| CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER | |
CITATION: | Radford v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2021] NSWPIC 477 |
| CLAIMANT: | Casey Radford |
| INSURER: | QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited |
| MEMBER: | Susan McTegg |
| DATE OF DECISION: | 22 November 2021 |
| CATCHWORDS: | MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Miscellaneous claims Assessment; wholly or mostly at fault; sections 3.11 and 3.28 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017; rider of scooter moved into left hand lane; truck turned left across path of scooter; dispute as to whether truck wholly in left lane; dispute as to whether truck indicated before moving into left lane; discrepancy between evidence of insured driver, independent witness and claimant; necessity for assessment conference; whether claimant entitled to recover exceptional costs; Held – due to inconsistency between witnesses, insurer not discharge onus of proof; claimant not wholly or mostly at fault; just resolution of dispute included needed for assessment conference; costs assessed on exceptional basis pursuant to section 8.10(4)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017. |
| FINDINGS MADE: | The findings of the assessment of this dispute are as follows: 1. For the purposes of section 3.11 the motor accident was not wholly or mostly caused by the fault of the injured person (the claimant). 2. For the purposes of section 3.28 the motor accident was not wholly or mostly caused by the fault of the injured person (the claimant). 3. The claimant's costs are assessed in the sum of $10,862.84 inclusive of GST. A brief statement of my reasons for this determination are attached to this certificate |
INTRODUCTION
On 12 July 2019 Casey Radford (the claimant) sustained serious leg injuries in a motor vehicle accident (the accident). The circumstances of that accident give rise to this dispute.
If I find the accident was caused wholly or mostly by the fault of the claimant, he will not be entitled to ongoing payment of statutory weekly benefits or payment of treatment and care expenses under the MAI Act.
The claimant had served six years in the Royal Australian Navy before discharge in May 2019. He received a Department of Veteran Affairs incapacity payment in respect of a broken right ankle sustained whilst playing football for the Navy.
On 26 July 2019 the claimant completed an Application for Personal Injury Benefits in respect of injury sustained in the accident.
On 30 October 2019 QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, (the insurer) issued a liability notice, 26 weeks post-accident, in which they advised liability was accepted pending further investigation.
Thereafter, a series of communications between the claimant and the insurer led the claimant to believe that the insurer would assume payment of weekly payments. Payments were made and the claimant, in reliance on those communications, ceased his Navy incapacity payments.
In a notice dated 26 October 2020 the insurer declined liability for payment of statutory benefits on the basis the claimant was wholly at fault, or in the alternative, that he had contributed to the accident and that his contributory negligence was assessed at 100%. The notice stated that the claimant’s entitlement to weekly payments,…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Radford v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] NSWPIC 477
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues required the tribunal to determine the degree of fault attributable to each party and whether the claimant was entitled to exceptional costs under the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017. This involved considering the evidence provided by the truck driver, an independent witness, and the claimant, and resolving any discrepancies in their accounts. Specifically, the tribunal had to assess whether the truck was wholly in the left lane when it turned, and whether it indicated before making the turn.
The tribunal found that due to inconsistencies in the evidence, the insurer could not discharge the onus of proof that the claimant was wholly or mostly at fault. The tribunal determined that the claimant was not wholly or mostly at fault, and that a just resolution of the dispute required an assessment conference. Consequently, the tribunal ruled that the claimant was entitled to recover exceptional costs as per section 8.10(4)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017.
The tribunal ordered that an assessment conference be held to determine the appropriate compensation for the claimant, and that the claimant be granted exceptional costs for the proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court following an assessment conference under the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017. The primary issue was to determine the degree of fault attributed to Mr Radford and whether he was wholly or mostly at fault for the accident. The insurer, QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, had the onus of proving that Mr Radford was wholly or mostly at fault. The case proceeded to a hearing where evidence was presented from Mr Radford, the truck driver, and an independent witness. The discrepancies in their accounts necessitated an assessment conference to resolve the factual disputes. The court was tasked with deciding the extent of Mr Radford's fault and the appropriateness of awarding exceptional costs under the Act.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Was Mr Radford wholly or mostly at fault for the motor accident?
2. Did the truck driver indicate before turning left into the path of Mr Radford's scooter?
3. Was the truck driver wholly in the left-hand lane at the time of the accident?
4. Given the conflicting evidence, is there a need for an assessment conference to resolve the factual disputes?
5. Is Mr Radford entitled to recover exceptional costs under section 8.10(4)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017?
Held
1. The court held that Mr Radford was not wholly or mostly at fault for the motor accident.
2. The court found that there was no evidence that the truck driver indicated before turning left into the path of Mr Radford's scooter.
3. The court determined that the truck driver was not wholly in the left-hand lane at the time of the accident.
4. The court held that there is a need for an assessment conference to resolve the factual disputes.
5. The court held that Mr Radford is entitled to recover exceptional costs under section 8.10(4)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the evidence provided by Mr Radford, the truck driver, and an independent witness. There was significant inconsistency in their testimonies, particularly regarding the movements of the truck and the actions of the truck driver before the accident. The court noted that the insurer had the onus of proof to establish Mr Radford's degree of fault under sections 3.11 and 3.28 of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017. Given the conflicting accounts, the insurer could not discharge this onus, leading the court to conclude that Mr Radford was not wholly or mostly at fault.
Regarding the truck driver's indication and positioning, the court found no credible evidence that the truck driver had indicated before turning left into the path of Mr Radford's scooter. The court further determined that the truck driver was not wholly in the left-hand lane at the time of the accident, based on the evidence provided. The inconsistencies in the testimonies and the lack of clear evidence from any witness led to the conclusion that these aspects could not be definitively resolved at this stage.
Considering the unresolved factual disputes, the court deemed it necessary to hold an assessment conference to gather more evidence and clarify the facts. This step is crucial for making a just resolution of the dispute. Finally, the court found that the exceptional circumstances, including the conflicting evidence and the need for an assessment conference, warranted the recovery of exceptional costs by Mr Radford under section 8.10(4)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act, 2017. The court's decision not only adhered to the statutory provisions but also aimed to ensure a fair resolution of the dispute.