R v Mantzoudis No. Scgrg-97-898 Judgment No. S7011

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

R v MANTZOUDIS
[1998] SASC S7011

Court of Criminal Appeal:  Prior, Lander and Wicks JJ

  1. PRIOR J.           The appellant was convicted by a jury of one count of false pretences.  Particulars of the offence found proved were that between 18 and 21 December 1995 at Renmark he obtained from one Andrew Eleftheriades $4,800 by falsely pretending he had authority from Beaurepaires Pty Ltd to receive the money as payment for truck tyres.

  2. The appellant was first arraigned in the District Court in November 1997.  A number of directions hearings occurred early in 1998.  His trial commenced on 7 October 1998.  The delay in his trial was due to the appellant’s failure to secure legal representation.  In no less than six directions hearings the court was told that the appellant had financial difficulties.  An application for legal aid funding in both Victoria and South Australia had been rejected.  At the directions hearings the appellant sought an extension of time for the commencement of his trial so that he could raise sufficient funds to pay for his representation.  At the sixth directions hearing on 19 August 1998 a trial date was fixed for 14 September 1998.  The appellant was then told that he would be expected to be ready to proceed to trial on that date.  The trial did not proceed on that date.  The matter was the subject of a further directions hearing on 9 September when a judge fixed a trial date for 7 October given listing and funding difficulties with respect to the September trial date.  On 7 October 1998 counsel appeared for the appellant to inform the court that the appellant had failed to secure funding for his defence.  He was seeking an adjournment to enable him to sell a motor vehicle.  The court was also told that besides putting the vehicle on the market some two weeks before the appellant had been negotiating with those who had put up his bail to allow him to apply those funds towards his legal defence.  They had not agreed to this.  The application for the adjournment was opposed.  Witnesses had come from distant parts to give evidence.  The notes of previous directions hearings were said to indicate that the appellant had not been truthful with the court.

  3. The trial judge refused the application for adjournment telling the appellant that he could either proceed to represent himself or apply to have the proceedings stayed on the ground that he could not get a fair trial without representation.  The trial judge gave the appellant time to discuss those options with his former counsel.  After a short adjournment, counsel indicated that he thought he could not participate in any application for a stay.  Counsel also indicated that if the matter were to proceed counsel were willing to advise the appellant of certain procedural matters so that he had an idea of what he might face if the trial were to proceed.

  4. The appellant told the trial judge he did not believe that he…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Mantzoudis No. Scgrg-97-898 Judgment No. S7011 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] SASC 7011
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Mantzoudis, appealed against his conviction of one count of false pretences by the jury in the District Court. The particulars of the offence found proved were that between 18 and 21 December 1995 at Renmark, the appellant obtained $4,800 from Andrew Eleftheriades by falsely pretending he had authority from Beaurepaires Pty Ltd to receive the money as payment for truck tyres. The appellant argued that the trial should not have proceeded and that the trial judge erred in refusing to grant him an adjournment to secure legal representation. The Court of Criminal Appeal held that the circumstances disclosed that the appellant had more than a reasonable opportunity to obtain legal representation and that the appellant could not complain of the refusal to adjourn since it was due to his own failure to take timely and appropriate measures to obtain legal representation. The Court also held that the trial judge made a deliberate attempt to avoid any hint of the appellant being known to the police in any adverse way by inviting him to admit that the photograph contained in a group of 12 shown to the three witnesses was a photograph of him. The photograph did not convey for itself that the appellant was from a rogues’ gallery strongly suggesting to the jury that the appellant had a criminal record. The Court found no miscarriage of justice resulted from the appellant’s lack of representation and any omissions by the trial judge in the course of the trial and his summing up. The appeal was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant was convicted of one count of false pretences. The offence occurred between 18 and 21 December 1995 at Renmark, where the appellant falsely pretended he had authority from Beaurepaires Pty Ltd to receive $4,800 from Andrew Eleftheriades as payment for truck tyres. The prosecution's case was that the appellant and an accomplice, Kypri, made false representations to Eleftheriades that they had authority from Beaurepaires to sell tyres on their behalf. Eleftheriades agreed to purchase 24 tyres for $4,800. On the day after the telephone call, a man claiming to be Steve Costas went to the Beaurepaires store in Renmark and inquired about the price of truck tyres. The appellant, along with two Beaurepaires employees, later arrived at Eleftheriades' property where the tyres were delivered. The appellant asked for payment, and Eleftheriades paid $4,800 in cash. After payment, the appellant disappeared. The three individuals involved in the incident selected a photograph of the appellant from a photo board on three separate occasions.

The appellant was first arraigned in the District Court in November 1997. Several directions hearings occurred in early 1998, with the appellant seeking extensions for securing legal representation. The trial was initially set for 14 September 1998 but was later rescheduled for 7 October 1998. On the trial date, the appellant sought an adjournment to secure legal representation but was denied. The appellant proceeded with the trial but elected not to call any evidence. The appeal against the conviction was heard by the Court of Criminal Appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PRIOR J LANDER J WICKS J
Issues
1. Whether the trial should not have proceeded and the trial judge erred in refusing to grant the appellant’s application for adjournment to secure legal representation.
2. Whether the trial judge erred in failing to inform the appellant of his ability to challenge the admissibility of the photo identification of him.
3. Whether the trial judge should have directed an acquittal as a matter of law.
4. Whether the trial judge misdirected the jury with respect to the appellant’s failure to give evidence.

Held
1. The appeal against the refusal to adjourn the trial and the trial proceeding without the appellant's legal representation was dismissed. The court found that the appellant had ample opportunity to secure legal representation and the refusal to adjourn was not a miscarriage of justice.
2. The trial judge did not err in failing to inform the appellant of his ability to challenge the admissibility of the photo identification. The photographic identification was conducted fairly and the trial judge's approach avoided any suggestion that the appellant was known to the police.
3. The trial judge did not err in failing to direct an acquittal as a matter of law. The directions given to the jury regarding the benefit element of the offence were adequate and properly reflected the prosecution's burden of proof.
4. The trial judge's direction to the jury regarding the appellant's failure to give evidence was not a serious error. The jury was already focusing on the appellant's statement to police, and the omission did not result in a miscarriage of justice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PRIOR J, LANDER J, WICKS J

The Court of Criminal Appeal considered the appellant's appeal against his conviction for false pretences. The appeal was based on several grounds, including the refusal to adjourn the trial, the admissibility of photo identification evidence, the adequacy of the trial judge's directions to the jury, and the trial judge's summing up regarding the appellant's failure to give evidence. The court found that the appellant's failure to secure legal representation in a timely manner justified the refusal to adjourn the trial. With respect to the photo identification, the court held that the identification process was fair and the photograph did not suggest the appellant was known to the police, making the evidence admissible. The court found the trial judge's directions to the jury on the benefit element of the offence and the accomplice evidence to be adequate, despite minor objections. Finally, the court concluded that the trial judge's summing up on the appellant's failure to give evidence, while not ideal, did not result in a miscarriage of justice. The ratio decidendi of this decision lies in the proper application of procedural fairness in criminal trials, the admissibility of photo identification evidence when conducted fairly, and the adequacy of trial directions in ensuring a fair trial.