| [2024] FWC 2635 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739—Dispute resolution
Rainer Kiessling
v
Fire Rescue Victoria
(C2024/2106)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT COLMAN | MELBOURNE, 25 SEPTEMBER 2024 |
Dispute arising under enterprise agreement – dispute determined
Rainer Kiessling has made an application under s 739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) and the dispute resolution procedure in clause 26 of the Fire Rescue Victoria Operational Employees Interim Enterprise Agreement 2020 (Agreement) by which he asks the Commission to determine his dispute with Fire Rescue Victoria (FRV). Mr Kiessling contends that FRV has acted unfairly and unlawfully by restricting his ability to apply for higher duties positions on the basis that he is a lateral recruit from the South Australian fire service who is ‘tenured’ to a position in Hamilton for three years. Mr Kiessling asks the Commission to make determinations that would require FRV to consider his higher duties applications without treating him differently because of his tenured status. He also asks the Commission to require FRV to develop policies governing the manner in which higher duties applications are determined.
Briefly stated, the background is as follows. Clause 48.6 of the Agreement allows FRV to recruit lateral entry firefighters from outside Victoria. FRV utilises lateral entries for vacancies in remote locations that have proved difficult to fill. It requires lateral entries to remain in the relevant position for an initial ‘tenured’ period. On 14 April 2022, Mr Kiessling accepted an offer of employment from FRV for a commander position in Hamilton, on secondment to the Country Fire Authority (CFA). The letter of employment signed by Mr Kiessling stated that he agreed to ‘remain in the nominated position for an initial period of 3 years’ concluding on 25 April 2025 (‘the 3-year tenure requirement’), and that after that time he would be able to ‘transfer to other positions’. The letter did not state that there were any restrictions on Mr Kiessling applying for higher duties positions.
Soon after arriving in Hamilton, Mr Kiessling began to apply for higher duties roles in other locations, but without success. Mr Kiessling considered that higher duties positions, which are temporary appointments, were not ‘transfers’ to other positions. FRV did not dispute this. However, in October 2022, FRV told Mr Kiessling that it was not contemplated that lateral entries would seek higher duties roles away from their tenured locations, and that they would be confined to applying for any higher duties roles in their ‘home’ district, meaning the district in which their tenured position was located (‘the higher duties limitation’). For Mr Kiessling, this was district 5 in southwestern Victoria. This limitation would apply until the end of the tenure period. Mr Kiessling believed that there was nothing that legally prevented him from applying for any higher duties positions in FRV. In June 2023, he lodged a dispute in the Commission under clause 26 of the Agreement. He asked the Commission to determine numerous grievances, one of which was whether the Agreement or his letter of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rainer Kiessling v Fire Rescue Victoria and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] FWC 2635
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
FRV denies that the 3-year tenure requirement or the higher duties limitation are unfair or unlawful or that it has acted unreasonably or unlawfully in connection with Kiessling’s applications for higher duties positions or otherwise. The Commission must determine whether the 3-year tenure requirement and the higher duties limitation are unfair or unlawful.
The Commission finds that the 3-year tenure requirement and the higher duties limitation are neither unfair nor unlawful. The 3-year tenure requirement is a reasonable and legitimate response to an operational problem, and Kiessling had understood and accepted the terms on which he was being offered employment with FRV. The higher duties limitation prevents Kiessling, as a tenured lateral recruit, from applying for higher duties roles outside his district during the tenure period. The Commission finds nothing unfair about this, as a person who has agreed to perform a hard-to-fill job in a remote location for a fixed period should honour that commitment. The Commission also finds that the 3-year tenure requirement and the higher duties limitation are not unlawful, as they do not contravene the terms of the Agreement, the Act, state legislation, Kiessling’s contract of employment, or any other legal requirements.
The Commission determines that FRV has not acted unfairly or unlawfully in its treatment of Kiessling in relation to the matters raised in his submissions. Accordingly, there is no basis for the Commission to require FRV to revisit any of Kiessling’s past applications for higher duties; to alter the manner in which it considers applications for higher duties positions from tenured lateral recruits like Kiessling; to lift or alter the 3-year tenure requirement for such recruits; or to create or publish any policies in relation to these matters.
The Commission determines the dispute that has been referred to it accordingly.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi