R v Pike

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

R v Pike [2012] QSC 353

PARTIES:

R
(respondent)

v

STEPHEN JONATHON PIKE
(applicant)

FILE NO:

Indictment 131/12

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

16 November 2012

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

2 October 2012

JUDGE:

Peter Lyons J

ORDER:

1.   I overrule the objection to the evidence of Mr Howard;

2.   I overrule the objection to the evidence of Ms Green;

3.   I overrule the objection to the evidence of the purchase of a shovel, referred to in evidence to which my attention is drawn;

4.    I adjourn the application so far as it relates to Ms Wiseman's evidence, to a date to be fixed.

CATCHWORDS:

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY AND RELEVANCY – IN GENERAL – OBJECTIONS – where statement of a witness records a conversation between the witness and the applicant – where the applicant submits the witness can not remember the conversation word for word – where the applicant submits evidence suggests the witness was intoxicated at the time of the conversation – whether evidence of the conversation should be excluded on the basis it is not reliable – whether reliability of evidence is a matter for the jury

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY AND RELEVANCY – IN GENERAL – OBJECTIONS – where statement of a witness records a conversation between the witness and the applicant and alleges, in relation to the killing of his mother, the applicant said “if I did it, there would be pieces of her in the bush everywhere…[t]hey would never find the body” – where the respondent’s case is a circumstantial case where the applicant submits the evidence is not probative – where the applicant did not identify any unfairly prejudicial effect that might flow from the admission of the evidence – whether, if accepted, the jury could rationally take the evidence of the conversation into account as supporting an inference of guilt, in light of the evidence overall

where witness states that she was the person initially involved in the sale of a particular cleaning product on 24 August 2010 – where the product is described as a “powerful corrosive and caustic shock treatment” for very dirty floors – where it was not suggested that the purchaser was a person other than the applicant – where the applicant submits the evidence is of no probative value – where the respondent submits that, in the context of other evidence, it is probative – whether, if the evidence were accepted, it might rationally affect the assessment by a jury of the probability of the applicant’s guilt

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY AND RELEVANCY – FACTS RELEVANT TO FACTS IN ISSUE – PARTICULAR MATTERS – MURDER OR MANSLAUGHTER where respondent proposes to lead evidence that a shovel and two plastic sheets were purchased with cash from the Bunnings Warehouse at Burleigh heads on 13 August 2010 – where applicant submits that evidence is not probative and accordingly not relevant – where respondent submits that evidence is probative in context of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Pike and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QSC 353
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal heard by the Court was brought by the appellant, who was convicted of the murder of his mother. The respondent’s case was circumstantial and the appellant objected to the admissibility of certain evidence that the court was asked to consider. These included the evidence of a witness who recorded a conversation with the appellant that suggested his involvement in his mother’s death, the evidence of another witness that related to the sale of a corrosive cleaning product, and evidence of the purchase of a shovel and two plastic sheets. The court was required to consider the reliability of the evidence, its probative value, and whether it could rationally affect the assessment by a jury of the probability of the appellant’s guilt.

The court found that the evidence of the conversation between the witness and the appellant was reliable and that its reliability was a matter for the jury to determine. The court also found that the evidence of the sale of the cleaning product was probative in the context of other evidence and could rationally affect the assessment by a jury of the probability of the appellant’s guilt. The court further found that the evidence of the purchase of a shovel and two plastic sheets was also probative in the context of other evidence and could give rise to an inference that the appellant was the purchaser. This could constitute an intermediate fact in a rational chain of reasoning leading to a conclusion that the appellant was involved in his mother’s death.

The court overruled the objections to the evidence of the witnesses and the purchase of the shovel and plastic sheets. The court adjourned the application so far as it related to the evidence of another witness, to a date to be fixed. The court held that the evidence was admissible and that it was for the jury to determine its weight and probative value.

The court’s orders were that the objections to the evidence of the witnesses and the purchase of the shovel and plastic sheets were overruled. The application so far as it related to the evidence of another witness was adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. I overrule the objection to the evidence of Mr Howard;

2. I overrule the objection to the evidence of Ms Green;

3. I overrule the objection to the evidence of the purchase of a shovel, referred to in evidence to which my attention is drawn;

4. I adjourn the application so far as it relates to Ms Wiseman's evidence, to a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around the events leading to and following the death of the applicant's mother. A conversation between the applicant and a witness, Ms Green, was recorded in a witness statement. The applicant argued that Ms Green could not remember the conversation word for word and that there were indications she was intoxicated during the conversation. The conversation allegedly related to the applicant saying, "if I did it, there would be pieces of her in the bush everywhere…[t]hey would never find the body." Another witness, Mr Howard, also recorded a conversation with the applicant in his statement, which the applicant objected to on the basis of reliability. The respondent proposed to present evidence that a shovel and two plastic sheets were purchased from Bunnings Warehouse with cash on 13 August 2010, a day before the death of the applicant's mother. The applicant contested the probative value of this evidence, while the respondent argued it was relevant in the context of other evidence.

The matter came before the court on an application to exclude certain evidence on the basis of its unreliability and lack of probative value. The application was made by the applicant, who was on trial for the murder of his mother. The court had to decide whether certain evidence, including witness statements and the purchase of a shovel and plastic sheets, should be excluded from the trial on the grounds of reliability and relevance. The court heard arguments from both the applicant and the respondent and considered the admissibility and weight of the evidence before making its decisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the evidence of the conversation between the applicant and Ms Green should be excluded on the basis that it is not reliable.
2. Whether the reliability of the evidence is a matter for the jury.
3. Whether, if accepted, the jury could rationally take the evidence of the conversation into account as supporting an inference of guilt, in light of the evidence overall.
4. Whether the evidence of the purchase of a shovel and plastic sheets is probative and relevant in the context of other evidence.

Held
1. The court held that the evidence of the conversation between the applicant and Ms Green should not be excluded on the basis that it is not reliable.
2. The court held that the reliability of the evidence is a matter for the jury.
3. The court held that, if accepted, the jury could rationally take the evidence of the conversation into account as supporting an inference of guilt, in light of the evidence overall.
4. The court held that the evidence of the purchase of a shovel and plastic sheets is probative and relevant in the context of other evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the objections raised by the applicant concerning the admissibility and reliability of certain pieces of evidence. Regarding the conversation between the applicant and Ms Green, the court found that the reliability of the witness's recollection was for the jury to determine. The court noted that the applicant did not suggest any specific prejudicial effect from the admission of this evidence, and therefore, the court did not find grounds to exclude it. The court acknowledged that the reliability of the evidence was an issue for the jury to assess, and it would be inappropriate for the court to exclude the evidence on this basis alone.

As for the probative value of the evidence, the court considered whether the conversation could rationally support an inference of guilt if accepted by the jury. The court held that the statement made by the applicant, if accepted, could logically contribute to an inference of guilt in light of the overall evidence presented. The court emphasised that the weight and probative value of the evidence were matters to be considered by the jury.

Concerning the purchase of a shovel and plastic sheets, the court determined that the evidence was relevant and probative in the context of other evidence. The court found that the evidence of the purchase could give rise to an inference that the applicant was the purchaser and that this inference could be part of a rational chain of reasoning leading to a conclusion about the applicant’s involvement in his mother’s death. The court overruled the objection to the admissibility of this evidence, holding that it could be relevant and probative when considered alongside other evidence in the case.

The court's decisions demonstrate a clear approach to balancing the reliability and probative value of evidence against the overarching principle that the assessment of such matters is primarily for the jury. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by the court is that the reliability of evidence is a matter for the jury to determine, and probative value must be assessed in the context of the entire case. The court did not depart from any prior authority but rather applied established principles of admissibility and relevance in reaching its decisions.