Ralph Lauren 57 Pty Ltd v Byron Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

Court of Appeal

New South Wales

Case Title: Ralph Lauren 57 Pty Limited v Byron Shire Council
Medium Neutral Citation: [2014] NSWCA 107
Hearing Date(s): 21 October 2013
Decision Date: 07 April 2014
Before: Beazley P at [1];
Ward JA at [2];
Preston CJ of LEC at [3]
Decision:

(1) Dismiss each summons seeking leave to appeal in proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401 against the decision of Sheahan J of the Land and Environment Court of NSW on 20 December 2012.

(2) Dismiss each notice of motion filed on 23 September 2013 in proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401 seeking an order to discharge the orders and decision of Leeming JA of this Court on 9 September 2013.

(3) Dismiss each notice of motion filed on 11 October 2013 in proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401 seeking an order that this Court receive into evidence certain documents.

(4) Order the applicants to pay the first respondent's costs of proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401.

Catchwords: COSTS - discontinued proceedings - whether primary judge erred in ordering parties to pay own costs - whether discontinuing plaintiff achieved practical success - whether achieving some practical success sufficient to justify costs in discontinuing plaintiff's favour - whether defendant had acted unreasonably - primary judge did not err - leave to appeal refused

PROCEDURE - leave to reopen - whether primary judge erred in refusing to grant leave to reopen - whether sufficient justification given to reopen - no sufficient justification given - primary judge's decision did not involve an error of law - primary judge's decision did not cause substantial injustice - leave to appeal refused

PROCEDURE - Court of Appeal - review of decision of single judge of appeal - decision that party had not waived privilege by serving written submissions - applicants not demonstrated relevant error in single appeal judge's decision - application to discharge decision dismissed

EVIDENCE - appeal against costs decision - application to receive evidence on the appeal - whether special grounds justifying receiving the documents into evidence - applicants failed to establish that evidence would have led to a different costs decision by primary judge - notice of motion dismissed
Legislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 s 98
Coastal Protection Act 1979 s 55G
Evidence Act 1995 s 122
Supreme Court Act 1970 ss 46(4), 75A, 101(2)(e),
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 rr 42.19, 51.2, 51.58
Cases Cited: Akins v National Australia Bank (1994) 34 NSWLR 155
Australiawide Airlines Ltd v Aspirion Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 365
Australian Securities Commission v Aust-Home Investments Ltd (1993) 44 FCR 194
Bitannia Pty Ltd v Parkline Constructions Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 32
Collier v Lancer [2013] NSWCA 185
Cooper v Hobbs [2013] NSWCA 70
Edwards Madigan Torhillo Briggs Pty Ltd v Gloria Stack [2003] NSWCA 302
Fordyce v Fordham [2006] NSWCA 274; (2006) 67 NSWLR 497
Foukkare v Angreb Pty Ltd [2006] NSWCA 335
Hall v Ku-ring-gai Council [2009] NSWSC 370
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
In re the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ralph Lauren 57 Pty Ltd v Byron Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWCA 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Ralph Lauren 57 Pty Ltd and others, sought leave to appeal decisions of the Land and Environment Court of NSW and the Court of Appeal concerning costs and the refusal to reopen proceedings. The primary dispute revolved around whether the applicants, as the discontinuing party, should have been awarded their costs against the respondent, Byron Shire Council, following the Council's withdrawal of a draft CZMP. The applicants argued that the Council's withdrawal constituted a capitulation, entitling them to costs.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine whether the primary judge erred in ordering the parties to bear their own costs, despite the applicants discontinuing their proceedings. This involved considering whether the applicants had achieved practical success sufficient to justify an award of costs in their favour, and whether the Council had acted unreasonably. Additionally, the court considered whether the primary judge erred in refusing to grant leave to reopen the proceedings, and whether sufficient justification had been provided for such a reopening. The court also addressed applications to receive new evidence on appeal and to discharge a prior decision regarding waiver of privilege.

The Court of Appeal found that the applicants had not established any error in the primary judge's discretionary decisions regarding costs or the refusal to reopen. The applicants' argument for costs was based on a flawed premise that the Council's withdrawal of the draft CZMP automatically entitled them to costs. The court reiterated that the discontinuing party bears the onus of establishing grounds for an alternative costs order, and the applicants failed to demonstrate a sufficient factual basis or persuasive argument for such an order. The primary judge had correctly applied this onus.

Consequently, each summons seeking leave to appeal was dismissed. The applications to discharge a prior decision and to receive new evidence on appeal were also dismissed. The applicants were ordered to pay the first respondent's costs of the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Dismiss each summons seeking leave to appeal in proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401 against the decision of Sheahan J of the Land and Environment Court of NSW on 20 December 2012.

(2) Dismiss each notice of motion filed on 23 September 2013 in proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401 seeking an order to discharge the orders and decision of Leeming JA of this Court on 9 September 2013.

(3) Dismiss each notice of motion filed on 11 October 2013 in proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401 seeking an order that this Court receive into evidence certain documents.

(4) Order the applicants to pay the first respondent's costs of proceedings CA 2013/13396 and 2013/13401.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

PRESTON CJ
The applicants have not established any error in the primary judge's decisions as to costs or reopening sufficient to warrant appellate intervention in these discretionary decisions.The decision as to costs In relation to the costs decision, the foundation and the steps in the reasoning of the applicants' argument in the court below, and on the applications for leave to appeal are flawed. The applicants' argument for a costs order in their favour was founded on the assertion that the Council's resolution of 14 April 2011 to withdraw the draft CZMP demonstrated that the Council had capitulated or surrendered to the applicants by "delivering the very relief which the applicants had sought". From this foundation, the applicants' argument then proceeded by the following steps. First, the alleged capitulation or surrender of the Council established a prima facie position that the applicants should have their costs paid by the Council. Second, the Council bore the onus of displacing the prima facie position by proving that there was some explanation for the withdrawal of the draft CZMP that was inconsistent with the prima facie position that it should pay the applicants' costs of the proceedings. Third, the Council failed to establish an explanation for its withdrawal of the draft CZMP which displaced the prima facie position. The Council's explanations for the withdrawal of the draft CZMP were contrary to the evidence. Hence, the proper exercise of the costs discretion remained that the applicants should have their costs paid by the Council. This foundation and these steps in the reasoning process involved error. At the outset, it needs to borne in mind that the applicants bore the onus of establishing that the court below should make a costs order in their favour. As the discontinuing party, the applicants had to be the moving party to apply for an alternative costs order to that provided for in r 42.19(2). They had to establish some positive ground or good reason for making the alternative costs order sought. They bore the onus of proving the relevant primary facts, and the particular inferences that should be drawn from those facts, so as to establish the factual basis for the alternative costs order they sought. Finally, they bore the burden of persuading the court that the alternative costs order for which they contended was appropriate: see Bitannia v Parkline Constructions Pty Ltd at [70]. The applicants did not formally make an application for an alternative costs order in the court below. Leave was granted by the court below for the applicants to discontinue their proceedings with the question of costs being reserved. The applicants did not file a notice of motion seeking an alternative costs order. Rather, they sought such an order at the hearing of the reserved question of costs. This lack of formality in making application for an alternative costs order to that in r 42.19(2) may have contributed to the applicants' misapprehension of who bore the onus to establish that the court should make the costs order the applicant sought and to establish the factual basis for such an order. The applicants were incorrect in submitting before this court that the primary judge misplaced the onus on the applicants; to the contrary, the primary judge correctly applied the onus when he concluded that the applicants had made no real case for them to recover any of their costs from the respondents (at [254]).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PRESTON CJ