R v Toby

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

COURT OF APPEAL

[1998] QCA 452

McMURDO P
PINCUS JA
CHESTERMAN J

CA No 374 of 1998

THE QUEEN

v.

DOUGLAS TOBY  Applicant

BRISBANE

..DATE 02/12/98

JUDGMENT

CHESTERMAN J:  On 9 October 1998 the applicant pleaded guilty to a charge that on 11 April 1998 at Camooweal he and other persons assembled together in such a manner as to cause persons in the neighbourhood to fear on reasonable grounds that the persons so assembled would tumultuously disturb the peace.  He was sentenced to three months imprisonment to be wholly suspended.  The sentence was given an operational period of nine months.  The applicant seeks leave to appeal against his sentence on the ground that it is manifestly excessive.

The applicant is a 40-year-old Aboriginal man who contracted polio as a child and has been crippled ever since.  He developed a feud with another Aboriginal man, Billy Watson, a resident of Camooweal.  On an occasion some few weeks before 11 April 1998 the applicant claimed that Watson took him to a secluded area outside the town, assaulted him and left him there.  It was with difficulty that he returned to the town.

On the day of the offence, a large number of the applicant's relations had journeyed to Camooweal in the Northern Territory to attend a festival.  To obtain revenge the applicant incited his relations to attack Watson, who appealed to his own family for succour.

Thus, at about 10 p.m. on 11 April 1998, a group of about 70 people assembled outside the Post Office Hotel.  This was the applicant's group.  Watson and his followers were inside the
hotel, reluctant to come out.  The police sought to relieve the tension by brokering a reconciliation between the applicant and Watson.  Having spoken to Watson, the police officers told the applicant that Watson did not want to fight and that he, the applicant, should "call off" his family.  The applicant replied, "It's too late.  All these young blokes, they want to fight.  It's with the families now."  He went on, "I tell them all that I've been wronged and they're going to fight for me.  It's the Aboriginal way."

As the applicant predicted, it was too late for negotiation and fighting broke out.  As many as 200 people became involved in the tumult which appeared to consist of brawling throughout the streets of Camooweal.  Luckily no-one was seriously hurt and no property was damaged.  The two police officers were quite unable to impose order and had to send for reinforcements.  Two other officers came from the Northern Territory and a large contingent from Mount Isa.  It was only when the latter arrived at about 2.30 a.m. that the riot was quelled.

Only three persons were charged as a result of the affray.  One, Aplin, has not yet been dealt with.  Another, Christie, a white man who involved himself gratuitously in the affair, pleaded guilty to the more serious offence of riot.  He was placed on a good behaviour bond.  He had no previous…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Toby and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QCA 452
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of The Queen versus Douglas Toby, Toby sought leave to appeal against his sentence on the grounds that it was manifestly excessive. Toby had pleaded guilty to a charge of assembling with others in a manner that caused fear of a disturbance of the peace. He was sentenced to three months imprisonment, wholly suspended for nine months. Toby argued that his personal circumstances and the penalty imposed were significantly greater than that imposed for similar offences. The Court of Appeal held that the sentence imposed was not manifestly excessive. The applicant is a severely disabled 40-year-old Aboriginal man who contracted polio as a child and has been crippled ever since. He developed a feud with another Aboriginal man, Billy Watson, a resident of Camooweal. On an occasion some weeks before 11 April 1998 the applicant claimed that Watson took him to a secluded area outside the town, assaulted him and left him there. On the day of the offence, a large number of the applicant's relations had journeyed to Camooweal in the Northern Territory to attend a festival. To obtain revenge the applicant incited his relations to attack Watson, who appealed to his own family for succour. Thus, at about 10 p.m. on 11 April 1998, a group of about 70 people assembled outside the Post Office Hotel. This was the applicant's group. Watson and his followers were inside the hotel, reluctant to come out. The police sought to relieve the tension by brokering a reconciliation between the applicant and Watson. Having spoken to Watson, the police officers told the applicant that Watson did not want to fight and that he, the applicant, should "call off" his family. The applicant replied, "It's too late. All these young blokes, they want to fight. It's with the families now." He went on, "I tell them all that I've been wronged and they're going to fight for me. It's the Aboriginal way." As the applicant predicted, it was too late for negotiation and fighting broke out. As many as 200 people became involved in the tumult which appeared to consist of brawling throughout the streets of Camooweal. Luckily no-one was seriously hurt and no property was damaged. The two police officers were quite unable to impose order and had to send for reinforcements. Two other officers came from the Northern Territory and a large contingent from Mount Isa. It was only when the latter arrived at about 2.30 a.m. that the riot was quelled. Only three persons were charged as a result of the affray. One, Aplin, has not yet been dealt with. Another, Christie, a white man who involved himself gratuitously in the affair, pleaded guilty to the more serious offence of riot. He was placed on a good behaviour bond. He had no previous convictions. The submission that the sentence is manifestly excessive has two bases: (i) the personal circumstances of the applicant; and (ii) the penalty imposed was significantly greater than that imposed for similar offences. The personal circumstances are that the applicant is severely disabled. He was taken from his parents when he was an infant but this, it seems, was to ensure that he had appropriate medical treatment in Adelaide. He has led a disadvantaged life but has, nevertheless, for the most part, been law-abiding. He has a criminal history, three entries in which are for minor offences. The only other one, assault occasioning bodily harm, appears to be more than 15 years old. The occasion for the unlawful assembly was the cowardly beating given to the applicant by Watson. The applicant saw his family's presence in Camooweal as an opportunity to obtain redress. Despite initially refusing to cooperate with police who attempted to diffuse the situation, the applicant did, later, endeavour to dissuade his clan from fighting but was unsuccessful. The other point concerns sentences imposed on Christie arising out of the particular riot and sentences for other offences of taking part in an unlawful assembly given to other Aboriginal people. Christie, as I have said, pleaded guilty to the more serious offence of taking part in a riot and was given a good behaviour bond. A similar penalty was imposed upon a man called Yanner on 5 June 1996 by the District Court in Mount Isa. That offence concerned an unlawful assembly outside the Burketown police station where a number of Aboriginals, led by Yanner and one other, gathered to secure the release of a family member who was detained in the police station. The impetus for the assembly was a sense of grievance that the detained man had been vindictively treated by a sergeant of police. The Judge thought there was little substance in that sense of grievance. The sentence of the court was that Yanner be released upon entering into a recognisance in the sum of $500 conditioned upon keeping the peace and being of good behaviour for two years. While on bail awaiting trial Yanner committed an identical offence. Again the object of the assembly was the release of a family member arrested by the police. The sentencing Judge said: "When you committed this offence you were on bail for that offence but had not been convicted and I accept what you say that you have taken into account what Judge McGuire said to you on the last occasion." His Honour went on:"[B]earing in mind that this offence occurred prior to your conviction in this Court on 5 June 1996, it is appropriate in all the circumstances to impose a similar penalty to that imposed by... Judge McGuire and I order that you be released upon entering into a recognisance in the sum of $1,000 to be of good behaviour and keep the peace for a period of three years..." In October 1997, again at Mount Isa, another Judge of the District Court dealt with a number of Aboriginal persons who had been charged with and pleaded guilty to rioting at Doomadgee. The occasion was a result of a simmering feud between two families who lived in the area. All but one of the accused were released upon entering a recognisance in the sum of $100 to keep the peace and be of good behaviour for 12 months. In this case, the learned sentencing Judge when passing sentence said to the applicant: "The assembly that formed eventually developed into a riot... The police were unable to control those people and were unable to exercise any authority. It must have been very frightening to those two police officers and other citizens of Camooweal who were not involved... I take into account that you are crippled and were previously assaulted by Billy Watson. I can understand you wishing to retaliate... However, we cannot allow people to take the law into their own hands, and we certainly cannot allow a situation where in taking the law into their own hands, police authority is blatantly ignored. Such conduct leads to a total break down of law and order and causes ordinary citizens to fear for their safety... Although there is no evidence that you were personally engaged in any violence on this night, it was you who initiated this unlawful assembly and you must bear responsibility for what subsequently happened." In the course of argument the learned Judge had commented that he did not generally impose suspended prison terms, instead favouring an order for the performance of substantial community service. Such an order was inappropriate because the applicant lives in a

Background

Background to the litigation

On 11 April 1998, Douglas Toby, an Aboriginal man with a history of minor criminal offences, incited about 70 of his relatives to assemble in Camooweal, Northern Territory, leading to a large-scale affray involving up to 200 people. The assembly was in response to an assault Toby had suffered weeks earlier from Billy Watson, another Aboriginal man. Despite police attempts to broker a reconciliation, the situation escalated into a riot that lasted until reinforcements from Mount Isa and the Northern Territory arrived. Toby, who had a long-standing disability due to polio contracted in childhood, was charged with inciting an unlawful assembly that caused public alarm. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to three months imprisonment, wholly suspended for nine months.

Douglas Toby was initially charged and pleaded guilty to inciting an unlawful assembly that caused public alarm. He was sentenced in the District Court. Subsequently, Toby applied for leave to appeal against his sentence, arguing that it was manifestly excessive. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal, where Justices McMurdo, Pincus, and Chesterman considered the application. The court heard arguments regarding the severity of the sentence in comparison to similar cases and Toby's personal circumstances.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the sentence imposed on the applicant is manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the sentence imposed is disproportionate when compared to sentences imposed for similar offences on co-offenders and others in similar circumstances.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that the sentence imposed on the applicant was not manifestly excessive.
2. The Court of Appeal held that the sentence imposed was not disproportionate when compared to sentences imposed for similar offences on co-offenders and others in similar circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the application for leave to appeal against the sentence imposed on the applicant, who was sentenced to three months imprisonment wholly suspended for an unlawful assembly. The applicant contended that the sentence was manifestly excessive and disproportionate when compared to sentences imposed on co-offenders and others for similar offences. The Court of Appeal was tasked with determining whether the sentence was indeed manifestly excessive and whether it was disproportionate when compared to other sentences.

The Court first addressed the argument that the sentence was manifestly excessive. Chesterman JA noted that the applicant, while severely disabled, had incited a large group of people to assemble with the intent to cause a disturbance, leading to a significant breach of peace. The Court considered the personal circumstances of the applicant, which included his disability and disadvantaged background, but also his criminal history and the nature of his involvement in the offence. The sentencing judge had taken into account the applicant's circumstances but had ultimately imposed a sentence to ensure public safety and to deter similar conduct in the future. The Court found no error in the approach taken by the sentencing judge and held that the sentence was not manifestly excessive.

Next, the Court turned to the argument that the sentence was disproportionate. Chesterman JA compared the sentence imposed on the applicant with sentences given in similar cases, including those involving co-offenders. The Court noted that the sentences in comparable cases were often less severe, but it emphasised that each case must be considered on its own facts. The Court held that the circumstances of this case, involving a large-scale disturbance and the deliberate instigation of violence, warranted a sentence within the appropriate range. Despite the lenient sentence imposed on a co-accused, the Court concluded that the sentence imposed on the applicant was not disproportionate. The Court also highlighted the importance of maintaining public confidence in the criminal justice system and the need to deter riotous behaviour.

The Court of Appeal, in refusing the application for leave to appeal, emphasised that sentences for offences of this nature should reflect the seriousness of the breach of peace and the need to protect the community. The Court found that the sentence imposed was appropriate and not manifestly excessive or disproportionate. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that courts should consider the specific circumstances of each case, including the nature of the offence and the need for deterrence, when determining the appropriateness of a sentence for an unlawful assembly.