R v Spicer; Ex parte Truth and Sportsman Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
98 CLR 48

THE QUEEN

SPICER AND OTHERS; Ex PARTE TRUTH AND SPORTSMAN LIMITED. Industrial Arbitration (Cth.)-Commonwealth Industrial Court-Right of appeal to-

From judgments etc. of State Courts in matters arising under the Conciliation and Arbitration Act- -Whether right available in respect of judgment delivered by MELBOURNE,

State Court in exercise of appellate jurisdiction-Conciliation and Arbitration May 13,

Act 1904-1956 (No. 13 of 1904-No. 103 of 1956), S. 113.

Section 113 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1956 provides

98 CLR 49

Newspapers) Award 1955 in that it did on or before 17th August 1955 terminate the employment of the complainant and did fail to give him eight weeks' notice of such termination or eight weeks' pay THE QUEEN in lieu of such notice.

On the same day the above-named complainant laid a further complaint against the above-named defendant alleging that it did, at Sydney commit a breach or non-observance of the award in that it failed to pay to the complainant his ordinary wages from 15th- 17th August 1955, both dates inclusive.

The complaints were heard together before H. Isles Esq., the Chief Industrial Magistrate, appointed under the provisions of the Industrial Arbitration Act 1940-1955 (N.S.W.), who, on 8th March 1956, ordered that the defendant be convicted and fined £10 with certain costs on each complaint and that it pay to the complainant the sum of £224 on the first complaint and the sum of £16 16s. Od. on the second complaint.

From these decisions the defendant appealed to the Industrial Commission of New South Wales constituted by Taylor, De Baun and Gallagher JJ., which Commission, on 19th December 1956, ordered that the appeals be dismissed.

From these decisions the defendant appealed to the Common- wealth Industrial Court constituted by Spicer C.J., Dunphy and Morgan JJ., which Court on 19th February 1957 ordered that the appeals be dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

On 16th April 1957 Taylor J., on the application of Truth and Sportsman Ltd., as prosecutor, granted orders nisi for writs of mandamus directed to the above-named judges of the Commonwealth Industrial Court and Voltaire Molesworth on the following ground in each case "That the Commonwealth Industrial Court was in error in holding that S. 113 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1956 did not confer jurisdiction on it to entertain the appeal

B.P. Macfarlan Q.C. (with him K. A. Cohen), for the prosecutor. Section 113 1 of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1956 covers both primary and appellate orders made after the date of coming into operation of the section. The order of the Industrial Commission of New South Wales is an order within the meaning of the section. [He referred to In re An Application by Public Service Association of N.S.W. (1).] The Commission was exercising appellate jurisdiction from what was a matter in the Chief Industrial Magistrate's Court when he determined whether or not there should

1(1947) 75 C.L.R. 430.
98 CLR 50

be a conviction under S. 59 of the Conciliation and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Spicer; Ex parte Truth and Sportsman Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1957] HCA 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *R v Spicer; Ex parte Truth and Sportsman Ltd* concerned an application for orders nisi for writs of mandamus directed to judges of the Commonwealth Industrial Court. The prosecutor, Truth and Sportsman Ltd, sought to compel the Commonwealth Industrial Court to hear appeals against judgments of the Industrial Commission of New South Wales. These judgments had dismissed appeals from decisions of a New South Wales industrial magistrate, which were made under the *Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1955*. The Commonwealth Industrial Court had previously dismissed the prosecutor's appeals on the grounds that it lacked jurisdiction.

The central legal issue before the High Court was the interpretation of section 113 of the *Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1956*. Specifically, the Court had to determine whether this section conferred jurisdiction on the Commonwealth Industrial Court to hear appeals from judgments of a State court (in this instance, the Industrial Commission of New South Wales) that were exercising appellate jurisdiction from a lower State court (the industrial magistrate). The question hinged on whether such appellate judgments constituted "a judgment, decree, order or sentence of a State court... made, given or pronounced in a matter arising under" the Act, as stipulated in section 113(1).

A majority of the High Court held that the Commonwealth Industrial Court had erred in dismissing the appeals for want of jurisdiction. The Court reasoned that section 113(1) was intended to grant the Commonwealth Industrial Court jurisdiction to hear appeals from any judgment of a State court (other than a Supreme Court) made in a matter arising under the Act, irrespective of whether that judgment was made in the exercise of original or appellate jurisdiction. While section 113(4) established the exclusivity of the Commonwealth Industrial Court's appellate jurisdiction, it did not operate to limit the scope of section 113(1) to exclude appeals from appellate judgments of State courts. The Court considered the timing of the judgments and the commencement of section 113, noting that the appeals to the Industrial Commission were heard and determined after section 113 came into operation. The majority concluded that the prosecutor's appeals to the Commonwealth Industrial Court were competent.

The orders nisi for writs of mandamus were made absolute.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established