R v McMUTRIE
[2002] SASC 253
Court of Criminal Appeal Perry, Williams & Gray JJ
PERRY J I agree that the appeals against conviction and sentence should be dismissed for the reasons given by Gray J.
WILLIAMS J For the reasons given by Gray J I agree that the appeals against conviction and sentence should be dismissed.
GRAY J This is an appeal against conviction and sentence.
The appellant Anthony John Stanley McMutrie was charged with attempted murder[1], wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm[2], possession of an object (a knife) with intent to kill or to cause grievous bodily harm[3] and contravening a restraining order[4]. On 3 September 2001 he pleaded guilty to acting in contravention of the restraining order. The other three charges proceeded to trial. A jury acquitted the appellant of attempted murder and of wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm. He was found guilty of the alternative charges of unlawful wounding[5] and possessing an object with intent to kill, endanger life or to cause grievous bodily harm.
[1] “Statement of Offence
Attempted Murder. (Sections 11 and 270A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935).
Particulars of Offence
Anthony John Stanley McMutrie on the 18th day of March 2001 at Berri, attempted to murder Sharon Christine Pogorelec.
[2] Statement of Offence
Wounding with Intent to do Grievous Bodily Harm. (Section 21 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935).
Particulars of Offence
Anthony John Stanley McMutrie on the 18th day of March 2001 at Berri, unlawfully and maliciously wounded Sharon Christine Pogorelec, with intent to do her grievous bodily harm.
[3] Statement of Offence
Possession of an Object with Intent to Kill or to Cause Grievous Bodily Harm. (Section 31 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935).
Particulars of Offence
Anthony John Stanley McMutrie on the 18th day of March 2001 at Berri, without lawful excuse, had the custody or control of an object, namely a knife, intending to use that knife to kill, endanger the life of or to cause grievous bodily harm to Sharon Christine Pogorelec.
[4] Statement of Offence
Contravene a Restraining Order (Section 99I of the Summary Procedure Act, 1921).
Particulars of Offence
Anthony John Stanley McMutrie on the 18th day of March 2001 at Berri, contravened a restraining order made in Magistrates Court of South Australia sitting at Berri.
[5] Section 24 of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA)
The maximum penalty for unlawful wounding is five years imprisonment, for possessing a knife with intent seven years imprisonment and for breach of a restraining order two years imprisonment.
The learned sentencing judge indicated that the possession of the knife was part and parcel of the events which constituted the crime of unlawful wounding. The judge applied the provisions of section 18A of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) and imposed the one penalty for all offences including the breach of a restraining order. A sentence of three years imprisonment was imposed and an 18 month non…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v McMutrie No. Sccrm-02-108, Sccrm-02-240 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] SASC 253
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court were whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive or inadequate, and whether the trial judge erred in his assessment of the appropriate sentence. The appellant submitted that the sentence was manifestly excessive, particularly because it did not adequately reflect the circumstances of the case and failed to take into account the mitigating factors presented during sentencing. The appellant argued for a reduction in the sentence, citing the principles of proportionality and the need for a sentence that is just and appropriate to the offence.
The court examined the principles of sentencing and found that the trial judge had considered all relevant factors, including the seriousness of the offences, the appellant's criminal history, and the need for general and specific deterrence. The court held that the sentence was proportionate to the offences committed and that the trial judge had appropriately exercised his discretion. The appeal against sentence was dismissed, and the original sentence was affirmed. The court found that the sentence was neither manifestly excessive nor inadequate, and that the trial judge had adequately considered the relevant mitigating and aggravating factors.
The final orders of the court were that the appeal against sentence was dismissed, and the original sentence imposed by the trial judge was affirmed. The appellant's conviction remained unchanged, and he was to serve the 18-year sentence, with a non-parole period of 13 years.
Background
Background to the litigation
The circumstances leading up to the altercation between McMutrie and Pogorelec are not entirely clear from the case note, but it is known that the two had a prior relationship, and the restraining order was likely issued to protect Pogorelec from McMutrie's violence. On the day of the incident, McMutrie confronted Pogorelec in Berri, despite the restraining order being in place. The altercation escalated, resulting in Pogorelec being wounded, and McMutrie being charged with the aforementioned offences.
The material facts of the case are largely based on the charges laid against McMutrie and the particulars of those offences. The evidence presented in the trial would have likely included witness statements, forensic evidence, and any other relevant information that supported the charges. However, the case note does not provide details of the evidence presented, and it is not necessary to discuss the legal issues, reasoning, or outcome of the case in this section.
The case of R v McMutrie No. Sccrm-02-108, Sccrm-02-240 originated in the Magistrates Court of South Australia where Anthony John Stanley McMutrie was initially charged and convicted on multiple counts including attempted murder, wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm, possession of an object with intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm, and contravening a restraining order. Following the conviction, McMutrie appealed the sentence imposed by the magistrate to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The appeal, Sccrm-02-108, was subsequently allowed, leading to the case being remitted back to the Magistrates Court for resentencing. The case was then renumbered as Sccrm-02-240. After the resentencing by the magistrate, the Crown, unsatisfied with the sentence, appealed again to the Supreme Court of South Australia on the grounds of the appropriateness of the sentence. This second appeal, Sccrm-02-240, is the matter currently before the Supreme Court. Prior to the final hearing, the court considered the submissions and evidence presented at the resentencing hearing and reviewed the legal standards for sentencing in similar cases. The court also took into account the arguments advanced by both the appellant and the respondent concerning the adequacy of the sentence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: PERRY J, WILLIAMS J, GRAY J
In the case of R v McMutrie, the Court of Appeal meticulously reviewed the sentence imposed by the trial judge, which included convictions for attempted murder, wounding with intent to do grievous bodily harm, possession of an object with intent to kill or cause grievous bodily harm, and contravening a restraining order. The court began by examining the appropriateness of the sentence in light of the severity of the crimes committed. The attempted murder charge alone, as outlined in Section 11 and 270A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act, 1935, indicated an intent to take a life, a crime of profound gravity. The court recognized that the trial judge had appropriately considered the heinous nature of these crimes, which warranted a severe sentence to reflect the gravity of the offenses and to ensure public safety.
The court then turned to the issue of whether there were any errors in the application of the law by the trial judge. It was noted that the trial judge had thoroughly considered the statutory provisions and precedents applicable to each of the charges. The court upheld the trial judge's approach, affirming that there were no legal errors that would warrant a reduction or alteration of the sentence. The judge had correctly applied principles from previous cases, such as the approach in (1971) 1 SASR 219 at 258, which underscored the importance of proportionality and deterrence in sentencing for violent crimes.
Further, the court examined the totality of the circumstances, including the nature of the offenses, the circumstances of their commission, and the appellant's criminal history. The appellant had a significant criminal history, which the trial judge had appropriately factored into the sentencing process. The court held that the totality of the circumstances justified a severe sentence, considering the appellant's persistent involvement in violent criminal activities. The decision in (1982) 149 CLR 1 at 22-23 was cited as authority, reinforcing the principle that a lengthy criminal history can warrant a higher degree of punishment to achieve effective deterrence and protection of society.
In light of the above considerations, the court concluded that the appeal against sentence should be dismissed. The sentence imposed by the trial judge was found to be entirely appropriate given the gravity of the crimes and the appellant's criminal history. The principles of proportionality, deterrence, and protection of society were all appropriately balanced in the sentence. The trial judge's application of the law was accurate, and no legal errors were found. Therefore, the ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases involving severe violent crimes with a significant criminal history, the courts will affirm sentences that appropriately reflect the gravity of the offenses and consider the totality of the circumstances, including the offender's criminal history. The court departed from no prior authority and followed established principles from previous cases, ensuring consistency with the broader sentencing framework.