Raedel & Anor v. Jezer Constructions Group Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[2008] QCA 368

COURT OF APPEAL

MUIR JA
WHITE AJA
McMURDO J

Appeal No 9692 of 2008

GREGORY MELVILLE RAEDEL AND  Appellants
KATHLEEN TERESA RAEDEL

and

JEZER CONSTRUCTION GROUP PTY LTD  Respondent
ACN 054 548 319

BRISBANE

DATE 27/11/2008

JUDGMENT

MUIR JA: Justice McMurdo will deliver his reasons first.

McMURDO J:  The respondent applies to strike out this appeal on the ground that it has no prospect of success.  Alternatively it applies for security for costs.

The appeal is against a judgment of the District Court which after a four day trial dismissed the appellant's claim with costs.

The appellants were the principals of Ramaville Pty Ltd, which carried on business as a landscaping contractor.  It contracted with the respondent for the performance of certain work in the construction of a retirement home at Caboolture.  The respondent was the head contractor.  Ramaville's subcontract was in writing and dated 7 August 1998.

Ramaville performed, or purportedly performed, its subcontract by about the end of 1998.  In 1999, Ramaville commenced these proceedings, claiming $77,403.38 against the respondent, in which the respondent made a counterclaim for $278,000.

On 15 September 2000, Ramaville was ordered to be wound up on the insolvency ground.  On the previous day, Ramaville executed a deed by which it purported to assign certain debts to the appellants, including what was said to be then owed to it by the respondent under or in relation to this subcontract.

Thereafter the appellants sought to recover what they said had been the amount owing to Ramaville.  The appellants were substituted for Ramaville as plaintiffs in the proceedings.  In the District Court, the respondent argued that this assignment by Ramaville was ineffective, but that argument was unsuccessful and is not pursued here.

The learned trial Judge concluded that the claims by and against Ramaville were mutual dealings which upon its winding up engaged Section 553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), with the result that what was due to Ramaville by the respondent had to be set off against whatever was due by it, with only the balance of the account admissible to proof against Ramaville, or payable to it. At the trial the appellants disputed the operation of Section 553C but this is not amongst the grounds of appeal.

The appellant's claim for $77,403.38 made no allowance for any sum which the respondent had claimed from Ramaville.  Notwithstanding the substitution of the appellants for Ramaville, the respondent persisted with its counterclaim, but of course no liability of Ramaville had passed to the appellants, so that on no basis could the respondent have recovered anything from them.

But what was within the counterclaim was relevant to the set-off under Section 553C. Accordingly, at the trial, the appellants had to prove their claim for $77,803 and defeat the respondent's case that it had been entitled to at least that amount from Ramaville.

The trial Judge held that of the claim for $77,403, only $36,488.13 was owing by the respondent.  He further held that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Raedel & Anor v. Jezer Constructions Group Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] QCA 368
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Raedel & Anor v Jezer Constructions Group Pty Ltd is an appeal against a District Court judgment that dismissed the appellants' claim and ordered them to pay costs. The appellants, who were the former principals of Ramaville Pty Ltd, a landscaping contractor, had commenced proceedings against the respondent, Jezer Constructions Group Pty Ltd, the head contractor for the construction of a retirement home at Caboolture. The appellants' claim was for $77,403.38, which they alleged was owing to Ramaville under their subcontract. The respondent counterclaimed for $278,000. The appellants argued that Ramaville had assigned its debts to them prior to its winding up, and they sought to recover the amount they claimed was owing to Ramaville. The District Court held that the claims were mutual dealings which engaged Section 553C of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and that the balance of the account was in the respondent's favour, dismissing the appellants' claim.

The appeal concerns the District Court's application of Section 553C and its determination of the set-off amount. The appellants raised five grounds of appeal, with the primary focus being on the $62,000 of liquidated damages that the respondent claimed. The Court had to determine whether there was an arguable case that the trial judge failed to consider the appellants' pleaded basis for denying liability for liquidated damages. The Court held that there was at least an arguable case that the trial judge erred in not considering this argument, and accordingly, the appeal should not be struck out. The Court also refused the respondent's application for security for costs, noting the substantial costs incurred by both parties due to the strike-out application.

The Court dismissed the respondent's applications to strike out the appeal and for security for costs. It granted leave for the respondent to amend the notice of appeal to include the grounds raised during the hearing and set out a timeline for further submissions. Each party was ordered to bear its own costs for the strike-out application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established