Radio 2UE Sydney Pty Ltd v Stereo FM Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )

)

- SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY ) S.A. M O . 1 5 of 19E1
l
DIVISIOX __ INDUSTRIAL )
_- IN -THE I'lATTER of an appllcatlon under

s.159 of the Conclllatlon and

Arbitratlon Act by Kaureen Paye Hibber-

and Others for an 1nc;ulry lnto sn
electlon for offlces In the FeSerated

Clerks Unlon of Australia (South

Australlen Branch)

EVATT J.

2 4 Septevber 1982

REASONS FOR JUDGXENT -_ -
On 20 July l081 an anylicatlon under 5 . 1 5 9 of
the Conclllation and Arbltratlon Act 1904 vas lodced by the

applicants seehn? an inqury into zlleqed lrreqularltles in

the electlon ln the South Australian Branch of the Federated

Clerks Union of Australia (the orcanlzation) for the offlces of (inter alia) Brznch Presldent, Branch Deputy-Presldent

and Branch Vlce-President.

After havlng satlsfled hlnself that there were

reasonable qrounc?s for an Inquiry, the Industrial ReFlstlrar
granted the appllcatlon zncl referred the matter to the Cocrt
pursuant to s . 1 6 0 on 14 September 1981. Section 161 provlses
that the lnqulry was then dceped to have been lnstltuted in
the Court. The Zattcr was llsted for dlrectlons before t h e
Court on 1 6 September 19El

On 17 September 1381 the Court, pursuant to s.163,

made certaln interln orders, includinn an order that

P!r Vleroever, who had been the successful candldate for the
office of Presldent of thc Peckrate6 Clerks Unlon of Australia,
South Australlap Branch ln the sub~ect election, act and contlnue
to act In that offLce and, aftcr qving certaln dlrectlons, flxec?
the hezrlna of the lnquiry for 15 Fovenber 1381.
Thcrenfter, the hearlna of the inquiry proceeded

on varlous dates up to a stage whcre dlrections requlrinq

written submisslons by the parties to be flled were mad by
the Court. The last of suzh submlsslons w a s flkd on
21 ScTtember last by the respondents, together with an
affidavit of !.:r Krantz, the Secretary of the South Australlan
Brznch of the organlzatlon, worn 1-6 Septenber 1961. Such
affldavit dlscloses that i4r Vlerqever' S health was such
that he could not carry out h15 dutles as President and that
tlr Eelloves, the person whom the Court had ordered on 17 September
1981 to act as Deputy-Presldect of the South Australlan Eranch,
he havlnu been success~ul. in the salc? election for that office,
had, lr. accordance wlth the rules, taken over the dutles of

President and that the Eranch Councll, hzvlnv granted leave

of absence to Xr Vlergever, pursuant to r.l6(s), had appointed
Wl11larn Turlcy, a Drench Counclllor, to "replace" I.;r Vlerqever
on the Branch Cxecutlvc.
Since the swearlnq of the szid affldavlt by

14r Krantz, Mr Vierqever has unfortunately dled, the date

of death beinq 22 Septerber 1982.

b i r Heywood-Smith, counsel for tke respondencs

has recuested that the Court, pursuant to S . 163 (1) (f) vary

its order of 17 Septercber 1981 or, pursuant to s . l 6 3 ( l ) ( e…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Radio 2UE Sydney Pty Ltd v Stereo FM Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1982] FCA 206
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of an application by Kaureen Payne Hibberd and others for an inquiry into an election for offices in the Federated Clerks Union of Australia (South Australian Branch), the Federal Court of Australia, sitting in the South Australia District Registry, was tasked with deciding whether to appoint a new acting president of the union following the death of the elected president. The applicants sought an inquiry into alleged irregularities in the election process, which was granted by the Industrial Registrar. The court was required to decide whether to appoint a new acting president in place of the deceased president or to leave the matter to the union officials.

The court held that it should not make any further order under s.163 in the present proceedings in addition to the orders made on 17 September 1981. The court considered that the officials of the Branch may take such steps as they may be advised. The application by the respondents in this regard was accordingly refused.

The court's decision was based on the fact that the elected president had already been appointed to act as president, and the court had no power to appoint a new acting president in his place. The court also noted that the union officials were best placed to decide what steps to take in light of the deceased president's passing. The court's decision was in line with the provisions of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act, which provided for the inquiry into the alleged irregularities in the election process.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 20 July 1981, an application under section 159 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act was lodged by Kaureen Paye Hibberd and others seeking an inquiry into alleged irregularities in the election for offices in the South Australian Branch of the Federated Clerks Union of Australia. The application followed an election where Mr Viergever was declared the successful candidate for the office of Branch President, and Mr Eelloves for Branch Deputy-President. However, due to Mr Viergever's health issues, Mr Eelloves took over the duties of President, and the Branch Council appointed William Turley to "replace" Mr Viergever on the Branch Executive. Mr Viergever passed away on 22 September 1982.

The Industrial Registrar granted the application and referred the matter to the Court pursuant to section 160 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act on 14 September 1981. The matter was listed for directions before the Court on 16 September 1981. On 17 September 1981, the Court made certain interim orders, including an order that Mr Viergever act and continue to act as President. The inquiry was fixed for 15 November 1981. The hearing of the inquiry proceeded on various dates, and the last of the written submissions by the parties was filed on 21 September by the respondents. The respondents requested that the Court vary its order of 17 September 1981 or make an order appointing Mr Turley to act as President pending an election for the filling of that office. The applicants opposed this request.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Should the Court vary its order of 17 September 1981 or make an order appointing Mr Turley to act as President pending an election for the filling of that office?
2. If the Court should make any order under section 163(1)(e) or (f), should the unsuccessful candidate for the office of Branch President, Mr Knight, be the person whom the Court should order to act as President?

Held
1. The Court should not vary its order of 17 September 1981 or make an order appointing Mr Turley to act as President pending an election for the filling of that office. The application by the respondents in this regard is accordingly refused.
2. The Court should not make any order under section 163(1)(e) or (f) that the unsuccessful candidate for the office of Branch President, Mr Knight, should act as President.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court considered the application by the respondents to vary its order of 17 September 1981 or make an order appointing Mr Turley to act as President pending an election. The respondents sought this based on the health incapacity of Mr Viergever, who had been ordered to act as President, and his subsequent death. Mr Heywood-Smith, counsel for the respondents, argued that Mr Turley should be appointed to act as President in the interim. However, the applicants opposed this and suggested that Mr Knight, the unsuccessful candidate for the office of Branch President, should be appointed instead.

The Court decided not to make any further order under section 163 in addition to the orders made on 17 September 1981. The Court reasoned that the Branch officials could take steps as they may be advised. The reasoning behind this decision appears to be that the Court was not inclined to intervene further in the internal affairs of the organisation beyond the initial orders made, which had already addressed the situation of Mr Viergever's health and subsequent death. The Court’s decision to refuse the application reflects a cautious approach to avoid further entanglement in organisational disputes unless there is a clear need for judicial intervention. This decision likely rests on the principle that the Court should not overstep its role in regulating the internal processes of the organisation unless absolutely necessary.