| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
CITATION: | Raffoul v AAI Limited t/as GIO [2023] NSWPIC 265 |
| CLAIMANT: | Johny Raffoul |
| INSURER: | AAI Limited t/as GIO |
| SENIOR MEMBER: | Brett Williams |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 15 March 2023 |
CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Preliminary assessment and determination of insurer’s application for exemption under section 7.34(1)(b) Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; application opposed by the claimant; liability denied for claim by insurer; breach denied; insurer relies on defences in Part 7 of the Civil Liability Act 2002; factual dispute between the parties; insurer intends to call non-parties to give evidence; insurer argues that claim gives rise to complex legal, factual, and liability issues; insurer argues that evidence given under oath or affirmation required; Held – claim involves complex legal issues; court hearing will resolve the matters in dispute in the claim more efficiently and effectively; claim not suitable for assessment; recommendation that the claim be exempt from assessment. |
DETERMINATIONS MADE: | 1. I recommend to the President that the claim be exempt from assessment. |
BACKGROUND
Johny Raffoul was injured in an incident that occurred on 13 November 2020 (incident). He subsequently made a claim for damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) on AAI Limited t/as GIO (insurer), the insurer of the vehicle involved in the incident. The insurer has denied liability for the damages claim, and Mr Raffoul has referred his claim to the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) for assessment under division 7.6 of the MAI Act.
The insurer has sought an exemption from assessment under s 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act. These reasons contain my preliminary assessment of the claim and determination under that provision.
As recorded in the preliminary conference report dated 24 January 2023, there is a dispute between the parties in relation to the facts and circumstances in which the incident occurred. Further, at the preliminary conference Ms Watts confirmed that, in addition to the factual disputes, the insurer would be raising a defence under part 7 division 1 of the Civil Liability Act 2002 (CL Act), together with an agony of the moment defence.
I do not propose to summarise all the material that has been lodged by the parties in the proceedings; rather, I have incorporated into these reasons aspects of the material to provide necessary context for my determination.
THE INCIDENT
The NSW Police report dated 12 January 2021 includes, relevantly, the following narrative in relation to the incident:
“About the stated date and time[1] POI1[2] had just pulled into his driveway after being tailgated and then stopping and pulling out in front of the VOI driven by POI2.[3] POI2 has pulled over just down from POI1 residence.
POI1 has walked towards the VOI and has leant down speaking to POI2 through the driver’s window of the VOI. They have been talking for a short time which appeared to become more heated. POI1 has then punched POI2 through the window of the VOI. POI2 appears to have punched him back. POI2 has then driven off…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Raffoul v AAI Limited t/as GIO and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWPIC 265
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues for the court to determine were whether the claim involved complex legal or factual issues that warranted exemption from the assessment process, and whether the claim's complexity justified the need for evidence to be given under oath or affirmation. The insurer contended that the claim involved complex issues, including the insured's potential self-defence under the Civil Liability Act 2002 and the necessity to subpoena non-party witnesses. The claimant opposed the application, arguing that the claim was suitable for assessment and should proceed through the usual channels.
In its decision, the court considered the objects of the Personal Injury Commission Act and the circumstances of the claim. The court noted that the claim involved complex legal issues, particularly regarding the insurer's reliance on self-defence under the Civil Liability Act. The court also observed that the insurer intended to call non-party witnesses, which necessitated evidence given under oath or affirmation. Given these complexities, the court determined that the claim was not suitable for assessment and should be exempted. The court reasoned that a court hearing would resolve the matters in dispute more efficiently and effectively.
The court granted the insurer's application for exemption, recommending that the claim be exempt from assessment. This decision was based on the complexity of the legal issues, the necessity for sworn evidence, and the need for a court hearing to resolve the matters in dispute. The court's ruling aimed to ensure that the claim was handled in a manner that was both efficient and effective, given the complexities involved.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Rule 99 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) applies to the application. The rule is in the following terms:“99 Consideration of discretionary exemption from claims assessment(1) A claimant or insurer may apply for an exemption from assessment under section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act by lodging an application.(2) In determining whether a claim is not suitable for assessment for the purposes of section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act, the Commission must consider the objects of the PIC Act and the circumstances of the claim.(3) Without limiting the matters that may be considered, the Commission may consider the following—(a) whether the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, or complex issues in the assessment of the amount of the claim,(b) whether the claim involves issues of liability, including contributory negligence, fault or causation,(c) whether a claimant or witness, considered by the Commission to be a material witness, resides outside the State,(d) whether a claimant or insurer seeks to proceed against one or more non-CTP parties,(e) whether the insurer alleges that a person has made a false or misleading statement in a material particular in relation to the injuries, loss or damage sustained by the claimant in the accident giving rise to the claim.” Procedural Direction MA5 (PD5) applies to the application for exemption. PD5 makes it clear that an application for exemption may be made before a Member in the course of the general assessment of a claim. That is what has occurred in these proceedings. In support of its application for exemption, the insurer relies on a bundle of documents dated 13 February 2023. The bundle includes submissions of the same date. I have considered the material in the bundle. The insurer submits that the claim is not suitable for assessment by the Commission, and ought to be exempted from assessment, on the following bases:(a) liability for the claim has been denied by the insurer, on the basis that the insurer denies that its insured driver breached his duty of care to the claimant. In so denying, the insurer intends to rely upon, among other things, the defences in Part 7 of the CL Act – specifically, those in ss 52, 53 and/or 54, and(b) the insurer expects that it will be necessary to serve subpoenas to attend to give evidence upon several non-party witnesses. It is the insurer’s position that the incident occurred in the course of its insured’s reasonable actions in attempting to flee the scene, in an effort to avoid further assault at the hands of the claimant. The insurer’s submissions assert that the circumstances of the incident fall within the provisions of s 52 of the CL Act (or s 53, should it be found that its insured’s actions were not a reasonable response in the circumstances as perceived by the insured, a matter that the insurer does not concede). Put another way, in circumstances where it is alleged that the claimant had assaulted the insured, the insured’s actions in attempting to leave the area amounted to self-defence, and these actions, it is submitted, were a reasonable response to those circumstances as perceived by the insured.