R v TAYLOR No. SCCRM-98-255 Judgment No. S7004

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

R v TAYLOR
[1998] SASC S7004

Court of Criminal Appeal:          Prior, Lander and Wicks JJ (ex tempore)

  1. PRIOR J:           The appellant was convicted of burglary and assault occasioning actual bodily harm.

  2. In this appeal, complaint is made about directions given by the trial judge with respect to evidence of identification.  The jury's verdict is said to be unsafe and unsatisfactory given the nature and extent of the admissible evidence. I have no doubt that the verdict could not be said to be unsafe and unsatisfactory had the matter remained as the prosecution led its case before the jury.

  3. It is said that, not only was no adequate or proper warning given as to the danger of identification evidence, but that the trial judge gave no proper direction as to how the answers of the accused could be dealt with by the jury.   It is also said that the trial judge failed to adequately deal with inconsistent statements with respect to the identification evidence.  It is not necessary to deal with this complaint given the views I have with respect to the course of the trial with respect to so-called identification evidence.

  4. The prosecution case was that, early in the morning of 19 November 1997, a house in Angas Street city was broken into.  The 80 year old occupant gave evidence of watching the intruder trying to remove a television set which had been left on in the bedroom.  The woman said that when the intruder left her room she attempted to prevent him from re-entering by placing a chair against the door.  She located the starting pistol and fired it.  The shot disturbed the intruder, who re-entered her bedroom and assaulted her, pushing down on her legs and then putting both of his hands over her face, twisting her nose around and blocking her mouth.

  5. There was evidence of fingerprints on the frame of the bedroom window.  It was the prosecution's case that the intruder gained entry into the house by way of the bathroom after unsuccessfully attempting to enter via the front bedroom window.  The fingerprints on the upper window frame at the front of the house included a right thumb print, its presence on the frame was consistent with a hand being held over the top of the window frame.  It was the evidence of a police technical services officer that the fingerprint on the window frame was a print of the appellant's right thumb.  There was also evidence that the appellant was at a house of a friend nearby on the night.  The appellant's house is also a short distance from the victim's house.

  6. The victim says that later on the same day as the burglary, the appellant, who was known to the victim as being involved with Neighbourhood Watch, came with two women saying he was interested in buying some furniture from her.  He did not buy any furniture.  The prosecution said this visit was a planned visit by the appellant to contaminate the scene some…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v TAYLOR No. SCCRM-98-255 Judgment No. S7004 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 7004
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Taylor, the appellant was convicted of burglary and assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The appeal focused on the directions given by the trial judge concerning the evidence of identification, with the argument that the jury's verdict was unsafe and unsatisfactory due to the nature and extent of the admissible evidence. The prosecution relied heavily on a response given by the victim during cross-examination, which was presented as evidence of identification of the appellant as the attacker. The appellant denied the charges, claiming that when he visited the victim's house the following day, he accidentally left his fingerprint on the window frame while trying to steady himself.

The legal issues in this appeal revolved around whether the trial judge appropriately directed the jury on the use of identification evidence, given its disputed reliability. It was argued that the trial judge did not provide an adequate warning about the dangers of relying on such evidence and failed to properly instruct the jury on how to consider the appellant's answers. Furthermore, it was contended that the trial judge did not adequately address inconsistencies in the identification evidence. The court needed to determine whether these failures by the trial judge were significant enough to warrant setting aside the conviction and ordering a retrial.

The Court of Criminal Appeal held that the trial judge should have intervened to clarify that the victim's response in cross-examination could not be regarded as an act of positive identification at the time of the attack. The judges emphasised that whenever the prosecution relies on answers given by a victim in cross-examination as evidence of identification, the trial judge must warn the jury about the dangers of convicting based on such evidence, particularly where its reliability is disputed. The Court found that the trial judge failed to properly direct the jury regarding the use of the identification evidence, which was crucial given the prosecutor's reliance on it. This failure was deemed significant enough to warrant setting aside the conviction and ordering a retrial. The appeal was thus allowed, and the appellant was remanded for trial.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.