RACQ Insurance Limited v BRT

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: RACQ Insurance Limited v BRT [2023] NSWPIC 672
CLAIMANT: BRT
INSURER: RACQ Insurance Limited
SENIOR MEMBER: Brett Williams
DATE OF DECISION: 13 December 2023
CATCHWORDS: MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; insurer’s application for discretionary exemption from assessment under section 7.34(1)(b); preliminary assessment of claim; complex causation issues; pre-and post-accident history of injuries; claimant’s reliability as a medical historian put in issue by the insurer; likely doctors will be required to give oral evidence; Held – a court hearing is more likely to result in the just, quick and cost effective resolution of the real issues in dispute between the parties; the claim is not suitable for assessment; recommendation made that the claim be exempted; recommendation subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate.

RECOMMENDATIONS – CLAIM NOT SUITABLE FOR ASSESSMENT

BACKGROUND

  1. BRT was injured in a motor accident on 28 June 2018 (accident). On


    28 February 2020 she made a claim for damages under the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) on RACQ (insurer). On 14 July 2020 the insurer wholly admitted liability for the claim.

  2. BRT subsequently referred her claim to the Personal Injury Commission (Commission) for assessment. She was, at that time (and when the first preliminary conference was conducted on 23 August 2022) legally represented. However, she no longer has legal representation, her solicitors having ceased to act in or about December 2022.

  3. The claim was referred to me to assess in accordance with s 7.36 of the MAI Act. The procedural history is recorded in the preliminary conference reports.

  4. On 20 October 2023 the Commission received correspondence from the insurer’s lawyers, in which the insurer requested that a preliminary assessment of the claim be performed in order to recommend to the President of the Commission that the claim be exempted from the Commission on discretionary grounds under s 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act (application for exemption).

  5. On 24 October 2023 I made directions for provision by the parties of submissions and evidence in relation to the application for exemption. The insurer was directed to lodge the material it relied on by 3 November 2023. BRT was directed to provide her written response to the application for exemption, together with any supporting documents, on or before 27 November 2023. The parties were informed that on or after 28 November 2023 I would undertake a preliminary assessment of the claim, under s 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act, on the papers. The insurer subsequently provided submissions dated 1 November 2023.

  6. On 21 November 2023, BRT informed the Commission that, due to various issues, she would not be able to respond to the directions made on 24 October 2023. On


    22 November 2023 I varied the directions made on 24 October 2023 so that BRT’s response to the application for exemption was to be provided to the Commission on or before


    8 December 2023. The parties were informed that I would undertake a preliminary assessment of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RACQ Insurance Limited v BRT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 672
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

RACQ Insurance Limited, the defendant, made an application for a discretionary exemption from assessment under section 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 against BRT, the plaintiff, in the Personal Injury Commission of Queensland. The central dispute concerns the suitability of BRT's claim for assessment, particularly in light of complex causation issues, the claimant's history of injuries both before and after the relevant accident, and the insurer's doubts about BRT's reliability as a medical historian. The insurer argued that a preliminary assessment of the claim revealed significant pre-existing injuries and multiple subsequent incidents, complicating the task of attributing the current injuries to the initial motor accident.

The court had to decide whether the claim was suitable for assessment under the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021, specifically considering the complex legal and factual issues, and the potential need for medical experts to provide oral evidence. The insurer contended that the claimant's reliability as a historian of her medical conditions was questionable, and that the presence of pre-existing conditions and multiple post-accident incidents made it difficult to attribute the current injuries solely to the initial accident. The court also had to determine whether a court hearing would more effectively resolve the issues in dispute between the parties in a just, quick, and cost-effective manner.

The court found that the claim involved complex issues of causation and liability, as well as the claimant's reliability in recounting her medical history. The court noted that the medical records showed injuries that were inconsistent with the claimant's account, and that there were multiple subsequent incidents that could have contributed to her current condition. The court concluded that a court hearing was more likely to result in the just, quick, and cost-effective resolution of the real issues in dispute between the parties. Accordingly, the court recommended that the claim be exempted from assessment, and this recommendation was subsequently approved by the Division Head, as the President’s delegate.

The court ordered that the claim be exempted from assessment under section 7.34(1)(b) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017, in accordance with the recommendation of the Personal Injury Commission. This decision was based on the complexity of the issues involved, the potential need for medical experts to provide oral evidence, and the likelihood that a court hearing would be more effective in resolving the real issues in dispute between the parties. The insurer's application for exemption was therefore granted.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Rule 99 of the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021 (PIC Rules) applies to the application. The rule states:“99 Consideration of discretionary exemption from claims assessment(1) A claimant or insurer may apply for an exemption from assessment under section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act by lodging an application.(2) In determining whether a claim is not suitable for assessment for the purposes of section 92(1)(b) of the MAC Act or section 7.34(1)(b) of the MAI Act, the Commission must consider the objects of the PIC Act and the circumstances of the claim.(3) Without limiting the matters that may be considered, the Commission may consider the following—(a)whether the claim involves complex legal or factual issues, or complex issues in the assessment of the amount of the claim,(b)whether the claim involves issues of liability, including contributory negligence, fault or causation,(c)whether a claimant or witness, considered by the Commission to be a material witness, resides outside the State,(d)whether a claimant or insurer seeks to proceed against one or more non-CTP parties,(e) whether the insurer alleges that a person has made a false or misleading statement in a material particular in relation to the injuries, loss or damage sustained by the claimant in the accident giving rise to the claim.” Procedural Direction MA5 (PD5) applies to the application for exemption. PD5 makes it clear that, as has occurred in these proceedings, an application for exemption may be made before a Member in the course of the general assessment of a claim. In correspondence from its lawyers to the Commission dated 20 October 2023, the insurer provided further submissions in support of the exemption application. The insurer argues that causation is a significant and complicated issue in the claim. Among other things, the insurer points to records from Bankstown Hospital, which it says show that on 2 July 2018 (four days after the accident) the only history was of a soft tissue back injury, and that nothing was recorded regarding a neck injury. In conducting a preliminary assessment of the claim, I have reviewed those records. They include reference to “pain all over the back” and “spinal and paraspinal tenderness thoracic and lumbar”. The hospital records confirm that X-rays of BRT’s lumbosacral spine, thoracic spine, and chest were performed. The triage comment includes the following: “Pt walked in with body pain and stiffness to body. Pt was involved in a MVA on Friday, but did not go to hospital because her friend was in critical condition. Pt is complaining of lower back pain. Multiple trauma in the past.” The insurer also refers to injuries and surgery after the accident, including: a motor vehicle accident on 24 July 2019; a C5/6 fusion and discectomy on 24 October 2019; presentation by BRT at Liverpool Hospital on 3 March 2020 with history of having exacerbated right side neck pain from sliding doors at Centrelink; a motor vehicle accident on 14 January 2021 with a subsequent history of neck and lower back pain; and a lumbar interbody fusion at L4/5 and L5/S1 on 9 July 2021.