| [2017] FWCFB 6059 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604—Appeal of decision
Rachna Garg
v
Eureka Operation Pty Ltd T/A Coles Express
(C2017/5309)
VICE PRESIDENT CATANZARITI | SYDNEY, 17 NOVEMBER 2017 |
Appeal against a decision of Commissioner McKinnon at Melbourne on 14 September 2017 in matter number U2017/1774 – permission to appeal – public interest not enlivened – permission to appeal refused.
[1] This is an application, pursuant to ss 400 and 604 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the ‘Act’), for permission to appeal and appeal of a decision of Commissioner McKinnon in matter U2017/1774, published on 14 September 2017; Rachna Garg v Eureka Operations Pty Ltd T/A Coles Express Brandon Park. 1 Ms Rachna Garg (‘the Appellant’) was dismissed by the Eureka Operations Pty Ltd T/A Coles Express (‘the Respondent’) on 24 January 2017, for ‘dishonesty’, after she put fuel in her own car from a fuel pump which was not working correctly. The Commissioner dismissed the Appellant’s unfair dismissal application after finding there was a valid reason for her dismissal and that the dismissal was otherwise neither harsh, unjust nor unreasonable, within the meaning of s 387 of the Act.
[2] The appeal was listed before the Full Bench on 1 November 2017 for oral submissions as to permission to appeal only. Both parties had filed written submissions prior to the hearing. The Appellant was represented by her husband, Mr P. Garg. Mr W Spargo, solicitor, with Ms S Brown represented the Respondent, with permission being granted by the Full Bench, pursuant to s 596 of the Act; noting Mr Garg did not oppose the Respondent being represented by a lawyer.
Decision at first instance
[3] In her decision, the Commissioner identified the Appellant’s conduct which was said to be valid reasons for the decision to dismiss her as:
(a) The taking of fuel without paying on 16 October 2016 and her dishonesty on 25 October 2016 and 24 January 2017, when during meetings with the Respondent, she claimed she had put the fuel in her car to test Pump 17; and
(b) Her encouragement of Ms Puri (another employee) to take fuel on 16 October 2016, without paying.
[4] The Commissioner at paragraph [10] set out the following matters said to be agreed and not in dispute:
1. On 16 October 2016, there was a problem with the fuel pumps at the Brandon Park service station.
2. ‘Pump 17’ was one of the fuel pumps affected. It could pump fuel, but the amount of fuel dispensed did not display on the console screen at the sales counter.
3. The Appellant put fuel in her car using Pump 17 while it was not working properly.
4. Mr Ashwani Kumar, who was also working at the time, used Pump 17 immediately after the Appellant.
5. Mr Kumar paid for his fuel toward the end of his shift on 16 October 2016.
6. The Appellant paid for her fuel on…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rachna Garg v Eureka Operation Pty Ltd T/A Coles Express and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] FWCFB 6059
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue the court was required to address was whether the appellant had established that the public interest warranted granting her permission to appeal the commissioner's decision. This involved examining the appellant's arguments for why the appeal should be allowed despite the absence of a public interest component. The court also considered whether there were any other grounds that could justify permission to appeal, beyond the public interest requirement.
In examining the appellant's submissions, the court found that she had not sufficiently demonstrated that the public interest was sufficiently engaged to warrant permission to appeal. The court emphasised that the public interest criterion was not the sole factor to be considered in granting permission to appeal, but in this instance, it was a critical component. The court concluded that the appellant had not made out a case that the public interest was sufficiently advanced to merit the grant of permission to appeal. Consequently, the court dismissed the appeal and refused permission to appeal the commissioner's decision.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi