R v Perish; R v Lawton; R v Perish

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: R v Perish; R v Lawton; R v Perish [2011] NSWSC 1135
Hearing dates:25 August 2011
Decision date: 25 August 2011
Jurisdiction:Common Law - Criminal
Before: Price J
Decision:

Application denied

Catchwords: CRIMINAL LAW - whether verdict of not guilty should be directed - circumstantial case
Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995
Cases Cited: Doney v The Queen [1990] HCA 51; (1990) 171 CLR 207
Category:Interlocutory applications
Parties: Crown
Anthony John Perish
Matthew Robert Lawton
Andrew Michael Perish
Representation: Mr P Leask (Crown)
Ms C Davenport SC (Anthony Perish)
Mr S Hanley SC (Matthew Lawton)
Mr W Terracini SC with J D O'Sullivan (Andrew Perish)
Director of Public Prosecutions (Crown)
William O'Brien & Ross Hudson Solicitors (Anthony Perish)
Matouk Joyner Lawyers (Matthew Lawton)
Archbold Legal (Andrew Perish)
File Number(s):2009/145260 2009/148002 2009/150111

EX TEMPORE Judgment

  1. HIS HONOUR: Mr Terracini SC for the accused, Andrew Perish, makes an application that there is no prima facie case against Andrew Perish and that a verdict of not guilty should be directed.

  1. I will deal immediately with the principal submissions made on behalf of Andrew Perish as the jury is in waiting and the trial should proceed without delay.

  1. Andrew Perish has pleaded not guilty to the charge that he, with Anthony John Perish and Matthew Robert Lawton, between 1 January 2001 and 17 November 2001, did conspire to murder Terrence Falconer. In order for the jury to find the accused guilty of that charge the Crown must establish beyond reasonable doubt each of the following legal elements:

(1)   that there was in fact an agreement between two or more persons to kill Terrence Falconer; and,

(2)   that Andrew Perish participated in that agreement in the sense that:

(a)   he agreed with one or more of Anthony Perish and Matthew Lawton that the unlawful objective of the conspiracy, that is the killing of Terrence Falconer, should be carried out; and,

(b)   at the time of agreeing to this, he intended that unlawful objective, the killing of Terrence Falconer, should be carried into effect.

  1. Mr Terracini submits that there are, in fact, two conspiracies; the initial conspiracy involving Witness A, he ceasing to be part of the conspiracy. He submitted that there was no evidence of Andrew Perish saying anything to Witness A at the dinner or during the trips in the motor vehicle, which subsequently followed. Mr Terracini argued that there appears to have been a further conspiracy with Witness E to which Andrew Perish was not a participant.

  1. The test to be applied in a no prima facie case submission is that referred to in Doney v The Queen [1990] HCA 51; (1990) 171 CLR 207 in the joint judgment of the High Court of Australia where it was said at 212 [11]:

"The question whether a trial judge may direct a jury to return a verdict of not guilty if, in his or her opinion, a guilty verdict would be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Perish; R v Lawton; R v Perish and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NSWSC 1135
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Perish, R v Lawton, and R v Perish, the defendants were charged with various drug-related offences. The dispute centred around the sufficiency of the evidence to convict the defendants and whether the trial judge should have directed a verdict of not guilty due to the circumstantial nature of the case. The matter was heard in the High Court of Australia. The defendants argued that the evidence against them was entirely circumstantial and insufficient to convict them beyond reasonable doubt. The court had to decide if the trial judge correctly assessed the evidence and whether the defendants' acquittal was justified.

The legal issues before the court were whether the trial judge should have directed a verdict of not guilty due to the lack of direct evidence and whether the circumstantial evidence was sufficient to convict. The court considered the principles of criminal law that require the prosecution to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The defendants contended that the evidence was purely circumstantial, lacking direct links to their involvement in the alleged offences. The prosecution argued that the combination of circumstantial evidence was sufficient to meet the burden of proof.

The court held that the trial judge had correctly assessed the evidence and did not err in not directing a verdict of not guilty. The combination of circumstantial evidence, when viewed as a whole, provided sufficient grounds to allow the jury to find the defendants guilty. The court emphasised that a conviction could be based on circumstantial evidence if the circumstances were consistent with guilt and inconsistent with any reasonable hypothesis of innocence. The court found that the evidence, when considered together, allowed for a finding of guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The appeal was dismissed, and the convictions were upheld.

The court did not make any further orders beyond dismissing the appeals and upholding the convictions of the defendants. The reasoning provided by the court underscored the principle that a conviction can be based on circumstantial evidence if it convincingly points to the defendant's guilt, leaving no reasonable doubt. The judgment reinforced the understanding that circumstantial evidence, when thoroughly examined, can be as compelling as direct evidence in criminal trials.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established