R v Perzefi; R v Garubi; R v Tracey

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Criminal Appeal)

R v PERZEFI; R v GARUBI; R v TRACEY

[2014] SASCFC 12

Judgment of The Court of Criminal Appeal

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Nicholson)

26 February 2014

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - APPEALS BY CROWN - PRINCIPLES APPLIED BY APPELLATE COURT TO CROWN APPEALS

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE - GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE  - SENTENCE MANIFESTLY EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE

Application by the Director of Public Prosecutions for permission to appeal against three sentences imposed in the District Court. The defendants and respondents, Perzefi, Garubi and Tracey, each pleaded guilty to two counts of aggravated blackmail.  The defendants, with others, were joint participants in both offences.  Perzefi also pleaded guilty to the offence of aggravated assault. Perzefi received a head sentence of five years and six months, with a non-parole period of three years.  Tracey received a head sentence of three years and 10 months to be served cumulatively upon an activated suspended sentence of 12 months, with a non-parole period of two years and three months.  Garubi was sentenced to remain in custody until the rising of the Court on the day of sentencing, upon which he was released. The defendants faced a maximum penalty for each offence of aggravated blackmail of imprisonment for 20 years.  Perzefi faced a maximum penalty of three years’ imprisonment for the aggravated assault.

Whether the Director should be granted permission to appeal. Whether the sentences for aggravated blackmail called for a significant component on account of general deterrence. Whether there was a need for personal deterrence in respect of each of the defendants. Whether the sentences were so low as to shock the public conscience.

Held per Gray J (Kourakis CJ and Nicholson J agreeing at [1] and [48]):

(1)  Application of the Director granted in respect of each defendant. The gravity of the offending called for a substantially lengthier term of imprisonment in each case (at [27]).

(2)  The sentences imposed on each defendant were so low as to shock the public conscience (at [27]).

(3)  The Judge made material errors when sentencing Tracey and Garubi. In sentencing Tracey, the Judge erred in his approach to a prior conviction of manslaughter (at [27]). It was an error to characterise Garubi’s conduct as an act of stupidity, and to proceed to release Garubi on the rising of the Court without hearing from the Director as to the appropriateness of such a course (at [27]).

(4)  Sentences imposed on each defendant in the District Court set aside (at [45]-47]).

(5)  Perzefi sentenced to nine years’ imprisonment with the sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment imposed by Chivell DCJ to commence on the expiration of the sentence of nine years’ imprisonment.  A non-parole period of six years fixed in respect of the total period of imprisonment of 10 years (at [32]-[35], [45]).

(6)  Tracey sentenced to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Perzefi; R v Garubi; R v Tracey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SASCFC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of South Australia, constituted by the Chief Justice Kourakis, Justice Gray, and Justice Nicholson, considered appeals by the Director of Public Prosecutions against sentences imposed on the respondents, Perzefi, Garubi, and Tracey. The dispute arose from the sentencing of the three men for offences including aggravated blackmail and assault, following a criminal enterprise where a victim was threatened and coerced into parting with property. The Director contended that the sentences imposed by the District Court were manifestly inadequate.

The primary legal issues before the Full Court were whether the sentences imposed on Perzefi, Garubi, and Tracey were unduly lenient, and if so, what sentences should be substituted. Specifically, the court had to determine the appropriate head sentences and non-parole periods for each offender, considering their respective roles in the offending, their personal circumstances, and the gravity of the criminal conduct.

The Court reasoned that while Garubi played a lesser role and had shown contrition, his offending was still serious. The original sentence, which involved a suspended term and release on a good behaviour bond, was deemed inappropriate given the nature of the crimes. For Perzefi and Tracey, the Court found the original sentences to be manifestly inadequate, particularly in light of the severity of the threats and the organised nature of the criminal activity. The Court applied principles governing Crown appeals against sentence, focusing on whether the original sentences were so low as to be outside the range of a reasonable sentencing discretion.

The appeals were allowed. Perzefi was sentenced to a total of 10 years’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of six years. Tracey was sentenced to a total of nine years and six months’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of six years. Garubi's sentence was increased to four years’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of two years, and the previously imposed suspended sentence was revoked.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed

Background

Background to the litigation

Perzefi was sentenced to a head sentence of five years and six months with a non-parole period of three years. Tracey received a head sentence of three years and 10 months to be served cumulatively upon an activated suspended sentence of 12 months, producing a cumulative total of four years and 10 months’ imprisonment. A non-parole period of two years and three months was fixed. Garubi was a first offender and by the time the Judge came to impose sentence, had spent more than 12 months in custody. The Judge considered this was an appropriate punishment and determined that Garubi should remain in custody until the rising of the Court on the day of sentencing and he would then be released.Background Facts Between 2004 and 2006, two men had invested monies in a company associated with B. As a consequence, it was said that they had lost approximately $900,000.00. Apparently the two men were upset about the loss, however, they had not made any claim that any debt was owed to them by B. On 9 August 2012, one of the men met with B and told him that he was under pressure to obtain $100,000.00 of the money that had been lost. On 30 August 2012, B received a telephone call from Perzefi who identified himself as “Frank Albanian”. He said he wanted to see B about some business and asked B to meet him that evening. B refused to meet, saying he did not know who Frank Albanian was. On 31 August 2012, the defendants, together with five or six other men, attended business premises at Mitcham operated by B. Perzefi spoke to B outside his shop and then in a car park adjacent to the shopping centre. At this time, the defendants and the other men surrounded B. Perzefi informed B that he was something like the “head senior” of the Comanchero Motorcycle Club in Sydney. He claimed to have taken over a debt so that the debt was now owed by B to Perzefi. At the time, Perzefi was wearing a jacket, to which there appeared to be attached a Comanchero badge. Perzefi showed B a slip of paper which had words to the effect of “My dad is owed 600k and I am owed 750k” handwritten on it. The words “total 1.35 million” were also written on the paper. B was threatened that if he did not pay, he and his family, including his elderly mother, would be dealt with violently. Perzefi said he would take over B’s business and make life very hard for him. He threatened to kill B’s mother. Perzefi said words to B to the effect of, “I know where you live in North Adelaide” and “you can sell your home and pay us”. Perzefi demanded that some of the debt be repaid. He informed B that if no payment was made, B would be put in the boot of a car and taken away. Perzefi demanded B’s car and B handed the keys to Tracey. The vehicle was later driven away. Tracey provided B with a phone number to contact him. Perzefi told B to contact “Tee” on that number to work out payment of the money. B was further threatened that if payment was not made, the men would return to his business and take his property.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It may be accepted that Garubi’s role was a lesser role than that of his co-offenders, however, he engaged in serious criminal offending. In the circumstances, I would impose a term of imprisonment of four years. In arriving at this sentence, I have made a reduction of 12 months on account of his pleas of guilty, and contrition and remorse. In fixing a substantially shorter head sentence than that imposed on the co-offenders, I have had particular regard to his youth and good record. I have also had regard to the lesser role he played in the criminal activities. In the ordinary course, I would have fixed a merciful non-parole period. However, Garubi has spent more than 12 months in custody. In this circumstance, I consider it to be inappropriate for Garubi to be returned to prison. On the other hand, I consider it to be entirely inappropriate for him to be released without parole and without supervision. In these unusual circumstances, I would impose a head sentence of four years, but suspend that sentence on Garubi entering into a three-year supervised good behaviour bond. I would fix a non-parole period of two years.Conclusion I would make the following orders in regard to the appeal concerning Perzefi:-That permission to appeal be granted to the Director in respect of the sentences imposed by the Judge and Chivell DCJ and the appeals allowed. -That the sentences imposed in the District Court be set aside. -That Perzefi be sentenced in respect of the counts of aggravated blackmail and the offence of assault to the one sentence of nine years’ imprisonment.-That the sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment imposed by Chivell DCJ in regard to the firearms offences be confirmed. -That the non-parole period fixed by Chivell DCJ be set aside.-That the sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment imposed by Chivell DCJ commence on the expiration of the sentence of nine years’ imprisonment.-That a non-parole period of six years be fixed in respect of the total period of imprisonment of 10 years. -That the sentence of nine years’ imprisonment and the non-parole period of six years be taken to have commenced on 13 September 2012. I would make the following orders in regard to the appeal concerning Tracey:-That permission to appeal be granted to the Director and the appeal allowed. -That the sentence imposed in the District Court be set aside. -That Tracey be sentenced to a term of imprisonment of eight years and six months in respect of the two offences of aggravated blackmail. -That the suspension of the sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment imposed on 7 July 2011 be revoked. -That the sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment commence on the expiration of the sentence of eight years and six months’ imprisonment.-That a non-parole period of six years be fixed in respect of the total period of imprisonment of nine years and six months. -That the sentence of imprisonment of eight years and six months and the non-parole period of six years both commence on 13 September 2012.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.