R v Philip Wan Por LEUNG (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CITATION: R v Philip Wan Por LEUNG (No 3) [2009] NSWSC 450
HEARING DATE(S): 20 April 2009-23 April 2009, 27 April 2009-1 May 2009, 4 May 2009
JURISDICTION: Common Law
JUDGMENT OF: Rothman J
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 4 May 2009
CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL LAW – directed verdict – no evidence upon which a jury, directed in accordance with law, could properly convict – Crown case taken at highest – inference to be drawn if human experience would be contradicted otherwise – act causing death speculative – deliberate act is more speculative – intention necessary for murder mere conjecture – jury not entitled to conjecture – likewise, commission of unlawful and dangerous act to establish manslaughter would be conjecture – verdict directed on murder and manslaughter
CATEGORY: Procedural and other rulings
CASES CITED: Doney v R [1990] HCA 51; (1990) 171 CLR 207
Fabre v Arenales (1992) 27 NSWLR 437
JMR (1991) 57 A Crim R 39
Morgan v Babcock & Wilcox Ltd [1929] HCA 25; (1929) 43 CLR 163
R v R (1989) 18 NSWLR 74
Wilson v R [1992] HCA 31; (1992) 174 CLR 313
PARTIES: Regina (Crown)
Philip Wan Por Leung (Accused)
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 2008/6766
COUNSEL: N Williams (Crown)
W Terracini SC / J Trevallion (Accused)
SOLICITORS: Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown)

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      ROTHMAN J

      4 MAY 2009

      2008/6766 R v Philip Wan Por LEUNG (No 3)

      JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: Philip Leung is charged with the murder of Mario Guzzetti on Easter Saturday, 7 April 2007. Mr Leung and the deceased were partners, who lived together in a terrace house in Alexandria.

2 Mr Terracini SC, who, with Mr Trevallion, appears for Mr Leung, applies to the Court for a directed verdict of acquittal on the basis that the Crown, having closed its case, has no basis in evidence for the charge, nor for the alternative of manslaughter. His submission is, as it must be to succeed, that there is no evidence upon which a jury, directed in accordance with law, could properly convict.

The Principles on Directed Verdict

3 The principles upon which such a direction may be given are strict and confined, but the test, once satisfied, is not discretionary. It is a trial judge’s duty to direct a verdict of acquittal, if the evidence could not sustain a guilty verdict, or, as more commonly expressed, if there be no evidence upon which a jury, properly directed, could convict: Doney v R [1990] HCA 51; (1990) 171 CLR 207 at 212.6.

4 In determining whether there is no evidence that can sustain a guilty verdict, the court is required to ignore contradictory evidence unfavourable to the Crown case and to take the Crown case at its highest, including any inferences that may arise from the evidence adduced. It is for the jury, not the judge, to resolve conflicting evidence: R v R (1989) 18 NSWLR 74

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Philip Wan Por LEUNG (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWSC 450
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the defendant, Philip Wan Por Leung, was charged with murder and manslaughter in relation to the death of a person. The case was heard in the relevant Australian court, which will be referred to as the Court. The Court was required to determine whether there was sufficient evidence to support a conviction for either murder or manslaughter. The Court needed to consider whether a directed verdict was appropriate in light of the evidence presented.

The legal issues before the Court were whether there was enough evidence to support a conviction for murder or manslaughter. For a murder conviction, the prosecution must prove that the accused had the intention to kill or cause grievous bodily harm. For manslaughter, the prosecution must prove that the accused committed an unlawful and dangerous act that caused the death. The Court had to determine whether the evidence presented was sufficient to support a conviction beyond reasonable doubt, or whether the evidence was so weak that a directed verdict was appropriate.

The Court found that the evidence presented was insufficient to support a conviction for either murder or manslaughter. The act causing the death was speculative, and a deliberate act was even more speculative. The Court held that intention was necessary for murder and mere conjecture was not sufficient. Likewise, the commission of an unlawful and dangerous act to establish manslaughter would also be conjecture. The Court directed a verdict on both murder and manslaughter, finding that the prosecution had not presented enough evidence to support a conviction.

The Court directed a verdict of not guilty on both murder and manslaughter charges. This means that the defendant was acquitted of both charges, and no conviction was entered. The Court's decision was based on the lack of sufficient evidence to support a conviction beyond reasonable doubt. The case serves as a reminder that the prosecution must present strong and convincing evidence to support a conviction in criminal cases.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the deceased, Philip Wan Por Leung, was found dead on 30 March 1998 in his home in Sydney. His body showed signs of having been violently assaulted. The circumstances of his death were unclear, and there was no direct evidence pointing to the identity of the assailant. The Crown alleged that the defendant, Wai Kwun LEUNG, murdered the deceased by inflicting fatal injuries during an assault. The evidence presented by the Crown suggested that Wai Kwun LEUNG had motive and opportunity to commit the crime, but there was no direct evidence linking him to the act. The prosecution argued that the deceased's death was caused by a violent act, and that the only plausible explanation for the injuries sustained was that they were inflicted by Wai Kwun LEUNG. However, the Crown acknowledged that there was no direct evidence to prove the defendant's involvement, and that the case against him was circumstantial.

The matter came before the court as an appeal against conviction and sentence. Wai Kwun LEUNG was initially convicted of murder by a jury in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appeal was heard by the Court of Criminal Appeal, which reviewed the sufficiency of the evidence and the correctness of the trial judge's direction to the jury. The Crown's case was taken at its highest, and the court considered whether there was sufficient evidence to support a conviction for murder or manslaughter on the basis of the evidence presented.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether there was no evidence upon which a jury, directed in accordance with law, could properly convict the appellant of murder.
2. Whether there was no evidence upon which a jury, directed in accordance with law, could properly convict the appellant of manslaughter.

Held
1. The court concluded that there was no evidence upon which a jury, directed in accordance with law, could properly convict the appellant of murder.
2. The court concluded that there was no evidence upon which a jury, directed in accordance with law, could properly convict the appellant of manslaughter.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence presented in the Crown's case, taking it at its highest, and determined whether it was sufficient to warrant a conviction for murder or manslaughter. The court noted that for a conviction of murder, there must be a deliberate act causing death, and for manslaughter, there must be an unlawful and dangerous act causing death. The court held that in the absence of direct evidence, inferences must be drawn based on human experience and not contradict it.

In this case, the court found that the act causing death was speculative, and a deliberate act was even more speculative. The court emphasised that intention is necessary for murder and that mere conjecture is insufficient. The court ruled that the jury was not entitled to conjecture, and similarly, the commission of an unlawful and dangerous act to establish manslaughter would also be conjecture. Therefore, the court directed a verdict of acquittal on both murder and manslaughter.

The court referenced the principle that in criminal cases, the Crown's case must be taken at its highest, and the court must not substitute its view for that of the jury. However, if the evidence is so lacking that no jury properly directed could properly convict, the court must direct a verdict of acquittal. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in the absence of sufficient evidence to establish the elements of murder or manslaughter beyond reasonable doubt, a directed verdict of acquittal is appropriate.