[2011] QDC 284
DISTRICT COURT
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
JUDGE DEVEREAUX SC
No 590 of 2011
| OLIVIA RAGUS | Appellant |
| and | |
| KEVIN STAIT AND HELEN STAIT | Respondents |
BRISBANE
..DATE 28/10/2011
JUDGMENT
CATCHWORDS
PROCEDURE - PEACE AND GOOD BEHAVIOUR ACT SECTION 4 - whether acts alleged against respondents sufficiently serious to require an order under the Act
PROCEDURE - PEACE AND GOOD BEHAVIOUR ACT SECTION 4 - where the complaint concerned the threat of assault to complainant's daughter, it was not necessary to join the child as complainant.
HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal under section 222 of the Justices Act against orders made by Magistrate Daley on 1 February 2011.
The appellant Ms Ragus made two complaints under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982 against Kevin Stait and Helen Stait, the respondents.
The complaint against Kevin Stait was filed on 6 December 2010. The complaint against Helen Stait was filed on 8 December 2010 and both complaints were listed for hearing before her Honour on the 1st of February this year. It's on that date that her Honour dismissed the complaints after hearing evidence.
The materials filed in the Magistrates Court before her Honour were two affidavits of Ms Ragus, one in respect of each of her two complaints; affidavit of Elizabeth Ponsaing, which was filed by the respondents; affidavit of Isabella Ragus who is the appellant's daughter and affidavit of Colin Balchin, filed for the appellant.
Her Honour heard evidence from the appellant Ms Ragus, Colin Balchin and the respondents Kevin and Helen Stait and two witnesses, their daughter Michelle Stait and Elizabeth Ponsaing. At the end of the proceedings, her Honour dismissed the two complaints.
There are six grounds of appeal. Before I address the grounds of appeal, I'll put on record the process of this appeal has taken. The appeal came before me last week on Friday the 21st of October 2011. In the days before that, the appellant contacted the court saying she was too ill to appear and she filed material. She sought that the hearing be adjourned so that she could prepare some further submissions.
The respondents, Mr and Mrs Stait appeared in person and they have appeared again this morning. Last Friday, I arranged for the Court to contact Ms Ragus by telephone and rather than adjourn the hearing both parties were heard for about 40 minutes with Ms Ragus on the telephone.
At the end of that hearing, I made orders that Ms Ragus could file further submissions by close of business on Monday the 24th of October and the Staits could reply by close of business on Thursday 27 October. I then adjourned the further hearing of the appeal to this morning.
Both parties did file further material. Ms Ragus filed further submissions relating to the fourth and fifth grounds of appeal. She did not seek to file any further evidence.
That prompted a reply by Mr and Mrs Stait simply to the effect that as there was no evidence, they did not…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ragus v Stait and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2011] QDC 284
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the Magistrate had indeed erred in not considering the complaint as it related to the daughter, as the appellant had the authority to make such a complaint under section 4(1)(a) of the Peace and Good Behaviour Act. However, the Court concluded that the evidence provided did not support the making of an order against either respondent. The Court considered the incidents described by Ragus, such as throwing away her daughter's flower sculpture, throwing away a ball, and the alleged threatening note, but found that they did not rise to the level of threats to assault or do bodily injury, or damage property, as required by the Act. The Court also found that the Magistrate's assessment of the evidence and the final order was within their discretion.
The final orders of the Court were to dismiss the appeals made by Ragus, as the Court found that the evidence did not support the making of an order under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act against either respondent. The Court emphasised the importance of ensuring that the parties could live together peacefully and without further litigation, and that orders under the Act should not be made lightly, as they have significant consequences for the individuals involved.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case of Ragus v Stait is an appeal brought under section 222 of the Justices Act against orders made by Magistrate Daley on 1 February 2011. The appellant, Ms Olivia Ragus, made two complaints under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982 against Kevin Stait and Helen Stait, the respondents. The complaints were filed on 6 and 8 December 2010, respectively, and were heard and dismissed by Magistrate Daley on 1 February 2011. The appeal came before Judge Devereaux on 21 October 2011. Ms Ragus, citing illness, did not appear in person but participated via telephone, while the respondents appeared in person. Judge Devereaux allowed further submissions from Ms Ragus and heard the appeal on the basis of the materials already before the Magistrates Court. Ultimately, the appeal was dismissed on all six grounds, with the Judge concluding that the materials did not support the making of an order under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act against either respondent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the acts alleged against the respondents were sufficiently serious to require an order under section 4 of the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982.
2. Whether it was necessary to join the complainant's daughter as a complainant in the proceedings under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982.
3. Whether the learned Magistrate erred by failing to find that the weight of the evidence before her was such as to justify an order in respect of the respondents.
4. Whether the learned Magistrate erred by preferring the evidence of the respondents when the evidence before her established that the respondents had incorrectly told another magistrate that only Helen Stait had been offered mediation.
5. Whether the learned Magistrate failed to conduct the hearing in accordance with the rules of natural justice by favouring the self-represented respondents at the expense of the self-represented appellant.
6. Whether the learned Magistrate erred by failing to conduct the hearing of the matter in accordance with the intention of Parliament in enacting the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982, namely to provide an efficient and expeditious mechanism for the resolution of neighbour disputes.
Held
1. The court concluded that the acts alleged against the respondents were not sufficiently serious to require an order under section 4 of the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982; the appeal in this regard was dismissed.
2. The court found that it was not necessary to join the complainant's daughter as a complainant in the proceedings under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982; the appeal in this regard was allowed.
3. The court held that the learned Magistrate did not err by failing to find that the weight of the evidence before her was such as to justify an order in respect of the respondents; the appeal in this regard was dismissed.
4. The court found no error by the learned Magistrate in preferring the evidence of the respondents; the appeal in this regard was dismissed.
5. The court concluded that the learned Magistrate did not err by favouring the self-represented respondents over the self-represented appellant in violation of natural justice; the appeal in this regard was dismissed.
6. The court held that the learned Magistrate did not err by failing to conduct the hearing in accordance with the intention of Parliament in enacting the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982; the appeal in this regard was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal in Ragus v Stait considered the merits of an appeal against the dismissal of complaints made under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982. The primary focus was on whether the alleged acts against the respondents were sufficiently serious to warrant an order under the Act, and whether there were procedural errors made by the learned Magistrate in handling the proceedings.
Firstly, the court examined whether the acts alleged against the respondents were serious enough to require an order under section 4 of the Act. The court considered the incidents involving threats to the complainant's daughter, including instances where the daughter was frightened by the respondents. The court concluded that while the complainant's account was emotive, the incidents described did not sufficiently demonstrate threats of assault or bodily harm, or the destruction of property, which would justify an order under the Act. The court emphasized that an order under the Act should not be made lightly, as it carries significant consequences including potential criminal sanctions.
Secondly, the court addressed whether it was necessary to join the complainant's daughter as a complainant in the proceedings. The court found that the Magistrate erred by not considering the daughter's welfare as part of the complainant's concerns under section 4(1)(a) of the Act. However, the court determined that it was not necessary to join the daughter as a complainant because the primary concern was the complainant's fear for her daughter's safety, which was adequately covered under the Act without formally joining her as a complainant.
Thirdly, regarding the allegation that the Magistrate erred by failing to find that the weight of the evidence justified an order, the court held that it was within the Magistrate's discretion to assess the reliability and credibility of the evidence. The court found no error in the Magistrate's assessment and concluded that the evidence did not sufficiently support the making of an order.
Fourthly, the court considered whether the Magistrate erred by preferring the evidence of the respondents over the complainant. The court noted that it was open to the Magistrate to draw conclusions about the reliability of the witnesses and that the complainant's allegations, while distressing, did not meet the threshold required for an order under the Act.
Fifthly, the court examined whether the Magistrate failed to conduct the hearing in accordance with the rules of natural justice by favouring the self-represented respondents. The court found no procedural unfairness and concluded that the Magistrate had followed a fair process.
Finally, the court addressed whether the Magistrate failed to conduct the hearing in accordance with the intention of Parliament to provide an efficient and expeditious mechanism for resolving neighbour disputes. The court held that the Magistrate's conduct did not deviate from the purpose of the Act and found that the appeal was properly dismissed.
The ratio decidendi of the decision is that an order under the Peace and Good Behaviour Act 1982 requires sufficiently serious acts that threaten assault, bodily harm, or property damage. Additionally, while procedural errors may occur, the court must focus on the weight of the evidence and whether it supports the making of an order. The court also highlighted the importance of adhering to the intention of the Act to provide an efficient resolution mechanism for neighbour disputes.