Ramlan Abdul Samad v Phosphate Resources Ltd T/A Christmas Island Phosphates

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read
[2024] FWC 3039

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Ramlan Abdul Samad
v

Phosphate Resources Ltd T/A Christmas Island Phosphates

(U2024/7715)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT O’KEEFFE

PERTH, 1 NOVEMBER 2024

Remedy for unfair dismissal – reinstatement inappropriate – compensation ordered.

  1. In my decision [2024] FWC 2868 (PR780293) I found that Mr Ramlan Abdul Samad (the Applicant) had been unfairly dismissed from his employment with Phosphate Resources Limited (the Respondent).  Following the publication of that decision, I conducted two conferences between the parties to determine if they could agree on a remedy.  The parties could not reach agreement and so I invited them to make additional written submissions on the subject of remedy.  These submissions were received on 30 October 2024 and the submissions on reinstatement are summarised as follows.

Reinstatement - submissions

  1. With respect to reinstatement, the Applicant submitted that s.390(3) of the Act prioritises reinstatement and that there were no grounds for finding that reinstatement was not appropriate.  He submitted that while the Respondent opposed reinstatement, the FWC could not base a decision not to reinstate solely on the opposition of the Respondent.   The Applicant further submitted that in any case, the Respondent did not have any valid reason to oppose reinstatement.

  1. It was the Applicant’s view that there was no merit in the Respondent’s position that reinstatement would undermine its system of complaint and punishment and act as a barrier to future complaints by employees.  Instead, the Applicant proposed in essence that if dismissal was the likely outcome of a complaint, employees might be less likely to complain about a fellow employee.

  1. Finally, the Applicant noted that the reasons why his dismissal was found to be unfair were relevant reasons as to why reinstatement was appropriate.  Those reasons were the lack of employment opportunities on Christmas Island, the Applicant’s age – being 62 – and his long service without any recorded prior incidents of behaviour similar to that which led to his termination.

  1. The Respondent submitted that reinstatement was not appropriate.  Primarily, it submitted that there was a breakdown of trust and confidence between the parties meaning that the working relationship had been irreparably damaged.  The evidence of this breakdown was submitted to be demonstrated by a number of factors.  In the first instance, the Respondent highlighted the fact that I had found that there was a valid reason for termination and the actions that gave rise to that valid reason undermined trust and confidence in the Applicant.

  1. This loss of trust was submitted to be exacerbated by my finding[1] that the Applicant had been an evasive witness and that where there had been a discrepancy between his evidence and the evidence of the Respondent’s witnesses I had preferred the Respondent’s evidence.  The Respondent further submitted that there was a lack of remorse shown by the Applicant and that he had engaged in “victim-blaming.”  In support of this submission it noted comments in my decision where I found this to be the case.[2]

  1. The Respondent also…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ramlan Abdul Samad v Phosphate Resources Ltd T/A Christmas I... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FWC 3039
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Fair Work Commission, the Deputy President, O’Keeffe, heard a case concerning the unfair dismissal of Mr Ramlan Abdul Samad from his employment with Phosphate Resources Ltd. The Applicant alleged that his dismissal was unfair and sought reinstatement or, failing that, compensation. The Respondent opposed any form of reinstatement, asserting that the relationship of trust and confidence had been irreparably damaged due to the Applicant's misconduct. The Deputy President examined the submissions from both parties, considering whether reinstatement was appropriate under section 390(3) of the Fair Work Act 2009. The Deputy President found that the Respondent had not provided sufficient evidence to support its claim of a loss of trust and confidence. The Respondent's assertion that trust and confidence had been lost was based on factors such as the Applicant's evasiveness during testimony and the severity of the bullying, but these did not meet the required standard of proof. The Deputy President also considered the impact of reinstatement on the Complainant, Mr Rahman, who had been subjected to the Applicant’s bullying and harassment. Given the likelihood of continued conflict and the lack of an apology from the Applicant, the Deputy President concluded that reinstatement would not be appropriate.

Following this determination, the Deputy President turned to the question of compensation. The Deputy President calculated the compensation amount by considering the remuneration the Applicant would have received if not dismissed, any earnings since the dismissal, and other relevant factors such as the length of service and the impact of the order on the Respondent's viability. The Deputy President deducted amounts for contingencies, efforts to mitigate loss, and the Applicant's misconduct, ultimately determining that the appropriate compensation was $33,076.13, which falls below the compensation cap. The Deputy President ordered the Respondent to pay this amount to the Applicant within fourteen days of the order.