99.288
COURT OF APPEAL
de JERSEY CJ
BYRNE J
WHITE J
CA No 62 of 1999
THE QUEEN
v.
STEPHEN JOHN WALLIS Applicant
BRISBANE
..DATE 27/07/99
JUDGMENT
BYRNE J: The applicant was convicted on his own pleas of guilty of two charges of official corruption and eight of forgery. The corruption offences took place in late 1993 and early 1994. The forgery offences took place over a period of almost four years between May 1992 and March 1996.
The applicant, who was born in late 1959, was serving a sentence of five years' imprisonment following a conviction at a trial for the supply of dangerous drugs. That sentence was imposed in February this year. He has a criminal history extending over some 20 years, although with the exception of the drug supply charge for which he was imprisoned and some other drug offences, his prior convictions were not for especially serious matters. Many related to driving offences although a couple involved some dishonesty.
The corruption charges arose out of dealings with a
Ms Parkinson, an employee of the State Public Service, to procure drivers' licences in the false names of Daniel James Young and James Andrew Whiting. The applicant corruptly paid money to Ms Parkinson to obtain these false licences, which were used in connection with the forgeries.
In February 1992 the applicant used the name Young to open a bank account and forged the application by signing that name.
In early 1993 he forged a signature purporting to be that of Whiting to buy land.
In December 1993, in connection with the corrupt arrangement with Ms Parkinson to obtain the false licence in the name of Whiting, he forged a writing purporting to contain Whiting's signature on a driver's licence application form.
In early 1994 he forged the signature of Young on a contract to buy land. Shortly afterwards, he corruptly arranged for Ms Parkinson to provide him with a false driver's licence in the name of Young, and again forged a writing purporting to contain a signature on the licence application form.
In January 1995 he used Young's name on a mortgage granted over the land which had been purchased in Young's name.
In February 1996 he used the name Whiting on a contract to buy land. The next month he endorsed a cheque in that name for payment into a bank account.
The motivation for these offences did not clearly emerge and no finding was made by the sentencing Judge with respect to it. The prosecutor had suggested, somewhat obliquely, that the purpose of the offences was to "hide money". The explanation offered by defence counsel was also less than clear.
For the applicant, the sentencing Judge was invited to infer that the transactions were engaged in to disguise the existence of these properties from the applicant's former wife out of a concern that she was likely to press him in the future with respect to the properties and that he would not otherwise have been able…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Wallis and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] QCA 288
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the sentences imposed by the sentencing Judge were excessive and inconsistent with the principle of totality and whether they represented an unjust disparity compared to the sentence of the public servant involved, Ms Parkinson. The Court had to determine if the sentences were within the range of a sound sentencing discretion and if they appropriately addressed issues of personal and general deterrence.
The Court of Appeal found that the sentences were not excessive and were within the range of a sound sentencing discretion. The Court acknowledged the seriousness of Wallis's crimes, particularly the official corruption charges, which warranted a sentence that emphasised both personal and general deterrence. The Court noted that while the sentences were not lenient, they were not beyond what could be considered appropriate given the circumstances. The recommendation for parole after one quarter of the sentence for the official corruption offenses was also considered a mitigating factor. The Court rejected the argument that the sentences were inconsistent with the principle of totality, as Wallis was already serving a significant sentence for his drug-related offenses. The Court also found no basis for concluding that there was an unjust disparity in sentencing compared to Ms Parkinson.
In conclusion, the Court of Appeal upheld the sentences imposed by the sentencing Judge. The application for appeal was refused by the Court of Appeal, affirming the sentences and the reasoning of the sentencing Judge.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi