Administrative Appeals Tribunal
DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2011] AATA 375
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No 2010/4074
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION ) Re SAMUEL RANDAZZO Applicant
And
CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member
Dr M E C Thorpe, MemberDate1 June 2011
PlaceSydney
Decision 1) The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review of CASA dated 13 September 2010, and in substitution decides that Mr Randazzo should be issued with a Class 2 medical certificate for 12 months from the date of this Decision.
2) The Class 2 medical certificate shall be issued with the following conditions:
a) Concerning Mr Randazzo’s atrial fibrillation; from the date of this Decision, he must provide CASA with progress reports every three months from his cardiologist detailing:
· any occurrence of atrial fibrillation;
· any symptoms;
· results of stress ECG including rate control;
· 48hr Holter;
· echocardiogram;
· treatment, response to treatment and side effects;
· confirmation of diagnosis; and,
· prognosis, including risk of adverse sequelae (including thromboembolism).
b) Concerning Mr Randazzo’s GIST; from the date of this Decision he must provide CASA with a (three monthly) report from his oncologist every three months updating:
· the diagnosis;
· results of any investigations (blood tests, scans, etc);
· treatment, response and any side-effects;
· prognosis; and,
· follow-up plan.
3) When Mr Randazzo’s Medical Certificate becomes due for renewal, in addition to the standard renewal medical examination report, he must provide CASA:
a) a progress report regarding the GIST from his oncologist including results of recent staging investigations, treatment, side-effects and prognosis;
b) a progress report regarding the atrial fibrillation from his cardiologist including results of recent staging investigations, treatment, side-effects and prognosis;
c) a copy of his GP medical records and reports for the previous 12 months.
4) Mr Randazzo will be responsible for the costs of all the reports.
5) Mr Randazzo’s aviation medical certificate is to be endorsed Renew by CASA Only. This alerts the Designated Aviation Medical Examiners that only Aviation Medicine can revalidate the certificate after assessment of the required reports.
..............................................
Ms G Ettinger
Senior Member
REASONS FOR DECISION
1 June 2011 Ms G Ettinger, Senior Member
Dr M E C Thorpe, MemberSUMMARY
1. Mr Samuel Randazzo, who is 73 years old, has held a private pilot’s licence since 1963 – that is, for approximately 46 years. When it came to the Civil Aviation Safety Authority’s (CASA) attention that on renewing his licence, Mr Randazzo had not disclosed various health conditions to it over a period of time, his application for a Class 2 medical certificate was refused. That was on 13 September 2010. Following that, on 2 December 2010, CASA issued a Class 2 medical certificate for the period of 12 months with various conditions, including the condition that Mr Randazzo only fly with a safety pilot.
2. The medical conditions about which CASA is particularly concerned are the possibility of recurrence of a gastrointestinal…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read RANDAZZO and CIVIL AVIATION SAFETY AUTHORITY and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] AATA 375
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues the AAT had to decide were whether CASA’s refusal of Mr Randazzo’s medical certificate application was lawful and whether the conditions proposed by the AAT for the issuance of the certificate were appropriate. The AAT examined the relevant sections of the Civil Aviation Act 1988 and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998, considering precedent cases such as Re Hall and Mulholland, Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority, and Hogan v Civil Aviation Safety Authority. The AAT also assessed the medical evidence provided by Mr Randazzo's treating specialists, ensuring that the proposed conditions for the medical certificate were both necessary for safety and reasonable for the applicant.
The AAT concluded that CASA’s decision to refuse Mr Randazzo's application was not legally sound. The Tribunal found that Mr Randazzo could safely fly alone if specific conditions were met. These conditions included regular reporting from his cardiologist and oncologist regarding his atrial fibrillation and GIST, respectively. The AAT also determined that Mr Randazzo should bear the costs of these reports and that his medical certificate should be endorsed as "Renew by CASA Only," ensuring that only CASA could revalidate the certificate. This decision was made to ensure that only qualified aviation medical examiners could assess Mr Randazzo’s ongoing fitness to fly.
In its orders, the AAT set aside CASA’s decision dated 13 September 2010 and substituted it with a decision to issue Mr Randazzo a Class 2 medical certificate for a period of 12 months, subject to the aforementioned conditions. The AAT also specified that Mr Randazzo would be responsible for the costs of the required reports and that his medical certificate would be endorsed to restrict renewal to CASA only. This ensures that Mr Randazzo’s ongoing medical status is continuously monitored and assessed by the appropriate aviation medical authorities.
Orders
Orders of the court
1) The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review of CASA dated 13 September 2010, and in substitution decides that Mr Randazzo should be issued with a Class 2 medical certificate for 12 months from the date of this Decision.
2) The Class 2 medical certificate shall be issued with the following conditions:
a) Concerning Mr Randazzo’s atrial fibrillation; from the date of this Decision, he must provide CASA with progress reports every three months from his cardiologist detailing:
· any occurrence of atrial fibrillation;
· any symptoms;
· results of stress ECG including rate control;
· 48hr Holter;
· echocardiogram;
· treatment, response to treatment and side effects;
· confirmation of diagnosis; and,
· prognosis, including risk of adverse sequelae (including thromboembolism).
b) Concerning Mr Randazzo’s GIST; from the date of this Decision he must provide CASA with a (three monthly) report from his oncologist every three months updating:
· the diagnosis;
· results of any investigations (blood tests, scans, etc);
· treatment, response and any side-effects;
· prognosis; and,
· follow-up plan.
3) When Mr Randazzo’s Medical Certificate becomes due for renewal, in addition to the standard renewal medical examination report, he must provide CASA:
a) a progress report regarding the GIST from his oncologist including results of recent staging investigations, treatment, side-effects and prognosis;
b) a progress report regarding the atrial fibrillation from his cardiologist including results of recent staging investigations, treatment, side-effects and prognosis;
c) a copy of his GP medical records and reports for the previous 12 months.
4) Mr Randazzo will be responsible for the costs of all the reports.
5) Mr Randazzo’s aviation medical certificate is to be endorsed Renew by CASA Only. This alerts the Designated Aviation Medical Examiners that only Aviation Medicine can revalidate the certificate after assessment of the required reports.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) as an appeal against the decision of CASA dated 13 September 2010. Mr Randazzo had appealed the decision of CASA to refuse his application for a Class 2 medical certificate. The Tribunal heard evidence and considered medical reports before making its decision to set aside the CASA decision and substitute its own decision regarding the issuance of a medical certificate with conditions.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1) Whether Mr Randazzo should be issued with a Class 2 medical certificate.
2) If so, what conditions should be attached to the issuance of the medical certificate.
Held
1) The court held that Mr Randazzo should be issued with a Class 2 medical certificate, setting aside the decision under review by CASA dated 13 September 2010.
2) The court further held that the Class 2 medical certificate should be issued with specific conditions concerning Mr Randazzo’s atrial fibrillation and GIST, as detailed in the orders.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the statutory framework provided by the Civil Aviation Act 1988 (Cth) and the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations 1998 (Cth), which set out the requirements for the issuance of medical certificates to pilots. The court found that the Civil Aviation Safety Authority (CASA) had not properly considered the evidence and the medical reports submitted by Mr Randazzo, who has been a private pilot for 40 years. The Tribunal was satisfied with the medical reports, which demonstrated that Mr Randazzo could safely fly alone with certain conditions. The decision to deny Mr Randazzo a medical certificate was therefore flawed and set aside.
In addressing the conditions to be attached to the issuance of the medical certificate, the court emphasised the importance of ongoing medical monitoring and reporting to ensure the safety of Mr Randazzo’s operations as a pilot. The conditions imposed on Mr Randazzo required him to submit regular progress reports from his cardiologist and oncologist, detailing his atrial fibrillation and GIST, respectively. This requirement ensures CASA is kept informed of his health status and any changes that might impact his ability to fly.
The court also noted that the conditions were proportionate to the risks associated with Mr Randazzo's health conditions. It referred to previous cases such as Re Hall and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2004] AATA 21 and Re Mulholland and Civil Aviation Safety Authority [2007] AATA 1952, which underscored the necessity of tailored medical conditions for pilots with specific health concerns. By endorsing the medical certificate with "Renew by CASA Only," the court ensured that only qualified aviation medical examiners could revalidate the certificate, maintaining the high safety standards required in civil aviation.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that when assessing the fitness of a pilot with significant health conditions, the Civil Aviation Safety Authority must consider all relevant and reliable medical evidence and may impose specific reporting conditions to ensure ongoing safety, provided those conditions are proportionate and necessary.