99.44
COURT OF APPEAL
McMURDO P THOMAS JA WILSON J
CA No 454 of 1998
THE QUEEN
v.
| FRANCIS SIMONE | Applicant |
| BRISBANE ..DATE 26/02/99 | |
| JUDGMENT | |
| 260299 T18/BP17 M/T COA 30/99 |
THE PRESIDENT: The applicant pleaded guilty by way of one count of unlawful assault, one count of entering a dwelling with intent to alarm, one count of going armed so as to cause fear and one breach of a domestic violence protection order.
ex officio indictment on 24 November 1998 in the
He was sentenced in total to an effective sentence of three years imprisonment suspended after 12 months. The 35 days pre-sentence custody was appropriately declared as part of the sentence.
The applicant, who represents himself today, is 46 years old. His prior criminal history consists of one aggravated assault committed on his ex de defacto wife on 16 November 1996. His relationship with his ex de facto wife is at the centre of these offences, the facts of which are as follows.
The applicant had a sad life in Samoa where he was born, after his mother's death when he was only 13. It seems he was a victim of violence from his older brothers. At 17 he left for New Zealand and in 1990 came to Australia where he soon formed a relationship with Joanne Kapani.
There are five children, the youngest being only two years old. The relationship was stormy, and Ms Kapani had taken out a domestic violence order against the applicant.
2 JUDGMENT
260299 T18/BP17 M/T COA 30/99
The applicant was distraught that three of his children had been placed in care without Ms Kapani consulting him. At about 10.45 a.m. on 17 October 1998, the applicant who was heavily intoxicated arrived at Ms Kapani's residence uninvited. He drove into the driveway, blowing the horn of his car. A car belonging to Mr Elsworth was blocking the driveway. Mr Elsworth went out of the house and saw that the applicant had driven into the rear of his car and was pushing it forward.
Mr Elsworth then moved his car onto the street and an argument started. The applicant was brandishing a large knife, or part of a knife, and smashed it into the boot of Mr Elsworth's car, causing chipping to the paintwork.
The applicant then went to the front of the car and hit the windscreen with the knife, causing a number of cracks.
The applicant then chased Mr Elsworth down the street for a short distance before returning to Ms Kapani's house. The police were called. The applicant went into the premises uninvited and noticed that Ms Brown, a friend of Mr Elsworth, was present. The applicant had had a brief relationship with Ms Brown in the past.
He swore at Ms Brown and told her to get out. When she tried to leave, he terrorised her with the knife, threatening a number of times to kill her and slashing the knife about in front of her. She was cornered in
3…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Simone and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] QCA 44
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue in this case was whether the sentence imposed by the lower court was appropriate given the nature and circumstances of the offences committed by the applicant. The Court of Appeal needed to consider the seriousness of the offences, the need for deterrence, and the potential for rehabilitation. The applicant's history of violence, his lack of insight into his conduct, and the potential for grave harm caused by his actions were all factors that the Court had to weigh in its decision.
In delivering the judgment, the Court noted the serious nature of the applicant's offences, especially considering the involvement of weapons and his state of intoxication. The Court highlighted the importance of domestic violence orders and the need for severe consequences when such orders are breached. The Court found that the sentence imposed was within the proper range, taking into account the applicant's guilty plea and the need for a deterrent sentence. The Court further noted the opportunity for the applicant to use his time in custody to engage in rehabilitation programs aimed at addressing his issues with alcohol, substance abuse, and anger management. Consequently, the Court refused the applicant's appeal and upheld the sentence imposed by the lower court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi