R v Maurangi and Rivett No. Sccrm-00-140

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

R v MAURANGI AND RIVETT
[2000] SASC 347

Criminal

1................ MATHESON AJ:........... The accused are charged with murder. Particulars of the offence alleged against them are that on 10 January 1999 at Holden Hill they murdered Svetislav Zegarac. The accused, Rivett, admitted in his statement to the police that he went to the Ultimate Billiards and Pool Centre to steal money and alcohol. In his statement, he said he entered the premises with the accused, Maurangi, armed with Maurangi’s sawn off shot gun. He admitted that he fatally shot the deceased in the stomach, that he had been aiming the gun at the deceased whilst he was lying on the floor at what must have been close range, that the gun was loaded, that he had his finger on the trigger, but that he did not intend to press the trigger and is unable to explain why the gun fired. In his statement to the police, the accused, Maurangi, denied he was there. The Crown Prosecutor sought to prove murder as defined at common law, and alternatively, as defined by s 12A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935, (“the Act”).

  1. Section 12A was inserted in the Act by the Criminal Law Consolidation (Felonies and Misdemeanours) Amendment Act 1994 which, inter alia, provided for the abolition of the classification of offences as felonies and misdemeanours.  It reads:

    “A person who commits an intentional act of violence while acting in the course or furtherance of a major indictable offence punishable by imprisonment for ten years or more (other than abortion), and thus causes the death of another, is guilty of murder.”

  2. In R v R;R v G (1995) 63 SASR 417 a court constituted by five judges had to consider whether the common law felony murder doctrine applied to a participant in a joint criminal enterprise other than the perpetrator of the death that occurred in the course of or in furtherance of the enterprise. The Court unanimously held that if two persons are engaged in an armed robbery, only one of them holding a knife which kills the victim, then both are guilty of murder.

  3. In a judgment with which three of the other four members of the court agreed, King CJ said at p 420:

    “The common law as to felony murder applied in South Australia at the time of the subject incident.  Since then it has been abolished by statute in consequence of the abolition of the concepts of felony and misdemeanour, and has been replaced by a more or less equivalent provision:  Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935, s 12A. The common law rule as formulated by this Court in R v Van Beelen (1973) 4 SASR 353 at 403 is that ‘it is murder to cause death in the commission of or in furtherance of the commission of a felony involving violence or danger’.”

  4. Parenthetically, I note that the Full Court in Van Beelen said immediately before the words just quoted by King CJ “abortion…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Maurangi and Rivett No. Sccrm-00-140 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 347
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the accused, Maurangi and Rivett, are charged with the murder of Svetislav Zegarac during an armed robbery at the Ultimate Billiards and Pool Centre. The primary legal issues revolve around the interpretation of Section 12A of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935, which defines murder under specific circumstances, and whether the actions of the accused fall within this definition. The court examined whether the presentation of a loaded firearm in a menacing manner constitutes an "intentional act of violence," and if such an act could be considered the cause of death under the statute.

The court considered the Second Reading Speech of the Minister introducing the 1994 amendment to the Act, which indicated that the statute was intended to replace the common law "felony-murder rule" with a more limited application, specifically targeting major indictable offences. The court also referenced the High Court’s decision in Ryan v The Queen, which highlighted that even if an act resulting in death was involuntary, it could still be considered an act of violence if it was part of a series of deliberate actions during the commission of a crime.

In ruling on the case, the court held that the presentation of a loaded and cocked shotgun at a person at close range in a menacing manner constituted an "intentional act of violence." The court concluded that it was open to a jury to find that such an act caused the death in the course of an armed robbery, even if it was not the sole cause. The court emphasized that the intentional nature of the act, rather than the specific intent to cause death, was the crucial element under Section 12A.

Ultimately, the court ruled that the accused were guilty of manslaughter, as the jury found that while the accused committed an intentional act of violence, they did not intend to cause the death of the victim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established