Rainbow Shores Pty Ltd v Gympie Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2012] QPEC 6

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

JUDGE RACKEMANN

P & E Appeal No 2768 of 2009

RAINBOW SHORES PTY LTD Appellant

and

GYMPIE REGIONAL COUNCIL Respondent

and

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENT AND RESOURCE MANAGEMENT

and

J LAWLER

and

M LAWLER

and

R RUESCHER

and

S RUESCHER

and

E DEVEREUX

and

CITIZENS HELPING INSKIP PENINSULA

and

REGINALD ROSS LAWLER

and

RAINBOW BEACH COMMERCE AND TOURISM ASSOCIATION INC

and

GREGORY DAVID WOOD

and

FIONA HAWTHORNE

and

VIVIEN GRIFFIN

and

NATIONAL PARKS ASSOCIATION OF QLD

and

COOLOOLA COASTCARE ASSOC INC

and

CHIEF EXECUTIVE, DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT AND MAIN ROADS

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

Co-Respondent

BRISBANE

..DATE 09/02/2012

..DAY 1

HIS HONOUR:  This is an application by which the co-respondent seeks leave for its waste water disposal expert to provide additional statements of evidence, which contain opinions which depart from opinions expressed in earlier joint reports.

Rule 30, sub-rule 3, provides that a further statement of evidence, in addition to a joint report, must not, without the Court's leave, contradict, depart from or qualify an opinion in relation to an issue the subject of an agreement in the joint report or raise a new matter, not already mentioned in the joint report.

In this case, the evidence sought to be adduced is from a Mr Gardner.  Mr Gardner is an expert who was belated notified by the co-respondent, late last year, in circumstances where I was prepared to make orders allowing the co-respondent to do so.  There are some matters of reserved costs from those applications.

At the time that leave was sought to notify Mr Gardner as an expert in the matter, and have him give evidence, reference was made to concerns which he then held in relation to the work which had been done by Mr Bristow, the appellant's waste water engineer.  Those concerns included concerns about the model which Mr Bristow was using, namely, the Medlii model.

Having notified Mr Gardner as an expert, joint meetings were held in the usual way, and a joint report was delivered in which the experts had reached agreement about the suitability of the proposed effluent disposal, and indeed about its potential to deal not only with effluent from the subject site, but to deal with effluent from the entire locality - A matter which would be, on the face of it, a significant community benefit, because of constraints with the council's existing methods of disposal of effluent.

When Mr Bristow was giving evidence, a question was raised about different areas of land for irrigation that were referred to in the joint report.  I asked that the experts again speak, simply to clarify which of the areas mentioned they were intending to refer to.  This provoked a further report, which was entitled Joint Report 7, which has been admitted as Exhibit 56 in the case.

In that report the experts answered the question which had been raised, but then the co-respondent's expert went…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rainbow Shores Pty Ltd v Gympie Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QPEC 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Rainbow Shores Pty Ltd v Gympie Regional Council, the applicant sought leave to call an expert witness to provide additional evidence that departed from a previously agreed joint report. The respondent, Gympie Regional Council, had belatedly identified the expert and the applicant objected to the new evidence on the grounds that it would contradict the joint report and raise new matters. The court considered whether it was appropriate to grant leave for the expert to provide additional evidence, and if so, whether to order the respondent to compensate the applicant for the costs incurred due to the late introduction of the new evidence.

The court found that the general prohibition on experts departing from the position in a joint report, unless by leave, served several purposes, including ensuring that experts treat the joint report process with appropriate respect and that trial preparation can proceed on the basis of some certainty as to the expressed views. The court also noted that the requirement to obtain leave ensured that any departure was accompanied by an explanation of the circumstances and reasons for the departure. In this case, the court was prepared to accept that the expert's change of position was genuine, and so granted leave for the expert to provide additional evidence.

In terms of costs, the court ordered that the respondent pay the applicant's costs of and incidental to the application for leave on a standard basis, but certified for one counsel only. The court reserved decision on the costs thrown away by the grant of leave, as it could not make a decision without hearing the evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established