CITATION: R v Nguyen [2000] NSWCCA 44 FILE NUMBER(S): CCA 60637/98 HEARING DATE(S): Friday 25 February 2000 JUDGMENT DATE:
25 February 2000PARTIES :
Regina v Kiet Huu NguyenJUDGMENT OF: Grove J at 1, 19; Smart AJ at 2
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S) : 97/11/0649 LOWER COURT JUDICIAL
OFFICER :Naughton DCJ
COUNSEL : P. G. Berman (Crown)
S.R. Norrish QC (Appellant)SOLICITORS: S. E. O'Connor (Crown)
T.A. Murphy (Appellant)CATCHWORDS: Criminal Law and Procedure - Demand Money With Menaces - Sentence - Organized Attempt at Extortion from Operators of Brothel - Group of Men Attend to Enforce Demand - Some Armed - Inferences of Knowledge Available to Sentencing Judge DECISION: Leave to Appeal Refused.
IN THE COURT OF
60637/98
CRIMINAL APPEAL
GROVE J
SMART AJ
Friday 25 February 2000REGINA v KIET HUU NGUYEN
JUDGMENT1 GROVE J: I will ask Smart AJ to give the first judgment.
2 SMART AJ: Kiet Huu Nguyen seeks leave to appeal against the severity of a sentence comprising a minimum term of three years six months and an additional term of one year two months for the offence of demanding money with menaces. The applicant was convicted after a six day trial.
3 The judge found the following facts:
"At about 9pm on Wednesday 19 February 1997 a receptionist at 'The Wild Orchid' Private Hotel at 429A Pitt Street, Sydney received a telephone call from Nhan Thanh Troung. The receptionist did not know that man. He introduced himself to the receptionist as "Tony". Troung said that he wanted protection money of $500 a week and that he wanted to see the person in charge of 'The Wild Orchid' at 7pm on Friday 21 February 1997. The receptionist told the manager who in turn contacted the police.
On Friday afternoon 21 February 1997 undercover police officers set up a video camera in the office of "The Wild Orchid" Private Hotel. Just after 7.15pm undercover police officers posing respectively as the manager of the private hotel and as a bartender saw Minh Han Ly and the prisoner Karauwan enter the reception/bar/lounge room next to the office. Each of them was armed with a loaded .22 calibre semi-automatic pistol. Neither of them had a licence authorising possession of those weapons. The weapons were not produced and were not visible.
A short time after the entry of Ly and Karauwan, Troung and Nguyen entered the premises. They were shown into the office by a staff member of the premises. The office was immediately adjacent to the reception/bar/lounge room.
The undercover police officer who was posing as the manager said to Troung, 'Who are you?' He said, "My name is Tony." The officer said to Nguyen, 'Who are you?' He said, "I'm Kiet." Troung then said to the officer, 'You know why we are here.' The officer said, "No, why are you here?" Troung said, 'Our brothers were here a couple of nights ago.' The officer said to Nguyen, "What's he…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Nguyen and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [2000] NSWCCA 44
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of R v Nguyen involved an appeal against sentence by the respondent, who was part of a group involved in a serious criminal enterprise. The group attempted to extort money from the operators of a brothel in Melbourne. The crime involved multiple individuals, some of whom were armed, attending the brothel and demanding money. The respondents were found guilty of various offences, including demanding money with menaces. The trial judge handed down a sentence of imprisonment, which the respondent now appealed, arguing that the sentence was excessive.
The primary legal issue before the court was the appropriateness of the sentence imposed by the trial judge. The respondent argued that the sentence was manifestly excessive, particularly in light of the mitigating factors presented. The court was required to assess the seriousness of the crime, the role of the respondent within the group, and whether the sentence was disproportionate. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the trial judge erred in failing to properly account for the mitigating factors.
In determining the appeal, the court examined the nature and gravity of the crime. The group's actions were described as an organised attempt at extortion, involving multiple participants, some of whom were armed. The court held that the trial judge correctly assessed the seriousness of the crime and the need for deterrence. The respondent's role was significant, and the court found that the sentence was not manifestly excessive. The mitigating factors, while acknowledged, did not warrant a significantly reduced sentence. The court concluded that the trial judge appropriately balanced the need for punishment and deterrence against the mitigating factors.
The appeal was dismissed. The sentence of imprisonment imposed by the trial judge was upheld as appropriate given the nature and gravity of the crime, the role of the respondent, and the need for general deterrence. The court found no error in the trial judge's assessment or in the sentence handed down.
The primary legal issue before the court was the appropriateness of the sentence imposed by the trial judge. The respondent argued that the sentence was manifestly excessive, particularly in light of the mitigating factors presented. The court was required to assess the seriousness of the crime, the role of the respondent within the group, and whether the sentence was disproportionate. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the trial judge erred in failing to properly account for the mitigating factors.
In determining the appeal, the court examined the nature and gravity of the crime. The group's actions were described as an organised attempt at extortion, involving multiple participants, some of whom were armed. The court held that the trial judge correctly assessed the seriousness of the crime and the need for deterrence. The respondent's role was significant, and the court found that the sentence was not manifestly excessive. The mitigating factors, while acknowledged, did not warrant a significantly reduced sentence. The court concluded that the trial judge appropriately balanced the need for punishment and deterrence against the mitigating factors.
The appeal was dismissed. The sentence of imprisonment imposed by the trial judge was upheld as appropriate given the nature and gravity of the crime, the role of the respondent, and the need for general deterrence. The court found no error in the trial judge's assessment or in the sentence handed down.