R v HUYEN THI THU HUYEN, TUNG QUANG TRAN & DUNG HOANH HUYEN
[2001] SADC 33
Judge Lunn
Criminal
REASONS FOR SENTENCE
Huyen Thi Thu Nguyen (“Huyen”) and Dung Hoanh Nguyen (“Dung”) are sister and brother. At the relevant times Tung Quang Tran (“Tung”) was the defacto husband of Huyen. On 26 February 2001 Huyen pleaded guilty to three counts of taking part in the sale of heroin, contrary to s32(1)(d) of the Controlled Substances Act 1984, Tung to two counts of that offence and Dung to one count of that offence.
In early 2000 the police had reason to suspect that Huyen was involved in the sale or supply of heroin. An undercover operation was set up under the Criminal Law (Undercover Operations) Act 1995 in relation to her suspected activities.
On 28 April 2000 an undercover police officer posing as a drug addict rang Huyen on her mobile phone and arranged to purchase heroin from her. Shortly afterwards the undercover police officer went to a supermarket car park. A car pulled up alongside his car which was driven by Tung and in which Huyen was a passenger. Huyen got out of her car and into the car of the undercover police officer. She handed him two balls which contained 0.97 gms of powder of which 0.47 gms was heroin and he handed her $380 in cash. Huyen then got back into the car in which she had come and it drove off.
On 4 May 2000 the undercover police officer again rang Huyen on her mobile phone and made an arrangement to buy a greater quantity of heroin. Shortly afterwards the undercover police officer went to the same supermarket car park. Huyen did not attend there but Tung did. He spoke to the undercover police officer and handed him two balls containing 1.9 gms of powder of which 1.05 gms was heroin in exchange for $700 in cash. After Tung had left the car park the police officer rang Huyen who confirmed that Tung was her boyfriend and her driver and they discussed a bigger purchase in the following week.
On 12 May 2000 the undercover police officer again rang Huyen and arranged to buy more heroin from her, but a different meeting place was arranged. Shortly afterwards the undercover police officer again rang Huyen concerning the location of the meeting place and she said that her brother would see him there. The undercover police officer drove to the meeting place where Dung waved him down and got into his car. Huyen was not there. Dung then handed the police officer a small ball containing 3.96 gms of powder of which 2.17 gms was heroin in exchange for $1,400 in cash. Each of Huyen, Tung and Dung were arrested by police later on 12 May, but each on legal advice declined to answer questions about the heroin transactions.
Huyen is 26 years of age. She was born in Saigon and came to Australia as a refugee when she…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Nguyen, Tran & Nguyen No. DCCRM-00-820 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SADC 33
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues at hand included assessing the extent of each defendant's involvement, the role they played in the heroin trade, and the mitigating factors that could potentially influence the severity of their sentences. The court had to balance the need for deterrence against the personal mitigating factors presented by each defendant. The starting points for the sentences were determined by the amount of heroin involved and the precedents set by previous cases.
The court concluded that while each defendant had personal mitigating factors, the overall involvement in the heroin trade and the need for general deterrence outweighed these factors. Huyen, who played a significant role in the heroin sales, was sentenced to five years imprisonment with a non-parole period of 2½ years. Tung, who participated in two sales out of loyalty to Huyen, was sentenced to 3 years and 3 months with a non-parole period of 22 months. Dung, who was involved in one larger transaction and had a more extensive criminal record, also received a sentence of 3 years and 3 months with a non-parole period of 22 months. The court also ordered the forfeiture of the heroin and cash recovered from the defendants.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi