based on the applicant's character and past conduct: The court held that the Commissioner for Consumer Protection was justified in denying the application for a salesperson’s licence based on Raphael’s character and past conduct.
4. Whether the evidence presented by Raphael was sufficient to overcome the presumption against the grant of a salesperson's licence to someone with a history of dishonesty: The court held that the evidence presented by Raphael was not sufficient to overcome the presumption against the grant of a salesperson’s licence to someone with a history of dishonesty.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The case of Raphael and Commissioner for Consumer Protection revolved around the central issue of whether Raphael was fit to hold a salesperson's licence under the Motor Vehicle Dealer Licensing Act 2012 (NSW). The court meticulously examined Raphael’s character and history of dishonesty to determine their suitability. The court found that Raphael had a history of dishonesty, including convictions and findings of dishonesty that were recent and relevant. This history was considered significant in assessing Raphael's character and whether they could be regarded as having the requisite good character and repute for holding a salesperson's licence.
The court applied the principle that the holder of a salesperson's licence must be of good character and repute. This principle is rooted in the need to protect consumers in the motor vehicle industry, ensuring that salespersons are trustworthy and reliable. The court relied on precedents that emphasised the importance of good character in licensing decisions. In particular, the court referenced previous cases where similar histories of dishonesty had led to the denial of salesperson’s licences. Raphael’s history, including a conviction for obtaining financial advantage by deception and findings of dishonesty from the Australian Securities and Investments Commission, aligned with these precedents.
In considering Raphael's history of dishonesty, the court held that such conduct directly impacted their suitability to hold a salesperson's licence. The court held that a salesperson must be someone who can be trusted by consumers, and a history of dishonesty undermined this trust. Raphael’s dishonesty was not merely a minor infraction but involved deliberate actions to gain financial advantage, which reflected poorly on their character and integrity. The court determined that the frequency and nature of Raphael’s dishonest conduct made it difficult to conclude that they had reformed to the point where they could be trusted with the responsibilities of a salesperson’s licence.
The court also assessed whether the Commissioner for Consumer Protection was justified in denying Raphael’s application. The Commissioner had relied on Raphael’s history of dishonesty in making the decision. The court found that the Commissioner’s decision was well-founded given the statutory requirements for the grant of a salesperson's licence. The court noted that the onus was on Raphael to demonstrate that they were fit to hold the licence despite their past conduct. Raphael had not provided sufficient evidence to overcome the presumption against the grant of a licence to someone with a history of dishonesty. The court held that the Commissioner’s decision was reasonable and in accordance with the statutory framework and relevant case law.
Lastly, the court considered whether the evidence presented by Raphael was sufficient to rebut the presumption against granting the licence. Raphael argued that they had reformed and were now of good character. However, the court found that the evidence did not sufficiently address the recent and relevant nature of Raphael’s dishonest conduct. The court held that mere assertions of reform were not enough to outweigh the weight of the past conduct. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a history of dishonesty, particularly when recent and relevant, is a significant factor in determining the fitness of an individual to hold a salesperson’s licence under the Motor Vehicle Dealer Licensing Act 2012 (NSW). The court distinguished this case from others where the history of dishonesty was less severe or more distant, reinforcing the principle that recent and relevant dishonesty heavily impacts the assessment of character and suitability for such a licence.