District Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: R v Petrovski; R v Abdallah; R v Atanovski; [2012] NSWDC 168 Hearing dates: 18 May 2012; 20 June 2012; 22nd June 2012. Decision date: 22 June 2012 Before: Berman SC DCJ Decision: Sentenced to imprisonment - See paragraphs [69]; [70]; [71] and [72]
Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW - Sentence - Form 1 - Co-offenders to be sentenced together whenever possible -Parity - Differing levels of involvement and moral culpability - Totality - Drug supply - Attempted drug supply - Commercial quantity - Possess unauthorised firearm - Obtain money by deception - Possess prohibited drug - Dealing with the proceeds of crime - Controlled operation Legislation Cited: Crimes (Sentencing Procedure) Act Category: Sentence Parties: The Crown
Dobre Petrovski
Michael Abdallah
Tony AtanovskiRepresentation: Ms B Pullilnger - Petrovski
Ms N Paul - Abdallah
Mr T Healey - Atanovski
Director of Public Prosecutions
Adrian Twigg & Co - Offender Atanovski
File Number(s): 2010/ 407990 - 2010/408093 - 2010/408463 - 2011/69797
SENTENCE
HIS HONOUR: Appearing for sentence today are three drug dealers, Dobre Petrovski, Tony Atanasovski and Michael Abdallah. Their sentence proceedings were heard together because Petrovski is a co-offender with Atanasovski and Abdallah, although the latter two are not co-offenders with each other. Three other drug dealers should be mentioned who were not part of the present proceedings - Adel Mustafa, who I sentenced in December last year; Done Romanov, sentenced by Chief Judge Blanch in November last year; and Leon Candarakis, sentenced by Judge Toner in February this year.
The proceedings involving the present three offenders were heard together in order that a proper appreciation of the roles played by each offender could be ascertained. Both this Court and the Court of Criminal Appeal have commented in the past upon the undesirability of co-offenders being dealt with separately. Often enough, where co-offenders are dealt with in separate proceedings, each blames the other and it comes about that each offender is sentenced on the basis that his or her co-offender was the more culpable because of the different evidence submitted in the separate proceedings. An example of this problem can be found in the circumstance that Romanov was dealt with separately from Peskovski. When sentencing Romanov Justice Blanch, clearly on the evidence before him, found that Peskovski was "a major dealer of prohibited drugs". However, the evidence before me, clearly different to the evidence before his Honour, did not satisfy me that that description was accurate.
Notwithstanding some confusion at the commencement of these proceedings, I have endeavoured to ascertain the role played by each offender, and compare their relative culpability based on the evidence before me, with the obvious qualification flowing from the fact that, as I have mentioned earlier Atanasovski and Abdallah were not co-offenders in the offence.
Now is perhaps the appropriate time to mention that I have taken into account the principle of parity in formulating appropriate sentences for each of these offenders. No offender should have a justifiable sense…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Petrovski; R v Abdallah; R v Atanovski and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2012] NSWDC 168
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to address several legal issues, including the principle that co-offenders should be sentenced together whenever possible, and the requirement to achieve parity in sentencing. It also needed to consider the varying levels of involvement and moral culpability among the respondents, as well as the totality principle. The offences involved included the supply of commercial quantities of drugs, attempted drug supply, the possession of an unauthorised firearm, obtaining money by deception, and the possession of a prohibited drug. Each respondent was also charged with dealing with the proceeds of crime.
The court found that Petrovski played a significant role in the drug supply operation, which necessitated a substantial custodial sentence. Abdallah, who was involved in a lesser capacity, was also sentenced to imprisonment but received a shorter term. Atanovski, who had the least involvement, was also sentenced to imprisonment but for the shortest duration. The court took into account the totality of the offending and the respective roles of each respondent in determining the appropriate sentences.
The court ordered that Petrovski be sentenced to imprisonment for a specified term, Abdallah to a lesser term, and Atanovski to the shortest term. Each sentence reflected the individual culpability and role in the offending, while also considering the need for parity and the totality of the crimes committed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Sentenced to imprisonment - See paragraphs [69]; [70]; [71] and [72]
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi