COURT OF APPEAL
PINCUS JA DAVIES JA McPHERSON JA
CA No 500 of 1995
THE QUEEN
v.
| BARRY ROBERT SMITH | Respondent |
| ATTORNEY-GENERAL OF QUEENSLAND | Appellant |
BRISBANE
..DATE 26/02/96
260296 T13/LZG M/T COA24-25/96
McPHERSON JA: This is an appeal by the Attorney-General against
a sentence of imprisonment of five years imposed on the
respondent for the offence of manslaughter. The sentence was
accompanied by a recommendation for parole after 12 months. The
Attorney argues that the sentence was plainly inadequate.
The victim of the offence was the respondent's wife. She died in hospital a week after the respondent had admittedly injured her on the evening of 15 September 1994. On post mortem examination there was some question about the precise mechanism by which death had been brought about. Manual strangulation could not be entirely ruled out as a possibility, but the opinion that prevailed among the medical practitioners who examined the body was that death was caused by blood inhalation resulting in obstruction of the airways.
That had led to hypoxic brain damage with the consequence that there was a loss of consciousness and, ultimately, death.
In recording that I have been referring to the opinion of
Dr Naylor, who examined the brain post mortem in conjunction
with Professor Tannenberg. Dr Lallecombe, who attended the
patient after her admission to hospital, formed a similar
opinion. The information in the record is somewhat scanty
because of the way in which the matter proceeded.
Before trial the respondent was prepared to plead guilty to manslaughter; however, he was brought to trial in the Supreme Court on a charge of murder. After some evidence had been given on behalf of the prosecution the Crown accepted his plea of guilty to manslaughter. The respondent had apparently not 260296 T13/LZG M/T COA24-25/96
taken part in an interview with the police, but it is possible from information now available on sentence to piece together some impression of the sequence of events.
The physical evidence, which included photographs, showed that the respondent inflicted at least two and possibly more blows to the cheeks or face of his wife. The force of the blows was sustained on both sides of the face extending to the eyes. Medical opinion was that this may have caused the nose to bleed, and so led to the blood inhalation already referred to.
For the purpose of sentencing this was the version accepted, adopted or acted on by the Crown.
The assault was committed by the respondent on his wife following an argument between them, in the course of which she told him that she had decided to leave home. That is a common enough feature of domestic manslaughter cases, but this one differed from many others in that the marriage of 20 years or so seems to have been a happy one not attended by acts of violence on either side.
He was 48 years old and she 40 at the time of the death. It is convenient to mention…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Smith & Attorney-General of Queensland and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1996] QCA 56
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Court of Appeal involved the adequacy of the sentence imposed by the trial judge and the appropriateness of the recommendation for parole after 12 months. The Court needed to determine if the sentence was sufficiently severe given the nature of the offence and the circumstances surrounding it.
The Court of Appeal held that although the sentence of five years might be considered on the lower end of the sentencing spectrum for manslaughter, it was not so markedly low as to warrant interference. The Court considered the respondent's background, including his otherwise respectable life, employment, and community contributions, as well as the emotional turmoil he experienced at the time of the incident. The psychiatric report indicated that the respondent was in a state of grief and remorse, and the recommendation for parole took into account personal factors specific to the respondent. The Court concluded that the trial judge's sentence, while perhaps lower than some might prefer, was not unjust and should not be interfered with on appeal.
The final order was that the appeal by the Attorney-General was dismissed, and the original sentence and recommendation for parole stood.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi