Randwick City Council v Nancor Trading Co Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Randwick City Council v Nancor Trading Co. Pty Ltd [2002]  NSWCA 108

FILE NUMBER(S):
40655/01

HEARING DATE(S):               27 February 2002

JUDGMENT DATE: 01/05/2002

PARTIES:
Randwick City Council (Appellant)
Nancor Trading Co. Pty Ltd (Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Stein JA Santow JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 204/00

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Rolfe DCJ

COUNSEL:
R  Forster SC/A J Thompson (Appellant)
P  Brereton SC/M Cohen (Respondent)

SOLICITORS:
Bowen & Gerathy (Appellant)
Stephen Wawn & Associates (Respondent)

CATCHWORDS:
LOCAL GOVERNMENT - powers, functions and duties of councils generally - call for tender for the operation of kiosk - tender accepted - kiosk demolished by council - CONTRACT - general contractual principles - offer and acceptance - agreement of terms - Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353 - whether acceptance of tender was conditional - whether a legally binding agreement existed - intention of parties at time of making agreement - construction of the terms of the licence agreement - whether draft plan of management was part of the terms and conditions of the tender - CROSS-APPEAL - costs - District Court Rules, Part 39A rule 25(4) - COSTS - D

LEGISLATION CITED:
District Court Rules, Part 39A rule 25(4)
Local Government Act 1993
Local Government (Tendering) Regulation

DECISION:
1. Appeal allowed in part. 2. The verdict and judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $469,506.46 be set aside and in lieu thereof substitute a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $407,061.00. 3. Set aside his Honour's orders as to costs made on 21 August 2001 and substitute therefor an order that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of the trial on a solicitor and client basis. 4. Order the appellant to pay 80% of the respondent's costs of the appeal. 5. Cross-Appeal allowed with costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT  
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40655/01
DC     204/00

MASON P
STEIN JA
SANTOW JA

Wednesday, 1 May 2002

RANDWICK CITY COUNCIL v NANCOR TRADING CO. PTY LIMITED

The Council was the Manager and Trustee of the Bundock Park Reserve Trust.  The Clovelly Beach Kiosk (the kiosk) was located within this reserve.

In July 1997 the Council called for tenders for the use by way of licence of the kiosk.  Although the respondent’s first tender was unsuccessful, the Council later re-advertised the invitation to tender on 17 November 1997.  In so doing, it invited the respondent, Nancor Trading Co. Pty Limited (Nancor), by way of letter dated 17 November 1997 to submit a fresh tender.

Nancor completed the tender form and lodged it by the required date.  It tendered in the amount of $37,000.00 per annum for the right to licence and operate the kiosk.  The tender form included the condition that ‘the term of the licence will be one (1) year with a five (5) year option’.

The Council resolved on 9 December 1997 to accept Nancor’s tender and wrote…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Randwick City Council v Nancor Trading Co Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] NSWCA 108
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Randwick City Council (the Council) and Nancor Trading Co Pty Ltd (Nancor) were parties to a dispute concerning the operation of a kiosk at Clovelly Beach. The Council had called for tenders for the kiosk, and after Nancor's initial tender was unsuccessful, it was invited to resubmit. Nancor submitted a tender which the Council subsequently accepted. However, the Council later decided to demolish the kiosk, leading to Nancor's claim for damages. The matter was heard in the District Court, and the Council appealed the decision to a higher court.

The central legal issues before the court were whether a legally binding agreement had been formed between the Council and Nancor at the time the Council accepted Nancor's tender, and if so, what were the terms of that agreement. Specifically, the court had to determine if the acceptance of the tender was conditional upon the execution of a formal licence agreement, and whether the draft plan of management formed part of the contractual terms. The court also considered the implications of the Council's subsequent actions, including the partial demolition of the kiosk, on the existence and enforceability of any agreement.

The court found that the parties had reached a binding agreement when the Council accepted Nancor's tender by letter on 15 December 1997. Applying the principles from *Masters v Cameron*, the court determined that the case fell into the category where parties had agreed on all essential terms but intended performance to be conditional on the execution of a formal document. The court rejected the Council's submission that no binding agreement existed until a formal licence was executed, noting inconsistencies in the Council's defence and finding that the Council's conduct, including producing a non-conforming draft licence agreement and unilaterally demolishing part of the kiosk, was the cause of the failure to finalise the formal agreement.

The appeal was allowed in part, with the judgment for Nancor being reduced. The court also substituted an order for Nancor's costs of the trial to be on a solicitor and client basis, and ordered the Council to pay 80% of Nancor's costs of the appeal. Nancor's cross-appeal concerning the costs order was allowed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed in part. 2. The verdict and judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $469,506.46 be set aside and in lieu thereof substitute a verdict and judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $407,061.00. 3. Set aside his Honour's orders as to costs made on 21 August 2001 and substitute therefor an order that the appellant pay the respondent's costs of the trial on a solicitor and client basis. 4. Order the appellant to pay 80% of the respondent's costs of the appeal. 5. Cross-Appeal allowed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent was given leave to file in court a cross-appeal concerning the costs order made by his Honour.Facts The Council was the manager and trustee of the Bundock Park Reserve at Clovelly Beach. Located within the reserve was the Clovelly Beach Kiosk (the kiosk). In July 1997 the Council called for tenders for the use of the Kiosk. The respondent tendered unsuccessfully. However, in late October 1997 the successful tenderer withdrew. The Council then readvertised the tender on 17 November 1997. In so doing, it invited the respondent to submit a fresh tender. The tender was advertised in newspapers on 17, 18 and 19 November 1997 and was to close on 24 November 1997. The Council’s letter to the respondent of 17 November 1997 enclosed ‘the tender specification, licence agreement and tender form’. At the trial the Council contended that the draft Clovelly Beach Plan of Management was also included with the letter but his Honour concluded that he was not satisfied that it was. The respondent submitted a tender on 23 November 1997. It completed the printed tender form offering $37,000 per annum, or a licence fee in that amount, for the right to licence and operate the kiosk. The tender form included the term of the licence (1 year) with a five (5) year option. The tender form also included a reference to the tender being in accordance with the specification issued by the Council and dated 11 November 1997 and an acceptance by the tenderer of the terms and conditions contained in the specification. The tender specification was for a one (1) year licence commencing on 1 January 1998. Licence conditions (1 – 25) were included in the tender specification. They included, inter alia, a five year option. The specification also referred to the ‘draft licence agreement’ which was attached for information. It stated that execution of the licence agreement was required prior to occupation. The draft licence document enclosed with the specification contained the following note:(Note: This document has been prepared for the guidance of intending tenderers and the final deed to be entered into may differ from this document, based on legal advice and the tenders submitted and accepted by Council). The draft licence agreement was substantially in accordance with the specification. On 9 December 1997 the Council resolved to accept the respondent’s tender. Accordingly, it wrote to the respondent on 15 December 1997 setting out Council’s resolution as follows:That the tender of Parks and Cafes [Nancor] for the operation of the Kiosk located Clovelly Beach for a one (1) year period with a five (5) year option commencing 1 January 1998 at an initial annual rental of $37,000 be accepted.The letter continued:The licence is being prepared by Council’s solicitors and I will contact you in the near future to execute the licence and arrange for you to collect the keys to the premises.The terms of the licence require the licence fee to be paid in monthly instalments, in advance. The first monthly instalment of $3,084.00 being due on 1 January, 1998 and an account will be raised from that date.Council congratulates you on your successful tender and wishes you well in your new business.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Between 19 March and 8 April 1998 further discussions took place between the parties about the possibility of rebuilding the kiosk. However, on 8 April 1998 the respondent was told, for the first time, that it was Council’s intention to completely demolish the building. This was reaffirmed to the respondent at a meeting with the Mayor and others on 21 April 1998. On 12 May 1998 the Council resolved that it withdraw the offer of a licence to the respondent for the operation of the kiosk and would proceed to complete the demolition of the building.The judgment of Rolfe DCJ His Honour held that the case fell within the second category identified in Masters v Cameron (1954) 91 CLR 353 at 360. That is, where the parties had completely agreed on all of the terms of their bargain and intend no departure or addition to the agreed terms, but nevertheless have made performance conditional upon the execution of a formal agreement. In particular his Honour said:Although it was submitted on behalf of the Council that it was the intention of the parties not to make a concluded bargain until the licence agreement was executed, I reject this submission. First of all, I consider the submission inconsistent with paragraphs 1 and 3 of the Notice of Grounds of Defence.More importantly, I am satisfied on the evidence that the parties entered into a binding agreement when Council accepted the plaintiff’s tender by its letter dated 15 December 1997. The Agreement required certain matters to be complied with by the plaintiff as was clear from the tender documentation, specifically the execution of a formal licence agreement. In this regard I am satisfied that the failure of the parties to enter into a licence agreement was entirely the fault of the Council, not the plaintiff. First of all, the council produced a draft licence agreement that did not conform with the draft licence agreement which was part of the tender documentation. I have already referred to the areas of departure earlier in this judgment. For its part, the plaintiff sought to have these points of departure addressed by the Council. I am satisfied that both Mr Dwyer and Vescio recognised that the plaintiff’s complaints in this regard were legitimate. Thus, the parties were attempting to finalise these matters when the Council, unilaterally and without consulting the plaintiff, partially demolished the Kiosk on 13 March 1998 so as to make it unfit for occupation and use by the plaintiff. His Honour’s point about the pleadings was appropriate. In its defence the Council admitted that the respondent tendered for a licence to use and occupy the kiosk and that it accepted the respondent’s tender (see paras 6 and 7 of amended statement of claim and para 1 of defence). However, the statement of defence argued that the acceptance of the tender was conditional upon certain things, including the execution of a licence agreement which did not occur. Notwithstanding the ‘pleading point’, his Honour went on to consider whether a final and binding agreement was made between the parties and held that there was when the Council accepted the respondent’s tender by its letter dated 15 December 1997.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established