Racecentre Pty Ltd v PS Property Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
CITATION: Racecentre Pty Ltd v PS Property Holdings Pty Ltd [2013] QCATA 310
PARTIES: Racecentre Pty Ltd
(Appellant)
v
PS Property Holdings Pty Ltd
Paul David Smith
(Respondents)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL298-13
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: On the papers
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Richard Oliver, Senior Member
Michelle Howard, Member
DELIVERED ON: 31 October 2013
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    Leave to appeal is granted.

2.    The appeal is allowed.

3.    The decision of the Tribunal dated 30 May 2013 is set aside.

4.    The proceeding shall be reheard by the Tribunal by another adjudicator.

5.    Mr Murphy must file and serve any further material to be relied upon at the rehearing within 21 days of receiving this decision;

6.    The respondents must file and serve any further material to be relied upon at the rehearing within 14 days of the service upon them of Mr Murphy’s further material.

7.    That the proceeding be listed for hearing on a date to be fixed.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND LEAVE TO APPEAL- MINOR CIVIL DISPUTE-CONTRACT - ALLEGATION OF FRAUDULENT MISREPRESENTATION-
whether the adjudicator had regard to the correct legal test and issues

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (QCAT Act).

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Racecentre Pty Ltd, of which Mr Murphy is a director, purchased a Holden Commodore from PS Property Holdings Pty Ltd for $29,000 on 19 May 2011. It had only some 5000 kilometres on the odometer. Mr Murphy says that Mr Smith, a former director and current shareholder of PS Property Holdings, represented the vehicle to him as an ‘as new’ ex-executive vehicle owned by Holden for whom he claimed to work or to do work. This is consistent with Mr Smith’s evidence. At the hearing, Mr Smith spoke of the car being practically brand new and that Mr Murphy had received a very significant saving, getting an as new vehicle for about half the cost. In making that assertion, he said that the cost of a new vehicle including on-road costs was $43,860, and added on various other amounts including $3,500 for the ‘upgraded’ wheels and tyres on the vehicle. 

  2. Initially when he took possession of the car, Mr Murphy noted fresh paint on the door. When he approached Mr Smith about it, he says Mr Smith told him that a scratch had been repaired. Later on 22 May 2011, he became aware that Mr Smith was being prosecuted for offences relating to dishonest dealing in motor vehicles, including winding back speedometers. He became concerned about the vehicle he had bought.

  3. When Mr Murphy subsequently had the vehicle serviced the mechanic pointed out items of concern which had been noted during the service. A copy of his written report was before the Tribunal. The extensive list included that the vehicle had undergone major body repairs; the alternator was not original (a second hand unit was fitted); the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Racecentre Pty Ltd v PS Property Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCATA 310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Racecentre Pty Ltd v PS Property Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, Racecentre, sought to appeal a decision made by the adjudicator of the Tribunal, which had ruled in favour of the defendants, PS Property Holdings and Mr Smith. The primary issue in the case revolved around whether Racecentre had been misled into believing that a vehicle they purchased was in a condition similar to that of a new vehicle, when in fact it was not. Racecentre further contended that the adjudicator erred in dismissing their evidence and that the proceedings were not fairly conducted.

The court was tasked with determining whether the adjudicator had correctly identified and applied the law to the facts of the case. Specifically, the court examined whether the adjudicator properly considered the nature of the claim, which was for fraudulent misrepresentation, and whether the evidence presented by Racecentre, including testimonies from independent mechanics and a Holden dealership invoice, was adequately weighed. The court found that the adjudicator had failed to properly consider the evidence and had focused on irrelevant issues, such as whether the vehicle was a write-off and whether the defendants were motor dealers. Additionally, the adjudicator's handling of independent evidence was deemed inadequate and unexplained.

The court concluded that the appeal should be allowed, and leave to appeal was granted. The decision of the Tribunal was set aside, and the matter was to be reheard by another adjudicator. The court also imposed deadlines for the parties to file and serve any further material to be relied upon at the rehearing. The proceeding was to be listed for a hearing at a date to be determined.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is allowed.

3. The decision of the Tribunal dated 30 May 2013 is set aside.

4. The proceeding shall be reheard by the Tribunal by another adjudicator.

5. Mr Murphy must file and serve any further material to be relied upon at the rehearing within 21 days of receiving this decision;

6. The respondents must file and serve any further material to be relied upon at the rehearing within 14 days of the service upon them of Mr Murphy’s further material.

7. That the proceeding be listed for hearing on a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Conclusions Racecentre’s reasons for seeking to appeal appear broadly to be related to considering it was not fairly heard, particularly concerning the issues about whether the vehicle was a repairable write-off, and that the adjudicator was in error that the information Mr Murphy advanced came from a private investigator rather than a Queensland Government investigator. Additionally, it says the adjudicator failed to take into account the independent evidence presented by it, from the mechanic who serviced the vehicle and from Holden and that attention was focussed on irrelevant matters in determining the claim concerning whether the respondents were motor dealers. The claim made by Racecentre is in effect a claim in contract for fraudulent misrepresentation. The issues for consideration were therefore, whether a false representation was made, knowingly or without belief in its truth with the intention that it be acted upon by a party who was thereby induced to act upon it. If so, then it fell to be considered whether the person to whom the representation was made was entitled to rescind the contract (which Mr Murphy suggests Racecentre tried to do for about a year before commencing proceedings) and a refund of purchase monies, or, alternatively, determine damages for the losses suffered as a result of the misrepresentation. Although the pressure of workload in a busy list must be acknowledged, the learned adjudicator did not identify the nature of the claim she was dealing with. She seemed to place significant weight on the fact that there was no evidence that the vehicle was a write-off. If evidence of this had been available, this may have gone to strengthening Racecentre’s case that there had been misrepresentation. However, the evidence she had was that Mr Murphy was led to believe that Racecentre was purchasing an as new vehicle from PS Property Holdings, and indeed, Mr Smith’s evidence was that Mr Murphy received an almost new vehicle for approximately half the new price. Yet, she did not find that a representation had been made that the vehicle was in as new or almost new condition, and if so, whether that representation was fraudulent. Instead she focussed on whether or not there was evidence the vehicle was a write-off. It was not critical, it seems to me, whether evidence was available about whether the vehicle was a write-off. The issue was whether the vehicle was as new or almost new. Also, the learned adjudicator was concerned about whether PS Property Holdings and Mr Smith, or either of them, were motor dealers. Racecentre does not appear to allege that they were, although I acknowledge that the evidence reveals a basis for the adjudicator’s expressed reservations about the status. She then makes an irrelevant finding, given the nature of the claim, that had the respondent been a motor dealer there may have been some scope ‘under the cooling off period.’ The adjudicator acknowledged the L & J Automotive Report setting out mechanical issues, although not the Holden dealership invoice which was before her which also set out some electrical issues. Somewhat inexplicably she later says when discussing those issues, and Mr Murphy’s evidence that trims and other parts were falling off the car, that Mr Murphy has provided no evidence of this to the Tribunal. She observes that there is no evidence beyond ‘his word versus the respondent’s word and that they are significantly disputed in terms of the exchanges which took place between the parties.’ This is not correct. She had evidence from 2 independent mechanics about issues with the car, but apparently dismissed them on an unrelated basis, namely that there was a dispute about exchanges between the parties. She failed to explain her treatment of the independent evidence, and indeed gave it no weight without explaining why.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established