R v Peter Buchanan, Justin Robert Smith and Trevor Thomas

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
CITATION: R v Peter Buchanan, Justin Robert Smith and Trevor Thomas [2004] NSWSC 815
HEARING DATE(S): 03/08/2004
JUDGMENT DATE:
4 August 2004
JUDGMENT OF: Buddin J
DECISION: Application to exclude identification evidence refused.
LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act
CASES CITED: Domican v The Queen (1992) 173 CLR 555
Festa v The Queen (2001) 208 CLR 593
Pitkin v The Queen (1995) 69 ALJR 612
R v Blick (2000) 111 A Crim R 326
R v Carusi (1997) 92 A Crim R 52
R v McDonald [2001] NSWCCA 363
R v Razzak [2004] NSWCCA 62
R v Tugaga (1994) 74 A Crim R 190

PARTIES :

Regina
Peter Buchanan
Justin Robert James Smith
Trevor Anthony Thomas
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 70054/03; 70235/03; 70236/03
COUNSEL: B Smith (Crown)
M Ramage QC (Buchanan)
J Chicken (Smith)
G Turnbull (Thomas)
SOLICITORS: SE O'Connor
John Krajcik (Buchanan)
Andrew Harris & Associates (Smith)
Adamson Solicitors (Thomas)

      IN THE SUPREME COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES
      COMMON LAW DIVISION

      BUDDIN J

      WEDNESDAY 4 AUGUST 2004

      70054/03 – REGINA v PETER BUCHANAN
      70235/03 – REGINA v JUSTIN ROBERT JAMES SMITH
      70236/03 – REGINA v TREVOR ANTHONY THOMAS

      JUDGMENT – Application by accused Justin Robert James Smith to exclude identification evidence

1 HIS HONOUR: Peter Buchanan, Trevor Thomas and Justin Smith are accused of the murder of Raymond Carrion on 5 July 1998. The alleged offence occurred in the shower block of Wing 12 of Long Bay Gaol. All three men were then inmates who were being housed in that part of the Gaol. The Crown case depends in large measure upon the evidence of another inmate who was in Wing 12 at the time. For the purposes of these proceedings, that inmate has been given the pseudonym, Ronald Stuart.

2 Objection is taken on behalf of the accused, Justin Smith, to evidence which the Crown seeks to lead from Ronald Stuart in which he purports to identify the accused as a participant in the murder of Mr Carrion. I have been requested to determine that question before the jury is empanelled and before the Crown opens its case, although it may be noted that each of the accused has been arraigned before me. The application is brought pursuant to s 137 of the Evidence Act.

3 Although the present application is made on behalf of Justin Smith alone, Mr Turnbull on behalf of the accused Thomas has foreshadowed an objection to the identification evidence which is to be led against his client. That objection gives rise to different issues from those which are currently being agitated. Nevertheless Mr Chicken has indicated that he may seek in due course to embrace them should the occasion arise. Mr Turnbull informed me that his objection does not have to be determined before the jury is empanelled. In any event Mr Turnbull is not presently in a position to make submissions in support of his objection.

4 It is necessary to briefly outline the case which the Crown seeks to lead against the accused. I…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Peter Buchanan, Justin Robert Smith and Trevor Thomas and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWSC 815
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Peter Buchanan, Justin Robert Smith and Trevor Thomas, the Supreme Court of New South Wales was tasked with determining whether identification evidence given by a witness, Ronald Stuart, should be excluded from the trial. The Crown sought to rely on Stuart's identification of the accused, Buchanan, Smith, and Thomas as participants in the murder of Raymond Carrion. The application to exclude the identification evidence was brought pursuant to section 137 of the Evidence Act. The court had to decide whether the probative value of the evidence was outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the accused.

The court considered the arguments presented by the defence, which highlighted various factors that suggested the identification evidence was unreliable. These factors included the fact that the identification was not made with complete certainty, the witness was a prison informer, the identification was made from photographs, the description given by the witness was general, the witness was in a state of apprehension, the witness had limited opportunity to observe the accused, the identification was made 19 days after the incident, and the photographs of the accused and their co-accused were compressed into the first 16 photographs shown to the witness. The defence argued that these factors, when considered together, demonstrated that the probative value of the evidence was outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice.

However, the court found that the asserted frailties of the identification evidence could be overcome by appropriate directions to the jury and by section 116 of the Evidence Act. The court also noted that there was other evidence, upon which the Crown could rely in addition to the identification evidence, such as the accused being present at the scene of the crime and a conversation in which the accused sought a fresh pair of shoes after the discovery of the deceased's body. The court concluded that there was no basis, pursuant to section 137 of the Act, upon which it should exclude the identification evidence.

The court further held that appropriately crafted directions should ensure that the jury did not use the material in an impermissible fashion and that it was properly alerted to the inherent dangers that can arise from identification evidence. The court made a non-publication order in respect of its decision, reasons, and discussion due to the stage of the proceedings at which the decision was made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.