R v Portus; Ex parte

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read
90 CLR 320

THE QUEEN

PORTUS AND ANOTHER; Ex PARTE AUSTRALIAN AIR PILOTS' ASSOCIATION. H.

Industrial Law (Cth.)--Conciliation and arbitration-Industrial dispute-Between 1953.

employers-Airline operating industry-Loy of claims served by one employer on organization of employees and on other employers-The Constitution (63 &MELBOURNE,

64 Vict. C. 12), S. 51 (xxxv.). Sept. 21, 22;

In a covering demand served with a log of claims, an airline company SYDNEY,

claimed that the wages and conditions, under which aircraft pilots of employers Dec. 17.

generally in the airline operating industry' were working, should be altered Dixon C.J.,

and that the log should govern the wages and conditions of employment of all such employees throughout the Commonwealth, whether members of the registered organization of employees or not. The log was addressed to thirteen named employers, the registered organization of employees and all other pilots employed by the employer serving the log and the thirteen named employers. It was served only on the thirteen named employers and the registered organization of employees. In a clause in the log headed area and incidence" it was stated that the log should be binding on the employer serving it and on the thirteen named employers in respect of their pilots whether members of an organization or not and on the registered organization of employees and on all the members thereof.

Held, by Dixon C.J., Fullagar and Taylor JJ. (Webb and Kitto JJ. dissent- ing), that an industrial dispute within S. 51 (xxxv.) of the Constitution cannot arise from a demand by one employer upon another employer, unconnected except by the fact that their businesses are of the same description, that the employer upon whom the demand is made shall pay a given wage to his employees or provide them with specified conditions.

Held further, by Dixon C.J., Fullagar and Taylor JJ., that the log was to be read as making a distributive demand upon each party served and was, accordingly, capable of giving rise to an industrial dispute between the employer serving it and the registered organization of employees in relation to employees of the said employer.

90 CLR 321

ORDER NISI for prohibition.

Qantas Empire Airways Ltd. served a log of claims, dated 4th September 1952, on Airlines (W.A.) Ltd., Ansett Airways Pty. Ltd., the Australian National Airlines Commission, Australian National Airways Pty. Ltd., British Commonwealth Pacific Airlines Ltd., Butler Air Transport Pty. Ltd., Connellan Airways Ltd., East-West Airlines Ltd., Guinea Airways Ltd., MacRobertson Miller Aviation Co. Pty. Ltd., Queensland Airlines Pty. Ltd., South Coast ASSOCIATION. Airways Pty. Ltd. and Trans Oceanic Airways Ltd. (In Liquidation) all of which companies were employers of air pilots, and on the Australian Air Pilots' Association, a registered organization of employees under the provisions of the Conciliation and Arbitration Act 1904-1952.

The covering demand served with the log read as follows To the employers set out in schedule 'A' attached hereto and to the Australian Air Pilots' Association, a registered organization of employees, and to all members of such organization and to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Portus; Ex parte and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1953] HCA 97
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved an order nisi for a writ of prohibition sought by the Australian Air Pilots' Association against Mr. J. H. Portus, a conciliation commissioner, and Qantas Empire Airways Ltd. The dispute arose from a log of claims served by Qantas on thirteen other airline companies and the Australian Air Pilots' Association. Qantas sought to alter the wages and conditions of aircraft pilots generally in the airline operating industry, with the log intended to govern the employment terms of all such employees, regardless of their membership in the Association. The Association argued that the log could not give rise to a valid industrial dispute within the meaning of section 51(xxxv) of the Constitution.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the log of claims, as served by one employer on other employers and an employee organization, could constitute an industrial dispute within the meaning of section 51(xxxv) of the Constitution, thereby conferring jurisdiction on a conciliation commissioner. Specifically, the Court had to determine if a demand by one employer upon another unconnected employer, concerning the latter's employee wages and conditions, could form the basis of an industrial dispute, and whether the log could be construed as making a distributive demand capable of giving rise to a dispute with the employee organization.

A majority of the High Court, comprising Dixon C.J., Fullagar and Taylor JJ., held that an industrial dispute cannot arise from a demand by one employer upon another employer, where the only connection is that their businesses are of the same description. They reasoned that such employers have no industrial relation to each other, and competition for business or labour does not establish such a relation. However, the majority also found that the log could be read as making a distributive demand upon each party served. Therefore, it was capable of giving rise to an industrial dispute between Qantas and the Australian Air Pilots' Association concerning the employees of Qantas.

The Court made the order nisi absolute, prohibiting the conciliation commissioner from further proceeding with the alleged industrial dispute, except in so far as it existed between Qantas Empire Airways Ltd. and the Australian Air Pilots' Association in relation to the employees of Qantas. Qantas was ordered to pay the costs of the Association.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established