Randoy Pty Ltd & 12 Others v Rasro Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re: Trade Mark Application 950915(20) – CLASSIQUE Imports - in the name of Rasro Pty Ltd and opposition thereto by Randoy Pty Ltd & Others

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Applicant: Richard McCormack of Counsel, instructed by Richard Payne & Associates, Solicitors
Opponent:  Guy Provan, Barrister and Solicitor
Decision:

2009 ATMO 1
s. 52 opposition: section 58 established – applicant not the owner of the trade mark. Opposition succeeds.
Costs:  Applicant to pay opponents’ costs.

Background

  1. Rasro Pty Ltd (‘the applicant’) filed an application to register a trade mark, current details of which appear below:

    Application number:              950915
    Filing date:  17 April 2003  

    Services specification:          Class 20 Furniture excluding therapy tables, massage tables and portable massage tables

    Endorsements: Provisions of subsection 41(5) applied.

    Trade mark:  CLASSIQUE Imports

    (‘the trade mark’)

  2. The trade mark was accepted for possible registration and advertised for opposition purposes.  Randoy Pty Ltd and twelve others[1] (‘the opponents’) then filed a Notice of Opposition under section 52 of the Trade Mark Act 1995 (‘the Act’), objecting to the registration of the trade mark.

    [1] Kalagala Fox Pty Ltd,
  3. The parties served and filed evidence in accordance with the Trade Mark Regulations 1995 and as described in greater detail later.  The parties then asked to be heard and the matter came before me, Debrett Lyons, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, in Perth on 28 August, 2008.  The applicant was represented by Richard McCormack of Counsel and the opponent was represented by Guy Provan, Barrister and Solicitor.

    Notice of Opposition

  4. The Notice of Opposition cited the following grounds:

    §  trade mark does not distinguish applicant's goods or services – s.41;

    §  trade mark scandalous or its use contrary to law – s.42;

    §  trade mark inherently likely to deceive or cause confusion – s.43;

    §  applicant not the owner of the trade mark – s.58;

    §  trade mark similar to trade mark with a reputation - s.60;

    §  application to the Registrar defective – s.62.

  5. At the hearing the opponents pressed only sections 58 and 62 and accordingly I treat the remaining grounds as having been abandoned.  It was agreed at the start of the hearing that section 58 was of fundamental importance and so with the parties’ permission I asked for submissions on that ground first.  The parties did so and were content to rely on their written submissions in relation to the remaining ground.

    The Evidence

  6. The evidence comprises the following statutory declarations:

    Applicant’s evidence

    vRodger Gerard Boyer made 27 January 2005, together with annexures "RGB-1" to "RGB-20" (First Rodger Boyer Declaration);

    vRodger Gerard Boyer made 18 August 2006, together with annexure "RGB-21" ;

    vRodger Gerard Boyer made 19 December 2006, together with annexures "RGB-22" to "RGB-34";

    vPatrice Jean-Marc Broissand made 19 December 2006, together with annexure "PJB-1";

    vBarry Graham Boyer made 19 December 2006, together with annexure "BGB-1";

    vJohn Wilhelm Pikora made 19 December 2006,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Randoy Pty Ltd & 12 Others v Rasro Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns an opposition to the registration of a trade mark by Randoy Pty Ltd and twelve other parties (the opponents) against Rasro Pty Ltd (the applicant). The dispute arose from the applicant's attempt to register the trade mark "Classique Imports," which the opponents argued they already owned or had rights to. The matter was heard by Debrett Lyons.

The court was required to determine whether the applicant was the owner of the trade mark for the purposes of section 58 of the relevant legislation. This involved assessing the historical development of the "Classique Imports" business, the relationships between the founding parties and subsequent entrants, and the nature of their use of the trade mark. The court had to consider whether the arrangements constituted a partnership or a joint venture, and how the trade mark rights were held and exercised within this structure.

The court found that, based on the evidence presented, the applicant was not the owner of the trade mark. The reasoning focused on the historical establishment of the "Classique Imports" business, which began as a loosely defined commercial enterprise or joint adventure involving several parties. While a company, Classique Imports Pty Ltd (later Matahari Pty Ltd), was incorporated, the court noted that a partnership of the four original parties, referred to as the CI Partnership, continued to operate the retail stores. The subsequent expansion involved new store owners operating under the common trade mark through a consensual arrangement, rather than a formal franchise agreement. The court concluded that these arrangements did not establish the applicant as the owner of the trade mark.

Consequently, the opposition was successful, and the court refused to register the application. The applicant was ordered to pay the opponents' costs, with the payment to be made to a nominated trust account for apportionment among the interested opponents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

In the result, this decision is based on all of the evidence sought to be relied upon by the parties. Factual Background Synoptically, the background to the dispute is as follows. In 1995 there was a business established in Mount Waverly, Western Australia under the name “Classique Imports” which essentially imported and then retailed Indonesian made furniture. The three founding interests[2] in that business – Messrs Boyer, Boyer and Broissand -have been described in the evidence as partners. Whether or not it is correct to describe their relationship as a partnership, I am at this moment content with the applicant’s submission which characterized the relationship as being at least a “joint adventure in the sense of a loosely defined commercial enterprise”.[2] Overlooking trusts or corporate structures which they may have owned or controlled. In 1997 those parties opened a second “Classique Imports” retail shop selling essentially the same goods and at approximately the same time a fourth party, Greive Holdings Pty Ltd took an interest in the business. The four parties formed a new and separate corporate entity, Classique Imports Pty Ltd (‘CIPL’) of which they each became 25% shareholders, either individually or through companies they controlled. Notwithstanding the incorporation of CIPL, it is alleged that a partnership comprised of the four parties continued and it is this group of four that will hereafter be referred to as ‘the CI Partnership’ and the individuals as ‘the CI Partners’. When CIPL later changed name to Matahari Pty Ltd (‘Matahari’) it was with the intention that thereafter it would concern itself with the importation and warehousing part of the business whilst the CI Partnership would continue to run the stores, which by that time existed at a number of locations, all of which stores traded under the name “Classique Imports”. In 2001 a meeting was held at which it was agreed that the CI Partners would each run and take individual responsibility for his or its own stores, all continuing to operate under the common trade mark. Thereafter, the evidence is of the simplest of business plans whereby the CI Partners would by consensus expand the business by admitting new users of the trade mark at new owner-operated stores provided that each such store was no closer than 10 kilometres from an existing store, and the new owner was willing to pool funds with the CI Partners for the purposes of common advertising and bulk purchasing power. Newcomers otherwise made no payment to the CI Partners for the benefit of joining the consortium of shops operating under the one name. None of these arrangements was reduced to writing and legal characterization of the relationship between the CI Partners and the new store owners is far from easy. Likewise, the terms of use of the trade mark were unspecified and took the form of a common permission or implied consensual license, albeit that at one point there was consideration by the CI Partners of a draft ‘franchise agreement’. That agreement was never formalized or used but it is noteworthy that the proposed franchisor was Matahari.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence comprises the following statutory declarations:Applicant’s evidence vRodger Gerard Boyer made 27 January 2005, together with annexures "RGB-1" to "RGB-20" (First Rodger Boyer Declaration);vRodger Gerard Boyer made 18 August 2006, together with annexure "RGB-21" ;vRodger Gerard Boyer made 19 December 2006, together with annexures "RGB-22" to "RGB-34";vPatrice Jean-Marc Broissand made 19 December 2006, together with annexure "PJB-1";vBarry Graham Boyer made 19 December 2006, together with annexure "BGB-1";vJohn Wilhelm Pikora made 19 December 2006, together with annexures "JWP-1" and "JWP-2";vBarry Graham Boyer made 27 August 2007, together with annexure "BGB-2"; andvRodger Gerard Boyer made 27 August 2007, together with annexures "RGB-35" to "RGB-37”.Opponent’s evidencevJennifer Joy Grieve made 3 February 2006, together with annexures "JG-1" to "JG-9";vGuy William Provan made 3 February 2006, together with annexures "GWP-1" to "GWP-5";vGuy William Provan made 6 March 2007, together with annexures "GWP-6" and "GWP-7";vWayne Peppernell made 6 March 2007, together with annexures "WP-1" and "WP-2";vDoreen Dorothy Kelly made 6 March 2007;vJennifer Joy Grieve made 6 March 2007, together with annexures "JG-10" to "JG-12" ;vNicole Frances Roberts made 7 March 2007, together with annexures "NR-1" to "NR-7".Other evidencevBoth parties petitioned the Registrar to issue Notices to Produce under section 202 of the Act. Unsworn documents produced under those directions but not comprehensively listed here have also been considered in making this decision.Admissibility of the First Rodger Boyer Declaration The First Rodger Boyer Declaration was made on 27 January 2005, before the Notice of Opposition. It was made in support of the application when it was still under examination. The application was accepted under the provisions of section 41(5). The examiner’s notes show that the application was accepted in the face of a number of section 44 citations, being trade mark numbers 659663, 730354, 787323, 918148. After written argument, objection based on trade mark numbers 730354 and 787323 was withdrawn, and on the basis of a specification amendment trade mark number 659663 was overcome. The First Rodger Boyer Declaration overcame trade mark numbers 659663 and 918148, the latter lapsing afterwards in any event. The First Rodger Boyer Declaration was not served and filed in the opposition proceedings by the applicant and would ordinarily be inadmissible. Nevertheless, at the Hearing, I raised this matter and Mr Provan indicated that he had no objection to admission of that evidence notwithstanding the formal defect. In the result, this decision is based on all of the evidence sought to be relied upon by the parties. Factual Background Synoptically, the background to the dispute is as follows. In 1995 there was a business established in Mount Waverly, Western Australia under the name “Classique Imports” which essentially imported and then retailed Indonesian made furniture.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In short, there is nothing in the evidence or in the applicant’s submissions to make me depart from my finding that for the purposes of section 58 the applicant was not the owner of the trade mark.Decision and Costs The opposition succeeds since a ground of opposition has been established. I therefore refuse to register the application. I order that the applicant pay the opponents’ costs according to the official scale. Despite the multiplicity of opponents, there was one Notice of Opposition and the matter proceeded on evidence common to all opponents. For that reason there is no reason that each opponent should be able to claim costs. On the other hand, the Notice of Opposition originally named thirteen opponents. By the time of the hearing, their number had reduced and Greive Holdings Pty Ltd is shown by the evidence to have already been dissolved. In these unclear circumstances, I direct that the applicant make payment to the nominated trust account of Mr Provan, who has acted for all opponents, in the understanding that it is he who will make proper apportionment as between the interested opponents.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.