R v MARTIN (No 4)
[1999] SASC 161
Criminal
Debelle J
This is an application for a permanent stay of an information on the ground that it is an abuse of the process of the court.
The applicant is charged with the murder of his father. Although there have been four trials, it must be noted that the first of those trials was aborted at a very early stage. At the first trial the accused had been put in charge of the jury and the prosecutor had opened. Before any witness was called, a juror informed the court that a prosecution witness was known to him and the jury was discharged. A fresh jury was empanelled that afternoon. The accused has been tried on three subsequent occasions and on each occasion has been found guilty by a jury. He has appealed against each of the verdicts and each of his appeals has succeeded. On each occasion a retrial was ordered. The Director of Public Prosecutions intends to proceed with the fourth trial. That decision has prompted this application for a permanent stay of the information.
In each trial it has not been disputed that somebody had entered the home of the victim, pointed a shotgun at the back of his head, and shot him at close range. The victim was probably asleep when he was shot. The issue at each trial was whether it was the applicant who had shot the victim.
A central feature of the prosecution case against the applicant was that the victim was killed between 4 o’clock and 7 o’clock in the morning of Friday 16 December 1994. The prosecution conceded that, had the murder not occurred between those times, it would have been impossible for the applicant to have committed it. The applicant has an innocent explanation for his whereabouts at all other relevant times.
Another critical feature of the prosecution case was evidence that the applicant had confessed to the crime to a Ms F. The alleged confession was made at a nightclub at which the applicant worked and was made on the evening of Saturday 17 December. At that time the victim had not been discovered. He was discovered at about 10.30am on Sunday 18 December. Ms F had gone to the nightclub with a friend, Ms Bligh. Ms F said that, while she and the applicant were alone together for a short time, the applicant had said that he had killed his father with a shotgun. She said that she did not then know whether to believe the applicant. Ms F and Ms Bligh left the nightclub with a male friend called Schloite. Ms F learned of the discovery of the victim from a television news broadcast on the Sunday. The next day she went to the police. It was the prosecution case that Ms F’s knowledge that a shotgun had been used could only have been gained from the applicant. Although Ms F had seen the television news broadcast on Sunday…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Martin (No 4) No. Sccrm-95-206 Judgment No. S161 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 161
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several arguments presented by the applicant’s counsel. Firstly, it was argued that the witness Ms F, having testified multiple times, would now be a well-rehearsed witness, potentially disadvantaging the applicant. However, the court noted that this situation arises in every retrial and is not a valid reason for a permanent stay. Secondly, the misconduct of the prosecution in the third trial was cited, but the court held that the power to stay proceedings was not to punish prosecutorial misconduct but to prevent unfair trials. Lastly, the extensive media coverage and previous trials were argued to prejudice the applicant’s right to a fair trial. While acknowledging the potential for prejudice, the court believed that appropriate jury directions and the right to challenge for cause would mitigate any prejudicial effects.
After weighing all factors, including the seriousness of the crime, the repeated failures to secure a conviction, and the community’s interest in the resolution of the case, the court concluded that a fourth trial would not violate fundamental principles of justice or cause such unfairness as to warrant a permanent stay. Consequently, the application for a permanent stay was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi