R v Zoneff No. Ccrm-98-98 Judgment No. S6977

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

R v ZONEFF

[1998] SASC 6977

Court of Criminal Appeal:  Cox, Prior, Olsson JJ

  1. COX J.               In my opinion the appeal against conviction should be dismissed.  I would allow the appeal against sentence and set aside the sentence orders of the District Court.  Instead I would impose a single sentence of four years’ imprisonment for all of the offences.  The appellant will not begin to serve that sentence until he has completed a previous sentence which still had three years, three months and twenty-six days to run when the present sentences were pronounced on 17 March 1998.  For the total sentence I would fix a non-parole period of five years to run from 17 March 1998. 

  2. I agree with the reasons of Prior J.

  3. PRIOR J:           The appellant was tried in the District Court on an information containing seven counts, four of which charged him with false pretences, three with fraudulent conversion.  A jury found him guilty of six of the seven charges.  They returned a verdict of not guilty on the first count.  That was an alternative charge to one of fraudulent conversion.  The total amount of money involved was just under $73000.

  4. In this appeal, the convictions and sentences imposed upon conviction are challenged.

  5. The prosecution case was that the appellant took advantage of five people.  The first two, referred to in the first and second counts, were Ms Sneath and Mr McKinnon.  The other three were Mr and Mrs Dik and Ms Phillips.  They each met the appellant when they went to purchase furniture from the Le Cornu Furniture Centre.  The appellant was a sales person there.  The prosecution alleged that the appellant ingratiated himself with these people, fostering their friendship to betray their trust by dishonestly dealing with their money.

  6. Ms Sneath and Mr McKinnon said that the appellant persuaded them to pay the amount outstanding on their purchases to him, so that they could have the benefit of bonus points to which he was entitled as part of his employment conditions with Le Cornu.  In their case, it was said that an additional discount of $720 was offered by the appellant if they sent the money they owed Le Cornu directly to him.  Ms Sneath and Mr McKinnon said that they agreed with the appellant’s proposal, believing that he was acting in his capacity as an employee of Le Cornu and that he had authority to do what he was doing. Sneath’s evidence was that she paid $4068 into the appellant’s account with a building society, that sum being the amount she and McKinnon were indebted to Le Cornu less the discount the appellant had offered to them.  Fraudulent conversion of this money was found proved.   The evidence accepted by the jury established that the $4068 deposited by Ms Sneath into the appellant’s account was used to pay the appellant’s personal debts.

  7. The other five charges were not put in the alternative. With respect to four of those Mr and Mrs Dik were involved.  Like…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Zoneff No. Ccrm-98-98 Judgment No. S6977 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 6977
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Criminal Appeal, the appellant, Zoneff, appealed against both his conviction and sentence. Zoneff was convicted by a jury of six counts of false pretences and fraudulent conversion, involving a total of just under $73,000. The appeal challenged both the validity of the convictions and the sentence imposed. The legal issues included whether the trial judge appropriately admitted evidence of uncharged loans, whether the trial judge adequately directed the jury on the elements of dishonesty and lies, and whether the sentence imposed was excessive. The Court found that the evidence of uncharged loans was properly admitted as it was relevant to the appellant's financial position and intent. The Court also held that the trial judge's direction on lies, while not ideal, did not prejudice the appellant or lead the jury to improper reasoning. However, the Court found that the trial judge's direction on lies was insufficient and necessitated a retrial. Regarding the sentence, the Court held that the cumulative sentence of seven years and six months was manifestly excessive and reduced it to four years, with a non-parole period of five years.

The final orders of the Court were to dismiss the appeal against conviction, allow the appeal against sentence, set aside the sentence orders of the District Court, impose a single sentence of four years’ imprisonment for all of the offences, and direct a retrial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

COX J OLSSON J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: COX J, OLSSON J