Rankin v State Electoral Commissioner

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TRIBUNAL

(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)

RANKIN v STATE ELECTORAL COMMISSIONER

[2010] SAEOT 3

Judgment of Her Honour Judge Trenorden, Member Ms A Bachmann and Member Mr D Shetliffe

8 September 2010

HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION

Complaints referred at request of complainant - complainant is vision-impaired and unable to vote at elections without assistance - whether failure to provide computer assisted voting or Braille voting or a combination is discriminatory - whether Complaints are valid Complaints.

HELD:  Complaints dismissed

Equal Opportunity Act 1984; Electoral Act 1985; Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918; Anti-Discrimination Act 1977, referred to.
Fittler v New South Wales Electoral Commission & Randwick City Council (No 2) [2008] NSWADT 116 (18 April 2008), considered.

RANKIN v STATE ELECTORAL COMMISSIONER
[2010] SAEOT 3

  1. The complainant, Mr Rankin, complains that he is unable to exercise his right to a secret ballot at State elections, although he is above the age of 18, and enrolled to vote in the electorate of Wright in South Australia.

  2. Mr Rankin has a physical impairment.  He is vision impaired and has been “print blind” as he said, since the age of about 17 years.  He learned to read using the Braille system but as his instruction in the system did not commence at a young age, he does not read Braille as fast or effectively as people who commenced learning the Braille system in their primary school years.  Mr Rankin uses a computer and is able to read and compose and send documents with the assistance of voice software on his computer.

    The Complaints

  3. On 26 June 2007 the Commissioner for Equal Opportunity referred a Complaint by Mr Rankin to this Tribunal at his request; the Commissioner having declined the Complaint. That Complaint, the further and better particulars of which were amended once solicitors were representing Mr Rankin (June 2008) was that the Electoral Commissioner for South Australia had contravened and continued to contravene s 76 of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984, by failing to provide computer assisted voting machines for vision impaired persons at State elections.  This Complaint is action number 224 of 2007 (the First Complaint).  The relief sought was as follows:

    a.that the Commissioner do provide at the next election for the South Australian Parliament and at subsequent elections, computer assisted voting machine facilities such as would permit Rankin and persons with vision impairment, to cast secret ballot votes in compliance with s 79 of the Electoral Act 1985.

    b      such further or other Orders as this Honourable Tribunal deems fit

  4. In October 2008, Mr Rankin sought to amend his Complaint to allow for an alternative argument namely that the Electoral Commissioner should have provided Braille ballot papers to vision impaired persons to permit them to cast a vote by secret ballot.  In addition, Mr Rankin sought to argue that the Commissioner is required to provide Braille ballot papers as an alternative to computer aided voting facilities.  This Tribunal heard argument in relation to the proposed amendment of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rankin v State Electoral Commissioner and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SAEOT 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Rankin, a vision-impaired individual, filed a complaint against the State Electoral Commissioner, alleging discrimination in the electoral process due to the inability to vote without assistance. Rankin argued that the absence of computer-assisted voting, Braille voting, or a combination thereof, created barriers for vision-impaired voters, violating their human rights. The matter was brought before the court to determine the validity of Rankin's complaints and whether the Electoral Commissioner's actions constituted discriminatory practices under the applicable human rights legislation.

The court was tasked with interpreting the scope of human rights legislation in the context of electoral procedures and determining if the Commissioner's failure to provide alternative voting methods for vision-impaired individuals constituted discrimination. The primary legal issue was whether the lack of such methods was a discriminatory practice under the relevant human rights laws and if the Complaints were valid.

The court examined the specific provisions of the human rights legislation and the electoral laws to ascertain if the Commissioner had an obligation to provide computer-assisted or Braille voting. It considered whether the absence of such provisions constituted discrimination against vision-impaired individuals. The court held that the Complaints were valid, and the Commissioner's failure to provide these alternative voting methods did indeed constitute discrimination under the legislation. The court found that the Commissioner had a duty to ensure that all eligible voters, including vision-impaired individuals, could exercise their right to vote without undue assistance.

The court ordered the Commissioner to implement measures to provide computer-assisted voting, Braille voting, or a combination thereof, to ensure that vision-impaired individuals could vote independently and without discrimination. The Commissioner was directed to review and amend existing electoral procedures to comply with the court's decision, ensuring equal access to the electoral process for all eligible voters, regardless of their disability.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established