COURT OF APPEAL
McPHERSON JA
WILLIAMS J
MUIR J
CA NO 315 OF 1998
THE QUEEN
v.
BRODWYN MARGRET O'ROURKE Applicant/Appellant
BRISBANE
..DATE 28/10/98
JUDGMENT
WILLIAMS J: On 1 September 1998 the applicant appeared in the District Court at Maryborough and was sentenced to 12 months imprisonment. She had initially on 1 July 1997 pleaded guilty to a breaking and entering offence and on that occasion had been released on probation for 12 months.
It is admitted that she breached that probation order in that she failed to report as and when required to the appropriate officer and also failed to notify that officer of her change of address. In consequence on 1 September 1998 a District Court Judge opted to sentence her again for the initial break and enter offence and it was in those circumstances that the order that she be imprisoned for 12 months was made.
The original offence was a reasonably serious one. On the evening of 30 December 1996 she attended a party at a residence near Ipswich. There was a male person at that party whose name so far as is revealed by the record was "Spud." Spud has not subsequently been arrested or charged in connection with the offences. But it was accepted by the Crown and by the sentencing Judge that Spud was the prime mover in connection with the offence and that he was the one who actually entered the residence next door to where the party was being held and removed the property.
The material before the Court would suggest that the applicant went on to the verandah of the neighbouring house and there received from Spud bags of goods which she carried back to the house at which the party was being held.
Subsequently when her residence was searched, police found a significant quantity of the property which had been taken from the burgled house.
At the initial sentence there was some difference of view as to the value of the property taken. The figure of $5745.65 was then mentioned. However on 1 September the Crown Prosecutor then appearing stated to the Court that the amount of property taken was $2893. In the circumstances it is appropriate to regard that latter figure as the value of the property that was involved in the offence committed by the applicant. As I said, quite a deal of property was discovered at her residence and that of course has been returned.
The applicant has no criminal history. She was born on 30 December 1960 and was thus about 36 years of age when the offences were committed. She had two teenage children. It would appear that after being placed on probation, she experienced difficulty in controlling those two children. It was partly because of problems associated with those children that she made the decision to move from the Ipswich area to Tin Can Bay. As I have already noted, she did not notify her probation officer of that move.…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v O'Rourke and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] QCA 449
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the sentence of 12 months imprisonment was manifestly excessive and should be reviewed. The Court considered the nature of the original offence, the appellant's role in it, and her compliance with the probation order. The appellant had no prior criminal history, and her role in the offence was not a leading one. She pleaded guilty due to the assistance she provided to another individual, who was the main perpetrator. The breach of the probation order was not the commission of a further criminal offence, but rather a failure to comply with reporting conditions.
The Court found that the sentence of 12 months imprisonment was manifestly excessive, taking into account the appellant's clean criminal record, her limited role in the original offence, and the fact that the breach of the probation order was not a new criminal offence. The Court concluded that while the appellant was not suitable for further probation, she would benefit from having a good behaviour condition hanging over her. Therefore, the Court of Appeal granted leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, and ordered that the sentence of 12 months imprisonment be immediately suspended under section 144 of the Penalties and Sentences Act, with an operational period of two years.
Background
Background to the litigation
The applicant initially pleaded guilty to the breaking and entering offence on 1 July 1997 and was placed on probation for 12 months. Due to her failure to comply with the probation conditions, she appeared in the District Court at Maryborough on 1 September 1998, where she was sentenced to 12 months imprisonment. The applicant then appealed the sentence to the Court of Appeal, seeking a review of the sentence on the grounds that it was manifestly excessive and that she was not a suitable candidate for further probation. The Court of Appeal granted the application for leave to appeal, allowed the appeal, and ordered that the sentence of 12 months imprisonment be immediately suspended under section 144 of the Penalties and Sentences Act, with an operational period of two years.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence of 12 months imprisonment imposed by the District Court is manifestly excessive.
2. Whether the applicant is a suitable candidate for further probation.
3. What alternative sentence should be imposed by the Court of Appeal, considering the applicant's background and the nature of her offence.
Held
1. The sentence of 12 months imprisonment imposed by the District Court is manifestly excessive.
2. The applicant is not a suitable candidate for further probation.
3. The appropriate alternative sentence is for the 12-month imprisonment sentence to be immediately suspended under section 144 of the Penalties and Sentences Act, with an operational period of two years.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal considered the severity of the sentence imposed by the District Court and the circumstances surrounding the applicant's breach of probation. The Court noted that the original offence was serious, involving a significant amount of stolen property. However, the applicant had no criminal history, and her role in the offence was secondary, as she had pleaded guilty due to her assistance to the main perpetrator and her receipt of some stolen property. The breach of probation was due to the applicant's failure to report and notify of a change of address, rather than the commission of a new criminal offence. The probation officer's report indicated that the applicant had been non-compliant and unsuitable for community supervision, leading to the sentencing judge's decision to impose a 12-month imprisonment sentence. The Court of Appeal held that this sentence was manifestly excessive and should be reviewed. The Court found the applicant unsuitable for further probation, considering her past compliance issues and the probation officer's recommendation. In light of these findings, the Court ordered that the 12-month imprisonment sentence be immediately suspended under section 144 of the Penalties and Sentences Act, with a two-year operational period. This decision was based on the applicant's background, her limited role in the offence, and the need for a good behaviour condition to be in place for a certain period. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a manifestly excessive sentence may be reviewed by a higher court, and the court may impose a suspended sentence with an operational period as an alternative to imprisonment for certain offenders.